Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 51 by Fantasy Fantasy

Do they tell you?

They want to “experiment and explore”.

“So… we talked this morning.” Emily begins. “I told Megan what I did with you.”

“So in turn I told Emily what I did with you.” Megan continues, her face flushed.

“We were both… well, shocked, really. But in the end we just laughed at the fact we both ended up falling for the same guy.” Emily chuckles.

You always thought you did a good job cleaning your ears, but it seems you have to redouble your efforts because you can’t possibly have heard that right.

“W-What?”

“We told each other everything,” Megan says. “From how good your kiss felt, to how you… used your fingers on me,” She clears her throat in embarrassment but pushes through it. “I even told her how… I’m in love with her.” She blushes as she looks at Emily with an embarrassed smile.

“I told her how I was really curious about all of this, and how I wanted to… explore this side to relationships.” Emily says, returning Megan’s smile. “And eventually, after a little… exploration of our own, the topic came back to you. She told me she really likes you and… to be honest, I think I really like you too.” She squeezes your hand and her grip tightens.

“So we decided that, if you were okay with it…” Megan takes a deep breath. “We’d like to try something.”

“What kind of… something.” Your whole body’s going numb, but your heart is beating dangerously fast. This kind of situation can’t be healthy.

“We want the three of us to go out together. You and me, you and Emily… Emily and I.” Megan says, her voice becoming softer as she speaks.

“We both want to go out with you, we want to go out with each other and… it seems you at least have feelings for us, too?” Emily asks in the most **** voice you’ve ever heard from her.

You hear Megan swallow, and now that they’ve explained everything, their smiles are replaced with nervous, expectant looks as they wait for your response.

It takes every fiber of your very being, every ounce of willpower, every last drop of self-restraint to not answer with a big “YES” in this very instant. The reason? You have a girlfriend whom you really, honestly love. What’s more, it wouldn’t do for Emily and Megan to find out about that right now. Therefore, you will talk about this with Emma first, and you have a feeling that conversation will go well enough. At least, you hope the trait you gave her will stack things in your favor.

“I… I do. I have feelings for you girls. Very, very strong feelings.” You admit. “But please, give me some time to think. Just a day will be enough.”

Emily gives you an incredulous look, as if asking “What is there to think about?”

You answer. “Let’s just say I’m not thinking with my brain right now.” That causes Megan to giggle and Emily to pull away slightly, though she doesn’t release your hand.

“I see. Well, it’s really a lot to take in, isn’t it?” Emily chuckles. “And you do have a lot on your mind right now. Sorry, I guess I was a little impatient.”

“Though that’s nothing new, just so you know. She’s always impatient.” Megan tells you with a grin. “Still, let us prove that we’re serious about this.”

“Uh… H-How?” You nervously ask.

Megan takes a deep breath and looks at you resolutely. “Let us… make you feel good.” She whispers. It seems your dick heard that too because it is already hardening in anticipation.

With shock clear in your face, you glance from Megan to Emily, who purses her lips, but nods, and then back to Megan, who awaits for your answer.

You swallow hard, your lips part you can only hear yourself uttering the word “Okay”. You know you shouldn’t be accepting this right now, but again, it’s not your head that’s doing the thinking.

Relief is clear in the faces of the two best friends, but there’s also a bit of anxiety. They’ve promised to do something they’ve never done before. You completely understand how they feel, considering your own first experience.

“Do you mind if we kiss first?” Megan asks, and you answer by freeing your arms from the girls and wrapping them around their narrow waists, pulling them closer to you.

“Someone’s excited.” Emily giggles, repositioning herself so she has a good angle on your face.

“Yeah, me!” Megan replies and dives straight towards your lips, shoving her tongue inside. You both moan loudly into the other’s mouth. Megan is like and animal who hasn’t eaten in days. She devours your mouth and you return it with equal passion, still holding tightly onto both athletes. After a minute or so, Megan breaks the kiss. “Your turn, Em.”

You’re both breathing hard, but you look to Emily. Her face is flushed, but she licks her lips, giving you a few moments to breathe, until she slowly closes in. Her kiss is deep, yet tender. She’s going slowly, letting her tongue savor every corner of your mouth. The change of pace catches you off guard, but you quickly adapt, returning the kiss eagerly.

You spend about 10 minutes making out with these gorgeous soccer stars, relishing in the physical contact and the emotional support it provides. After what’s undoubtedly been your worst day at Hayes Academy, Emily and Megan come and make everything better.

“How do you do it?” Megan asks as she watches you make out with Emily. “I could kiss you all day. It feels so good.” She licks her lips. Emily agrees, moaning into your mouth. It seems the Great Kisser trait is paying off, and more than you thought.

The brunette leaves your embrace and kneels in front of you, unbuckling your belt and unzipping your pants. When Emily notices this, she hastily breaks the kiss and goes down to join her friend.

“Don’t you dare start without me!” She tells Megan.

“I wasn’t going to.”

You take a deep breath and look down at the two gorgeous girls kneeling right in front of your crotch. To think things would turn like this. You can’t help but feel pretty uneasy about it, but your lust is reaching critical levels. Your mind is no longer capable of saying no.

Megan pulls down your pants while Emily pulls your boxers. Their eyes widen in shock when they lay eyes on your massive cock, fully erect and twitching in anticipation.

“Oh my God!” They exclaim in unison. “They tell you in Sex Ed. To not expect guys to be porn-star sized, but…” Megan mutters to herself and you see Emily swallow hard. They look up at your face and you can only give them a sheepish smile.

In one of those silent conversations that only teenage best friends have, they nod towards each other and you hear Emily quietly count “1, 2, 3!”

Both girls lick the sides of your shaft. It’s a hard lick that goes from the base to the tip, sending a strong shock through your whole body. You shiver as you hear the girls giggling. It doesn’t last long as they quickly go back in. They lick and kiss your huge cock, and they do it sloppily. Honestly, neither of these girls can hold a candle to Emma, but holy fuck does this make your mind go crazy. The fact that this is their first blowjob, that they’re two best friends that are doing it together, that they offered it to prove how serious they are to be with you. It’s not about technique, but the feelings behind every little kiss, every lick that makes you tremble in pleasure.

You throw you head back and groan as they keep going, slowly but surely syncing up. You feel the warmth and wetness of Megan’s mouth around your cockhead. Her tongue swirls around it and Emily keeps savoring your length. They sometimes get in each other’s way, but are quick to fix their angles and start again. This goes on for about 15 minutes, every second you can feel them getting the hang of it a little more.

It happens when they switch to have Emily take you in her mouth. The sensations and feelings overwhelm you. You give a quick warning, and though Emily hears it, as noted by her eyes meeting yours, she does not heed it. She stays there like a champ as you ejaculate in her mouth.

Megan can’t help but look a little disappointed, but that expression fades when Emily presses her lips against hers. The brunette is the first one to open her mouth, and Emily uses her tongue to share with her the reward for their efforts. It’s as if these longtime friends and confidants are reaffirming their bond by sharing a passionate, and extremely hot cum kiss. They giggle after they swallow every last drop, erotically licking their lips.

“That was really fun!” Megan says with an excited smile from ear to ear.

“And I always thought it’d taste a lot worse,” The blonde licks her lips again. “But it’s actually not that bad.”

As if your strength had left you, you fall back on the bed and lay there with an arm over your forehead. “Girls… that was… just… Wow…” You add eloquently, earning you a chuckle from your friends.

“We’ll leave you with that for now. We have work to do tomorrow, so there’s no time for awkwardness, okay?” Emily tells you firmly.

“Good night, David. Sleep well, okay?” Megan leans over you and sweetly kisses your cheek. It would be a very innocent move if your dick wasn’t hanging there for them to see. Emily mimics her and both girls say goodbye.

You can’t help but wonder how they even agreed to propose something like this. You take out your phone and look up their scores.

-Grant, Megan-
Affection Score: 82.
Love Score: 75.
Lust Score: 72.

-Miller, Emily-
Affection Score: 73.
Love Score: 52.
Lust Score: 76.

How on earth did Emily make such a big jump in scores? Last time you saw, she held no romantic feelings for you. Now she’s at 52? Was is a combination of the Sex is Love trait with the kiss and the blowjob? Maybe even things you said? And Megan. Oh boy Megan!

With Emily’s new scores, your points are now like this:

170 Friendship points / 300 Love points / 115 Lust points

Do something else or go to sleep?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)