Misunderstandings and Manipulations

“I am NOT okay with this!” Courtney shouts to you and Brooke.

The three of you are in the Master’s bedroom. You and Brooke are sitting down on the bed while Courtney is standing in front of you, almost like a parent scolding her children.

How the three of you got here is very similar to how Courtney and Chad got here in the first place. While you and Courtney were shouting at each other about how much you both cared for Brooke enough not to do something as stupid as fucking each other, especially doing it the day after you and her are finally officially dating; Chad and Brooke had a much more silent talk in the hallway just outside of the spa room.

A few minutes ago…

“I am. I’m okay with it now.” Brooke reveals to you and Courtney.

“You’re fucking joking!” Courtney audibly reacts before you could, since your jaw is pretty busy still hanging open. You look at Brooke in confusion, since the whole point of this charade was to only get Chad’s points to increase, so you’re not sure if she’s only saying that to get Chad’s points to increase, or if she’s actually serious.

“I’m not, Court. I’m being serious.” Brooke informs both of you with all sincerity.

“Chad and I talked while you guys were arguing. It seems like the only reason you guys are in this mess is because you both want to do something for Chad for your own reasons; and the only reason you guys are against it is because of me. The two of us realized that that’s unfair to both of you and we wanted to give you guys your autonomy back.” Brooke points out, and you and Courtney can’t help but look at them guiltily for inadvertently guilting them with your shouting match.

“I’m okay if you do this with Jay, Court.” Brooke assures both of you. “Especially now that I know you’re not just doing it so you can lord it over me.” Brooke adds, giving Courtney a really genuine smile of affection.

“Oh~, believe me, bitch. I’m going to lord this over you when he starts asking Chad to keep fucking me, and he starts forgetting about you.” Courtney replies smugly, trying to turn Brooke off from the idea.

“Never gonna happen.” You immediately chime in to assure Brooke.

*TAP!!*

“Oof!” You grunt again after Courtney forcefully taps your crotch with the back of her hand, even getting Brooke to audibly shout her name in reprimand.

“Not helping our argument against fucking each other, doofus.” Courtney points out. “Also, I have feelings too, dipshit. Jesus Christ! At least pretend I’m even a little bit fuckable.” Courtney then adds, making you realize how adamant you’ve been about not wanting to fuck her too.

“That would be a lot worse for our argument not to fuck each other too… stupid.” You counter argue, adding the insult at the last possible moment so you can guard your crotch if ever Courtney has another violent reaction.

“Babe! Jay finds you super fuckable! He told me—” Chad starts saying excitedly before pausing since he gets surprised by another sudden action from Courtney.

*SLAP*

“COURT!!” Brooke reacts violently, after Courtney slaps you in the face again.

“That was for calling me stupid.” Courtney nonchalantly informs you, before asking Chad to continue, “You were saying?”

Chad still looks shocked that Courtney just slapped you in the face, but you just motion for him to continue with your free hand, as the other is rubbing your cheek from Courtney’s slap. Just having been slapped, you completely forgot what it actually was that Chad was saying, and immediately regret asking him to say it again.

“Oh! J-bro thinks you’re actually super hot! He said so when I showed him your photo before our date!” Chad tells Courtney excitedly, completely getting over his concern for you getting slapped by her.

“Oh~ whoopie. I’m so horny for him now.” Courtney sarcastically replies; and to no one’s surprise, Chad missed it entirely.

“OH! OH! That means you guys are going to do it!” Chad reacts.

“What part of what I said made you think that!?” Courtney asks him in frustration.

“You said you were horny for him. Jay thinks you’re hot too. Brooke’s okay if you guys do it. You guys want to help me with my ‘thing’. What’s stopping you guys from doing it?” Chad coherently… and most surprisingly, logically points out in his own Chad way; taking you and Courtney by surprise to be honest. You’ve only ever heard him be like that when he’s talking about workouts. You guess getting cucked makes him use more brain cells.

‘You sound like Courtney now.’ you suddenly realize, making you mentally slap yourself to stop thinking like that.

“Okay! Good! So it’s settled!” Chad declares, his enthusiasm undeniable. Apparently, he took everybody’s silence as a lack of argument to his point.

“Tell me all about it tonight, babe!” Chad then tells Courtney, before giving her a tight loving hug and a kiss on the forehead.

“Anyway, I’m gonna go before you guys change your mind! Have fun you guys!” Chad declares as he walks away from the three of you, forcing Courtney to leave the spa room to chase after him. You and Brooke shrug at each other and follow suit.

“Where the fuck are you going?” Courtney shouts at Chad, getting him to turn around.

“Oh! You said you don’t like it when I watch, and since we can’t do what we need to do here…” Chad starts saying, before covering his mouth to one side to look like he’s telling a secret, “Since fucking me here would be super disrespectful to J-bro… “ Chad tells her in a not so quiet whisper, “I’m going to the gym so you guys can do your thing.” Chad informs her, which leaves Courtney stunned once more, and her mouth just hanging open in shock.

“Thanks for being so cool with this, you two!” Chad points to you and Brooke, waving goodbye as he does. Brooke seems to not be bothered by this development at all and waves back at Chad to say goodbye, who promptly turns around to leave the suite.

Chad stops mid-walk to turn around to address Courtney again. “Remember every last detail, babe! I’m sure J-bro will blow your mind if he can satisfy multiple women. I’m so excited for tonight!” Chad exclaims, before really walking away this time.

Courtney’s jaw is practically on the floor with how this whole thing has progressed so suddenly. She turns around to look at you, and practically tells you to run after Chad and tell him this isn’t happening. Brooke seems to notice this too, and gives you an entirely different signal.

Brooke takes your hand and holds it, squeezing it to signal to you that you don’t need to bother stopping Chad.

“Come on, Jay. Let’s take this to the bedroom.” Brooke tells you, before leading you back to the other end of the suite. You go along with Brooke, and it seems she’s heading to the master’s bedroom, before she pauses and calls out to Courtney.

“Are you coming or not?” Brooke asks her, before walking away with you again.

“OH YOU MANIPULATIVE SONS-A-BITCHES!” Courtney shouts exasperated.

Back at the present…

“What kind of magical cock does this loser have that you’re willing to risk your self-esteem to get me to fuck him?” Courtney asks Brooke.

“You heard what he said, this is as much a chore for him as it is for you.” Brooke calmly replies.

“Oh~! Hearing that makes me so fucking wet!” Courtney sarcastically replies. “Chad’s going to love hearing that while I jerk him off.” Courtney then adds, while doing the jerkoff motion with her hand, before splooshing it on you and Brooke with exaggerated grunts.

“I just meant I know he’s not doing it just because he’s horny, or he just wants to get his dick wet.” Brooke rephrases her wording.

“Right~, because it’ll be a lot easier for him to just get one of those two sluts that even suggested this to wet it for him.” Courtney says, faking like she heard an epiphany. “Quick question, dummy. HOW DO YOU THINK HE EXPANDS HIS LITTLE GROUP OF GIRLFRIENDS, HUH!?” Courtney asks in a shout.

“Unintentionally and with a lot of support and encouragement from his girlfriends.” Brooke answers her, still in her calm demeanor. The answer doesn’t really appease Courtney much.

“That sounds exactly like what’s happening right now, don’t you think?” Courtney points out.

“Oh? So you’re going to fall in love with my boyfriend now, Court?” Brooke teasingly asks her.

“In your dreams.” Courtney replies back.

“Then this isn’t exactly like what I described, is it?” Brooke asks back, getting Courtney to pause for an argument again, giving you a chance to jump in.

“Courtney, I’m honestly still not comfortable with this. So if you say no, then we don’t do it. Simple as that.” You assure her.

“Are you deaf!? I have been saying no!” Courtney shouts at you.

“Then why are you still here, Court?” Brooke asks her, not even pretending she doesn’t know the answer yet.

“Did you see how excited he was? Like a fucking puppy! I can’t say ‘No’ now!” Courtney halfheartedly justifies.

“Wait… that can’t be the only reason.” You suddenly realize. “Why are you really doing this, Courtney? It can’t just be because Chad gave you puppy dog eyes.” You argue.

“Oh, Love Coach.” Brooke teasingly reacts to your question. “Isn’t it obvious?” Brooke asks you, turning her head towards Courtney again to give her a happy smile. “She finally found a good one.” Brooke explains. “Like I did with you.” Brooke adds, before taking her hand to stroke your cheek.

“Where’s the toilet? I need to barf.” Courtney sarcastically reacts.

“This room has a private one.” Brooke answers before pointing towards it.

“You should get changed if we’re doing this.” Brooke adds, to yours and Courtney’s surprise.

“We?” Courtney repeats the offending word that caused the shock and confusion.

“Yeah. What did you think was going to happen?” Brooke asks nonchalantly.

“I’m not Chad.” Brooke adds.

“You two ain’t cucking me.”