More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 3 by MonsterInNeed MonsterInNeed

What curious soul gets the display case, and how is it obtained?

Alex and Jenna, Finding a Magic Box in their Parent's Attic

The attic was thick with dust and nostalgia, a testament to the many years my stepsister, Jenna, and I had spent growing up under the same roof. I, Alex, was the quintessential nerd – glasses perched on my nose, a shirt that was just a tad too tight over my not-so-impressive physique, and a penchant for comic books that Jenna never let me live down. She was rifling through a box of our old toys, her short, tomboyish hair falling into her eyes as she laughed at a particularly embarrassing action figure she'd unearthed.

"Remember when you thought you could talk to aliens with this thing?" Jenna teased, holding up a makeshift communicator I had crafted out of a broken walkie-talkie and some tinfoil. Her laughter was infectious, but it resonated with a different frequency in the pit of my stomach. She was attractive in a way that was subtle yet undeniable, her shirt clinging to the large breasts that I tried, and failed, not to notice. The attraction I felt towards her was like a persistent hum in the background of our interactions, something I'd learned to live with, knowing full well it was one-sided.

Jenna's teasing continued, her wit as sharp as ever, but her eyes were kind. As she bent over to pick up another long-forgotten relic of our past, I caught a glimpse of her cleavage, and I felt a familiar warmth spread through me. It was an unspoken truth, this attraction I harbored, and as much as I wished to act on it, I respected the boundaries of our relationship. She was my stepsister, after all, and I was just plain, nerdy Alex – nothing more.

Jenna's eyes sparkled with mischief as she recounted the time I had tried to build a rocket from soda bottles. "You were always the dreamer, Alex. Remember when you said you'd fly to the moon before you turned twenty?" Her laughter was light, but it cut through me when she casually shifted the topic. "Speaking of dreams, Derek is talking about backpacking through Europe. Can you imagine?"

I mustered a smile, the sting of her words masked by a practiced indifference. "Sounds exciting, Jenna. You always wanted to travel." I busied myself with a stack of old comic books, my mind racing with the images of her in far-off places, without me.

As she continued, Jenna stumbled upon a peculiar, large empty box that seemed out of place amidst the clutter. The design was unassuming, but as she touched it, a sharp zap of static made her recoil. "Ouch! Damn, that hurt," Jenna exclaimed, shaking her hand and inspecting it for any real harm. But then her eyes widened in disbelief, and she pointed at the front of the box, "Alex, look at this!"

I leaned in closer, and there it was – a picture of Jenna, so current she was wearing the same outfit as today, with the attic's wooden beams and cluttered memories in the background. The image was uncannily accurate, down to the way her hair fell across her forehead. "That's… impossible," I murmured, my own curiosity piqued and a sense of unease creeping up my spine. "How could that picture be here?"

Jenna's expression was a mix of fascination and fear, "I have no idea, but it's freaking me out. This has to be some kind of prank, right?" Her voice trembled slightly, betraying her composed exterior, and she looked to me for some semblance of an explanation.

Jenna and I circled the box cautiously as if it were some alien artifact that had crash-landed in our midst. I ran my fingers over the smooth surface, half-expecting another jolt of static or some hidden button to reveal its secrets. "Could be some kind of Polaroid tech?" I proposed, though the idea sounded flimsy even to my own ears.

Jenna shook her head, her brow furrowed in concentration, "But there's no lens, no shutter, nothing. And look at this," she pointed to the photo, "it's just plastered on here, like a sticker. The box is perfectly empty, Alex. No camera, no tech. Just… this picture."

We exchanged uneasy glances, the thrill of the mystery now giving way to a creeping sense of unease. The attic, once a place of fond memories and laughter, felt suddenly oppressive, the shadows around us appearing to dance with malevolent intent. "I don't like this," Jenna murmured, her voice barely above a whisper, "Let's just go watch a movie or something."

Nodding in agreement to cut our attic session short, I helped Jenna gather her things. In her hand, she had the old teddy bear she'd been toting around, a relic from when we were kids. With a nonchalant shrug, she tossed it into the box. The sound it made as it landed was strangely muffled, as if the bear had plunged into something much deeper than the box appeared.

The noise sent a shiver down my spine, and I couldn't help but voice my discomfort. "That sounded… weird, didn't it?" I asked, peering into the box once more, half expecting the teddy bear to have vanished into thin air.

The teddy bear lay innocently at the bottom of the box, its button eyes gazing upward as if nothing was amiss. "Did sound kind of funny, didn't it?" Jenna's voice suddenly took on a childlike lilt, soft and gentle, as if she were speaking through the mouth of a tiny, playful child. "Like a poofy cloud hug," she added with a giggle.

When I glanced up at her, confusion etched across my face, the sight before me was beyond comprehension. Jenna's clothes had shrunk to mere patches of fabric, reminiscent of a stuffed animal's attire, and her skin… it was covered in a fine layer of brown fur. Even her ears had taken on the rounded, soft shape of a bear's. Yet, it was undeniably Jenna, her eyes wide with the same spark of life, though now framed by this bewildering transformation.

I stumbled backward, my heart racing as I nearly toppled over an old lamp. Jenna, still oblivious to her altered state, gasped and moved towards me with concern etched in her furry features. "Oh no! Are you alright? Did you get a boo-boo? Do you need a hug?" Her voice was filled with the innocent concern of a child comforting another.

As she extended her furry arms to help me up, realization dawned in her eyes. She froze, suddenly aware of her transformation, her mouth agape in silent horror. Yet, even in her fear, she retained that quiet, childish manner, as if she were a scared little girl lost in a costume far too real.

"Oh my goodness gracious!" Jenna's voice was still coated with the syrupy tones of a cartoon character soothing a child. "What in the world is happening? This is so strange, but don't worry, we'll figure it out together, okay?" Her words were incongruous, as well as the tone she used, but they underscored an awareness of the bizarre situation.

She pointed a furry finger at the teddy bear resting inside the box. "Maybe, just maybe, when I put Mr. Cuddles in the box, it turned me into a big, cuddly bear too," Jenna hypothesized, her voice a soft coo. I stood there, dumbfounded, unable to reconcile the surreal scene with reality.

With a shared sense of purpose, we leaned over the box, and I carefully plucked the teddy bear from its depths. As I did, I gasped. Before my eyes, Jenna's fur receded, her ears shrank back to their human shape, and her clothes returned to their original size. In mere seconds, she was back to the Jenna I knew, her skin free of fur and her body no longer a caricature of her childhood toy.

She frantically inspected herself, running her hands over her arms and torso, and finally, let out a long, relieved sigh. "I'm me again! That was… unbelievably weird." Her voice was now her own, the childlike overtones completely gone, replaced by the familiar timbre of her normal speech, though tinted with relief.

Jenna and I stood there, our eyes locked on the enigmatic box, the air thick with disbelief. "That was real, right?" I asked, my voice barely above a whisper, **** for some validation that we hadn't collectively lost our minds.

She nodded slowly, her gaze not leaving the box. "It linked to me, I think… when I touched it. And then, it turned me into… into that." Her hand gestured towards the teddy bear, now resting on the dusty floor, her voice a mix of wonder and revulsion. "It's like it's making me a human version of whatever's inside…"

The silence that followed was heavy with possibilities. I broke it with a hesitant suggestion, "Should we… try it with something else? You know, just to see." My curiosity was piqued, the scientist in me eager to understand, even as I recognized the potential danger.

Jenna bit her lip, her **** clear. "I don't know, Alex. That was scary. But…" She trailed off, her eyes betraying the same curiosity that gnawed at me.

"How did it feel? When you… changed?" I asked, my voice tinged with a mix of fear and fascination.

Jenna paused, her brows knitting together as she recalled the experience. "Honestly, it didn't feel like anything special. It was as if it was the most natural thing in the world," she confessed, her eyes distant. "When I realized what happened, I knew it wasn't normal, but it felt… normal. Like that was who I was supposed to be."

"That's crazy," I muttered, trying to wrap my head around the concept.

She continued, a thoughtful look on her face. "I felt calmer, more… nurturing. When you almost fell, I wanted to hug you, to make sure you were okay. It was like this overwhelming need to take care of you, to provide comfort."

"That makes sense," I said, the realization dawning on me. "That's exactly what a teddy bear is for, right? To comfort and be there for someone." I couldn't help but wonder what would happen with another object, another purpose. The implications were both thrilling and terrifying.

Jenna's eyes glinted with a mix of trepidation and excitement as she finally nodded. "Okay, let's do it. But I'm choosing what goes in the box," she declared with newfound resolve. "And Alex, promise me—if anything weird happens, you'll take it out immediately. I don't want to be stuck forever as some kind of absurd version of myself."

I nodded earnestly, understanding the gravity of the situation. "I promise, Jenna. The second things go south, I'll empty the box," I assured her, my heart racing with the uncertainty of what was to come.

Jenna's gaze flitted across the attic, her mind racing with possibilities. She picked up a worn-out dictionary, musing aloud, "What if this makes me super smart?" Then her hand hovered over a sleek fitness tracker, "Or this could turn me into a fitness guru." But with each hypothesis, the potential for unforeseen consequences seemed to grow.

After much deliberation, she settled on a small, solar-powered calculator, a tool for accuracy and efficiency. "Let's try this," she said, her voice threaded with nerves and anticipation. "I mean, who knows? It could make me better at my job, speed up my work."

I couldn't help but interject, a cautious edge to my words, "Jenna, maybe we shouldn't mess with this too much. We don't know what it's capable of." My warning hung in the air, underscored by the shared thumping of our hearts—an erratic soundtrack to our surreal adventure.

She glanced at me, a wild spark in her eyes. "This has to be some crazy dream, right?" Jenna half-laughed, the sound tinged with disbelief. "Like we're going to wake up any second now."

"Yeah, one hell of a dream," I agreed, the reality of our situation feeling more and more like a bizarre fantasy with each passing moment.

What do They Try First?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)