Super Set

“We’re just getting started, Maddy.” You assure Maddy, before parting her knees and spreading her legs as wide as possible. Her pussy lips gape open from the **** you spread her legs, and her gaping hole even twitches as you put weight on her thighs to lay them flat on Becca’s gym floor.

Maddy’s feeling the same rush you are too, as she can’t help but spread her pussy lips even wider with her fingers, showing more of her pink center for you. Despite this, you can see just how small and tight her hole still is, and how inexperienced her pussy is to being penetrated. So you remind yourself, despite how horny you are, to go slow and gentle with Maddy.

You move your hips and direct the tip of your cock directly at her entrance, and Maddy immediately closes her eyes and bites her lower lip in anticipation. You penetrate her tight gaping hole slowly, already feeling the wetness that’s coating her labia before pushing it in further. Maddy immediately moans breathily as she takes in the head of your cock, but stops you from pushing further with her hands.

“Wait, Mr. Craig.” Maddy tells you breathily. “It already feels so big inside me.” She adds, unintentionally stroking your ego. You give her an understanding smile, and begin to do quick pumps in and out of her with just your cockhead. Maddy lets out quick breathy moans as you pump in and out of her, and even you can’t help but moan along as this much is already enough to stimulate all the right nerves of your cock.

“The energy of youth.” You hear Becca comment from beside you and Maddy, still sounding exhausted and recovering from her orgasm.

“So you don’t want to go another round?” Brooke asks from the other side, sounding equally exhausted.

“Not what I said.” Becca replies. “I’m just impressed with Maddy’s speed of recovery, is all.” Becca explains.

“Jay’s not bad at the energy department either.” Brooke comments, shifting the flattery towards you.

“Thank you, magic.” You jokingly chime in, as you continue to pump in and out of Maddy.

“Aww~, don’t I get some credit for all the workouts we’ve been doing?” Brooke teases you, as she moves to lay next to Maddy on her side and propping her head up with her hand.

“I still don’t look like Stone Cold Steve Austin circa 1996, so~... No.” You tease back, and Maddy instinctively closes her legs around your hips to remind you not to stop fucking her, as you took a brief pause to tease Brooke back.

“~Stop. I’m already wet.” Brooke jokes back with a laugh after hearing your rebuttal. “Is Stone Cold really your fitness inspo?” Brooke then asks.

“The more realistic one, at least. Chad told me it’s almost impossible to look like Tyler Durden from Fight Club.” You tell her, which elicits another laughing fit.

“Yeah~, that’s a bit too lean for you. What do you think of Shawn Michaels though? I kinda imagine your fitness endgame like that. Especially with your hairier chest. I can already see you posing for Playgirl with just a title belt hiding your cock right now.” Brooke asks, before starting to fantasize about what you could look like after consistently working out with her.

“Isn’t Shawn Michaels on the lean side too?” You ask.

“HA! Lean in comparison to the roid monsters of his era, you mean. But I think he’s a perfect fitness inspo for you.” Brooke argues. “What do you think, Becca?” Brooke then asks.

“The only name I recognized in that entire conversation was Chad’s.” Becca bluntly replies, getting you and Brooke to laugh, and forcing Maddy to give you another pull with her legs to not stop with your consistent pace. She may not be doing it intentionally, but she pulled you in deeper into her pussy this time, and she’s not showing any discomfort.

“I was just asking what kind of body you think Jay should aspire to have after consistently working out with us.” Brooke clarifies her question to Becca.

“I don’t put much weight on physical looks. Whatever he finds to be his most attractive self, and as long as he's healthy, is enough for me.” Becca answers honestly.

“You’re no fun.” Brooke jokingly responds in faux disappointment. “What about you, Maddy?” Brooke asks her nonchalantly, as if she’s not currently busy getting fucked.

“I think you’re perfect just the way you are, Mr. Craig!” Maddy answers, but she says it while looking straight at you.

“Thanks, Maddy.” You reply, staring into her eyes as you do.

“You’re both no fun. No fun at all!” Brooke says again, but clearly joking as she’s chuckling when she does.

“It’s not my fault I’m already a stud muffin.” You joke back, before flexing your biceps and puffing your chest out like Shawn Michaels would during his entrances as you continue to pump your hips to fuck Maddy, making Brooke laugh.

“Vivian’s sense of humor is rubbing off on you.” Becca comments teasingly.

“I’m pretty sure it’s Maddy that’s rubbing me off.” You joke back, getting a wince out of Brooke and a teasing smirk out of Becca.

“Thank you for proving my point.” Becca jokes back.

Meanwhile, in a different part of Becca’s apartment…

“AGH!” Viv winces in pain, after accidentally biting her tongue.

“You know you can explain this stuff a lot slower, right? It’s not like we’re riveted.” Stella tells her sarcastically.

“I felt a disturbance in the ****.” Viv tells her ominously.

“What?” Cassie asks in confusion.

“Nothing.” Viv tells them as she waves her hands across her face to signal she’s resetting the conversation. “Where was I?” Viv asks them.

“You were telling them about the Monday Night Wars, V.” Tanya reminds her.

“Oh! Right! So…”

Back at Becca’s home gym…

“I’ve sufficiently recovered, and this conversation no longer entertains me.” Becca suddenly comments, as she sits up and gets on her knees.

“Wow. Thanks for being blunt about it.” Brooke sarcastically replies.

“You’re welcome.” Becca replies just as sarcastically, but you see her give Brooke a wink to show she’s only teasing. Becca shows her true intentions of stopping the fun banter Brooke had going, as she mounts Maddy with her back towards you, before bending forward, raising her ass up, and spreading her cheeks to show you her own gaping pink center.

“Take your pick… Daddy.” Becca teases, as she looks back at you from her position.

“No! Focus on me, Mr. Craig! AAAH!” Maddy immediately shouts, as she forcefully pulls your entire cock’s length into her, causing her to let out a groan of both pleasure and surprise as she seems to climax just from taking in your entire length.

“Someone doesn’t like to share.” Brooke teases.

“Yes. It seems Madeleine is a greedy little slut, isn’t she?” Becca adds to tease Maddy as well.

“I’m not a slut!” Maddy shouts defensively, misunderstanding Becca’s dirty talk. “I only want Mr. Craig, and I meant what I said when I don’t want this to end!” Maddy adds passionately, while keeping your hips locked onto her with her legs and not allowing you to even threaten taking your cock out from inside her.

“Now, now, Madeleine. Learn to share. I haven’t had his cock inside me yet.” Becca points out in a calm and collected voice.

“Sorry.” Maddy apologizes with a meek voice. “I just… this feels amazing! I just want Mr. Craig to focus on me. Can you wait? Please?” Maddy pleads with Becca, trying to sound as cute as possible under her current circumstances. Becca seems to take it in stride and just lets out an amused chuckle.

“I can.” Becca answers her, and you feel Maddy’s legs loosen up a little after hearing Becca’s answer. “But who Jay decides to fuck is his decision. Daddy’s in control.” Becca tells her, before giving her a peck on the lips just to show how Maddy's pleas had no effect on her… but they did have an effect on you.

“Maybe you should’ve begged like Maddy.” You whisper into Becca’s ear after bending forward to get closer. “Now you will have to wait.” You add, before pulling Maddy in through her hips, while pushing your cock into her as deep as you can.

“I don’t beg.” Becca tells you defiantly, which is counter to what you experienced with her just a couple of nights ago. She does beg… if you tease her enough.

“Then maybe I won't give you what you want.” You tell her teasingly.

“You won’t be able to resist me for long. You’ll crave for me soon enough.” She replies confidently.

“We’ll see about that.” Brooke surprisingly replies for you as she stands up from the floor.

Brooke then effortlessly picks up Becca by the armpits like a baby, forcing her to stand over Maddy. Brooke then turns around, and mounts Maddy just like Becca did earlier, and similarly with her back towards you and Becca. She then slides her butt across Maddy’s upper body, with her pussy directly in front of Maddy, while her head is now below Becca’s pussy, and just above Maddy’s crotch where you’re continuing to pound into Maddy.

“Let’s see how much he’ll crave for you if he can just choose to fuck my face and cum in my mouth instead.” Brooke openly antagonizes Becca now.

“He won’t be able to use that tongue if it’s busy.” Becca quickly thinks of a comeback, and you see Brooke give a toothy grin that you can only imagine Becca’s mirroring, right before Becca lower her pussy into Brooke’s awaiting mouth.

“Don’t be greedy, Becca.” You whisper into Becca’s ear, while she’s leaning her back on your chest. “Don’t forget to return the favor.” You add, before pushing her to bend forward and basically sixty-nine with Brooke, while you fuck Maddy below them. Becca doesn’t seem to find your forcefulness off putting, as you immediately hear a muffled moan from Brooke a few seconds later.

The four of you continue in this pornographic jenga of a position until the room being filled with noises other than moans and wet squelches of bodily fluids is but a distant memory. The concern over Maddy being unable to handle the combined weight of Brooke and Becca on top of her dissipated quickly, since Brooke has her crotch raised for Becca, while Becca’s squatting over Brooke’s face to not put their full weight on Maddy who’s below them.

“OH GOD!” Maddy shouts as her lower body convulses beneath you, spraying her orgasmic fluids everywhere, and most definitely coating Brooke’s hair with most of it.

“Fuck me, Jay!” Becca shouts commandingly, her voice labored as Brooke continues to eat her out. You decide to tease Becca like Brooke suggested earlier and instead slide the length of your cock along Becca’s clit with Brooke’s tongue licking your under shaft.

“Stop with this teasing and put your cock inside me!” Becca shouts more desperately.

“You’re gonna have to beg, Becca.” Brooke says, almost indecipherable with her tongue out as she speaks.

“Nnnggghh~” Becca tries to resist the urge of begging, as you continue to slide your cock across her clit.

…

…

“FINE! PLEASE FUCK ME, DADDY!” Becca finally shouts in desperation, and Brooke can’t help but laugh beneath her. You don’t tease Becca further and immediately penetrate her sopping wet pussy with your equally sopping wet cock, and it easily slides right in balls deep without resistance.

“YES!” Becca shouts in intense pleasure, orgasming almost immediately after you start pounding her pussy intensely. It seems the build-up from Brooke’s oral and your teasing of her clit from earlier has gotten her extremely close.

“Didn’t know you were a squirter like Maddy, Becca.” Brooke comments, as you continue to use Becca’s pussy to reach your own climax.

“OH FUCK! That feels awesome, you two!” Brooke then shouts in pleasure, after Becca and Maddy joined forces with their tongues to bring her to climax as well.

“Don’t stop! I’m getting cl-UGHK!” Brooke continues to encourage them, but her last word gets choked up as you direct your cock into her mouth so you can fuck her face. It doesn’t take long before you can feel your own climax nearing thanks to Brooke’s lack of a gag reflex.

You decide to take your cock out of Brooke’s mouth and stroke your cock until you spray Brooke’s already fluid coated face with your own fluids, which she enthusiastically takes with her mouth open and tongue sticking out.

As soon as your last drop of cum splatters on Brooke’s face, you fall flat on your butt in exhaustion, as the pile of bodies in front of you seem equally as exhausted as you are. Except the upside down smiling face of Brooke that looks like she’s been put through the ringer with her wet hair and cum covered face.

“Is this going to be how we spend every night now?”