Have Paige join her mother

The tension has been building in your cock ever since you arrived at the house, and you can't bear to let it go on for much longer without release. Besides, this is too perfect of a set-up, and you would never forgive yourself for letting an opportunity like this pass you by... "Actually, Paige, before we go I want to fuck you and your mom side-by-side, so I can see what I have to look forward to with you in the future."

Paige's eyes widen in surprise, and she lets out a small gasp. A split second of panic flashes through you like a lightning bolt at her reaction, as you're momentarily convinced you've gone too far and horribly offended her. Your worry is dispelled a moment later as Paige presses one hand to her cum-stained blouse and exclaims with a blush, "Oh, John, that's so sweet! You're already thinking about the long term with me?" She's clearly touched by your consideration, and happily takes up her position on the couch next to her mother. Paige hikes up her blouse so your view of her flawless ass is unobstructed as she bends over the back of the couch.

You pull your fingers out of Sophie's dripping vagina and unzip your pants, letting your cock spring out as hard as it's ever been. Even from behind, the family resemblance between Paige and her mother is clear. They both have the same pale skin, slim frames, and delicate pink pussy lips and assholes. Sophie's asscheeks are fuller, and the thighs framing her puffy pussy are a bit thicker, but it's the healthy curvaceousness of a mature woman who clearly takes good care of her body. If Paige ages as gracefully as her mother has, she's going to be a knockout for decades to come.

You stroke your cock a few times while looking at the two women presenting themselves to you, trying to decide how to choose from so many appealing options. After a moment's consideration you decide to start with Sophie's pussy, since she's still extremely wet and that will help lubricate your cock for whichever hole you choose to try out next.

With one hand on Sophie's hip to steady her, you rub the head of your cock up and down her pussy lips a few times to coat it well with her wetness. She hums in pleasure at the sensation, and reaches back with both hands to spread her asscheeks apart for better access. Her vagina gapes open a bit as she does so, giving you the perfect target to shove your cock into, and you don't waste a moment in doing so. Sophie lets out a pleased "Ooh!" as you sink into her wet cunt all the way up to the hilt in one stroke. You remain still for a moment, savoring the incredible feeling of Sophie's pussy. She's so warm! Her vagina grips you pleasantly all along your length, not quite as tightly as Paige's cunt did earlier, but it's no less pleasurable. You pull back and begin thrusting into her soft MILF pussy rhythmically, balls slapping against her inner thighs as you fuck her in earnest. Sophie squeezes her vagina around you with each thrust in perfect practiced timing, and you can tell you won't last long inside a woman of her sexual expertise. After only a minute or two you reluctantly pull out, not wanting to finish before you get a chance to compare Paige to her mother.

It only takes a step to the side to position you behind Paige's waiting ass. Unlike her mother, whose pussy is still spread open wetly after you pulled out of her, Paige's fresh pink slit remains closed even though she's kneeling with her knees apart. You reach down and gently part her delicate pussy lips, and she lets out a soft sigh of anticipation as you open her up. Your cock is thoroughly lubricated in her mother's wetness, but even so you're careful to go slow as you push yourself into Paige's inexperienced cunt. You bottom out with her asscheeks against your crotch, slowly withdraw, and then push your cock in again. She's tighter than her mother, and the walls of her vagina aren't quite as velvety soft, which makes for an interesting contrast of sensations. You gradually pick up the pace as she grows accustomed to the feeling of your cock filling her up, and she begins shoving her hips back towards you with each thrust as you fall into the rhythm together.

As wonderful as Paige's pussy is, you're really looking forward to testing out her asshole as well. Her delicate pink ring beckons you as you continue to pump her pussy, and you begin to lose yourself in the flow of sensations as your pace continues to quicken. Eventually your last shred of self-control is overcome by the rising passion, and after the next downstroke you pull out of her pussy and sink the head of your cock into her virginal asshole in one smooth thrust.

Paige lets out a surprised yelp of pain at the sudden intrusion in her rear hole, which shocks you out of your sex-drunk reverie and back into reality. Paige's father even pokes his head out of the kitchen at the sound of her shriek, but quickly loses interest when he sees it's just you anally violating his daughter. Still, you cringe inwardly at your own thoughtlessness. "Sorry, Paige, I guess I got caught up in the moment," you say sheepishly.

Paige pants for a moment, but shakes her head. "N-no, it's fine of course," she says somewhat shakily. "I am a big-breasted whore, after all. You're free to use my cumdump of a body however you want. It just surprised me." She lets out a slow breath and visibly tries to relax, resuming her previous position after having reflexively flinched away.

Sophie reaches over and rubs Paige's shoulder affectionately. "Look at my good little girl, being such an accommodating slut," she says with obvious maternal pride.

Paige grins at her mother and replies, "Of course, mom. You always set such a good example for me, offering your holes to anyone who wants them." She looks back at you and says, "Go ahead and fuck my asshole as hard as you want, John. Don't worry about hurting me, this is what I'm for."

Even with her reassurances, you don't want to hurt your new girlfriend, even if it's something she wouldn't think twice about later. You gradually start to push your cock deeper into her ass, slowly rocking your hips back and forth as her anus stretches open to admit you little by little. Paige smiles softly back at you, pleased by your gentleness despite her permission to be rough with her. She lays her upper body down on the back of the couch and closes her eyes, breathing in a slow and regular pattern to relax herself further. Even so, her asshole is still extremely tight, and the feeling of the taut ring of her sphincter sliding back and forth around your cock is absolutely mindblowing. You can feel the stiffness building inside you as you approach climax, and even with all the sex you've been having today already you can tell it's going to be a powerful one.