Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 18 by Cheesers123 Cheesers123

What two slips do you draw?

Nicole and Miranda

You manage to snag two slips at once and bring them up to your eyes to read. Nicole and Miranda. A few moments earlier it would have been your dream pairing. A ménage-a-trois seemed like a good way to make them settle their differences or get your dick ripped in half. Either way, it would have been very entertaining for at least a little while. However, such a lewd suggestion might have turned their animosity on to you. This is all a moot point now, however, your dick in the state it’s in isn’t up to fucking one girl, let alone two. Even if they were both exemplars of cuteness and beauty respectively.

Thinking of your flaccid member you’re struck by a bolt of inspiration. "Nicole and Miranda." You announce, throwing their names back as you feel them both sit up to attention beside you. "How about you both get me hard?" As soon as you say it you regret it, the both of them go diving for your cock like a dropped bouquet at a wedding. "Wait!" You stop them, their clawing fingers only inches from your weak skin. "I'm not done." You pause, trying to come up with a stipulation that will prevent them fighting over your dick too violently. "You can only use your. . ." Your mouth hangs open as you try to think of what to say.

". . . Mouths." You decide, figuring lips and tongues would cause less damage than fists and nails. Slowly, like gunslingers holstering their weapons, the girls both put their hands behind their backs. Sitting back on the couch you watch as they both slowly slide off the couch to kneel on the floor before you, their eyes flitting quickly from your dick, to each other, and back again.

Nicole starts by leaning in slowly and giving your dick a shy peck before glancing awkwardly up at you. Miranda follows that up with a much more certain lick, her tongue trailing lewdly along your shaft, ending with a confident smile directed at you. With that, they’re off. Not to be outdone Nicole starts lapping at your shaft too while Miranda peppers the other side with smooches of her own. The rivalry between them eggs them both on to do more and more, eagerly trying to win your attention by lavishing your cock with their mouths.

When you start to re harden they both go to take their tip between their lips and start properly sucking your dick. Miranda’s confidence allows her to get their first, leaving Nicole’s lips relegated to kissing your shaft. She does it dutifully though, planting innocent kisses up and down your length as sweetly as if she were kissing your lips. Meanwhile Miranda gently suckles on the tip of your cock, her lips barely moving a few centimeters up and down as she commits to the delicate act of resuscitating your cock. As time goes on Nicole finds herself with less and less dick to worship as Miranda works her way down your shaft, her wet mouth engulfing your dick while her tongue flicks against it’s underside.

All this sensation combined with how sexy the pair of them look on their knees for you means it doesn't take long for your dick to start to recover. With every heartbeat it bobs slightly in Miranda's mouth, regaining a little of it's girth and imperceptibly stretching her lips more and more. Seeing that what she's doing is working Miranda starts to take in more of your recuperating dick. Of course it's not just what Miranda's doing that's making you hard, Nicole's innocent looks and naïve kisses are helping too, but Miranda would never acknowledge her contribution. As far as she's concerned she's the main event and Nicole is a sideshow at best and a nuisance at worst. Taking all your dick where it rightfully belongs, lodged deep in her throat, should remind you who you should be attracted to and remind Nicole of her place. Below Miranda

Pretty soon Nicole is left with little but your balls and the base of your shaft, the tip of your regrowing cock now tickling Miranda’s tonsils. Even with most of your semi-hard dick in your mouth Miranda still finds time to look up at you, giving you sultry bedroom eyes that make you want to buck your hips and fuck her perfect face. Nicole is giving you eyes too, pitiful puppy dog ones as she licks your balls almost like she was asking you to make Miranda share your dick. Before you can decide if intervening would be a good idea or just a way to embarrass Nicole further she decides to use her head.

Rather than using it to bash Miranda out of the way, like some primeval dinosaurs mating display, she instead uses it to think. With her arms still behind her back she gets to her feet and kneels on the couch next to you, her lips coming up to your ear. Instead of saying anything instead she brings her mouth to your earlobe, nibbling it gently before releasing it with a sigh. "I should have known you liked my mouth John." She whispers, her words dripping with lust. "When I whispered to you before you looked like you were going to lose your mind." It had felt like it too, although Sarah's soft tits pumping up and down your cock might have also had something to do with it. With that brief bit of foreshadowing Nicole picks up almost from where she left off before, her soft lips ready to drizzle honey in your ear.

"You're such a bad man John. I can't believe you wanted me to act like a slut for you." Nicole purrs into your ear, her voice almost breaking into laughter a couple of times. "Do you really think about touching my butt? Or grabbing my breasts? Or putting your big dick in my..." Nicole's words trail off as she glances down to your dick again, now mostly concealed in Miranda's mouth. Taking a deep breath to recompose herself Nicole continues. "So, if I was a slut how would you fuck me John? Have you thought about it? Tom already fucked my mouth but I want you to be the first to fuck my . . . My pussy!" The word burst from her lips like she was **** to say it, moaning it into your ear like you were already fucking her.

Taking her face in your hands you turn and kiss her hard, her little gasp of shock being drowned out as she kisses you back. After making out for a few seconds you release Nicole's face and slide one hand down neck, marveling at how soft and fragile it feels under your fingers. The sound of your and Nicole's lips smacking mixes with the noises from Miranda's continued blowjob that makes you groan into your friend's mouth. Eventually Nicole breaks the kiss, a crazed look in her eyes as she leans to your ear again.

"Why didn’t you tell me you were a fucking pervert who wanted to fuck his best friend earlier John?" Her voice is high and wild, she’s barely able to restrain her volume as whatever madness has possessed her compels her to talk. "We wasted so much time just being friends when we could have been friends with benefits." Her words come in a torrent, flooding from her lips like a dam has burst in her brain. "When did Nicole get such a dirty mouth?" You wonder. "Has she always been like this, her demure looks a façade for the filthy slut beneath?" You think about all the walks in the park and trips to the beach you've shared, if you'd asked her then could you have fucked her in the sand dunes or behind the bushes instead of sharing a picnic? "Nevermind the tittyfucking I mentioned, the next time we’re hanging out and you get an erection, I don’t want you to ask permission, I don’t want you to even warn me, I just want you to tear my clothes off and use my body to relieve yourself. To make up for lost time I want you to bounce me on your big cock like I’m your own personal fucktoy." It seems Nicole's mind is moving in the same wild places as your own.

You kiss her even harder this time, your grip on her shoulder tightening thoughtlessly. You’d grab her and spear her on your cock right now, if it wasn’t for the fact it was still in Miranda's mouth. When Nicole had started her dirty talk you’d felt your crush gag as your cock enhardened a little and surged down her throat before she was able to pull herself away, then as Nicole continued talking you’d felt Miranda's lips trying to chase your dick as it throbbed and grew. At one point while she was still trying to kiss the sides of your shaft your pretty sure your dick had smacked hard against her face. Despite all that, despite your crushes perfect pouty lips pampering your prick, most of your attention is on locking lips with Nicole.

Only when your dick is undeniably at full mast again does Miranda pull her slutty mouth away from it and recall your attention. “Wow Nicole you must be a dick whisperer! That thing nearly took my head off a couple times.” She giggles, only for her laughter to abruptly stop when she sees you and Nicole both ignoring her to make out. With her hands still behind her back Nicole lays her body against yours as her lips lock with your own. "Okay Nicole, John's already hard, that'll do." Miranda says, sounding jealous as she gets back to her feet. Nicole ignores her at first, instead choosing to keep her eyes closed and her lips joined to yours. It's only when she feels two hands grasp her wrists that her eyes flit open and your lips sadly part.

Your mind races as she's pulled away. She was just saying all that to complete her dare, right? She’s always been competitive and she just wanted to prove to Miranda that she can still get you hard even if she can’t put her mouth on your dick. This must all be part of the game still. If it wasn't part of the game though then you definitely want to be more than friends, then your eyes catch Miranda's and you start thinking about how jealous she looks. "How about you go grab a name to dare sweety." Miranda dismisses Nicole with a wave of her hand, stepping past her and towards you. "I've got to put a finishing touch on this dare." Suddenly she leaps up and straddles your hips with your hard dick trapped between your bodies, smearing precum and spit up her smooth flat stomach. Your cock lifts her skirt to reveal her bare and wet pussy. Her short neat patch of brown pubic hair tickles the underside of your dick while that sopping pussy is positioned to drool on your balls. “Let me show you what else my mouth can do.” Before you can say anything she captures your lips with her own, her body pressed against yours and her hands brushing up your chest to your shoulders.

Breaking the kiss she glances down to your cock rising halfway up her stomach. “Oh look at that, I’m such a silly ditz getting myself in a position like this. You could stuff that big hard dick of yours inside me and there’s nothing anyone could do to stop you." As she speaks she gyrates her hips slightly and squeezes your shoulders even harder. "I wouldn’t do anything to stop you." She purrs that last sentence into your ear while her hands on your shoulders begin leveraging her body slowly upward so her pussy glides wetly up the underside of your cock. Before her eager opening can line up with your tip small hands grasp her biceps from behind. “You’re right Miranda, dare’s done. But I think you should draw a name.” Nicole says tersely as she pulls Miranda off of you like she was a misbehaving dog. She shoots you a disapproving glance over your crushes shoulder too but you're to in shock to do anything but raise your hands in a placatory gesture.

Miranda turns to face the girl who just pulled her to her feet, towering over Nicole and meeting the shorter girls look of defiance with an annoyed glare. "How about you just draw, I feel like I need a sit down." Miranda tells her before leaning back like she was going to fall into your lap, the pale curve of her ass cheeks peeking out from beneath her skirt like they were about to fall perfectly around your cock. Miranda's fall is only stopped by Nicole grabbing your crushes wrists and planting her feet firmly. "I think I've given a lot of dares tonight, how about you give one?" Nicole replies, **** to keep your crush away from your cock. "John read your name first, that means it's your turn." Miranda fires back, trying to sit on your lap again.

"Goddamn, how about you both draw a name and give a dare." Tom sighs, frustrated at his own current lack of a girl as well as this delay to the game. The girls both look at him before slowly turning to face each other. Their eyes meet for a pregnant moment until they both seem to relent and Nicole finally releases Miranda's wrists. Wordlessly they both go to the hat and begin shuffling around it for a name without lifting it from the table.

Taking a moment to yourself to breathe you cannot believe the night you're having. Your crush is begging you to fuck her, what the hell are you hesitating for? Looking at her perfect ass wiggling in the air as she plays with the hat you think about doing just that, taking her by the hips and fucking her bent double in front of everyone. It’s only Nicole's little butt beside it that gives you pause. You really don't think she's just playing around anymore, but do you want to give up on your dream girl you've chased for years to sully your friendship with Nicole? If only you had two dicks this wouldn't be a problem, you could fuck the pair of them while they put their differences aside and sloppily made out with each other. "If only it were so simple." You think with a sigh as you settle back into your seat. A moment later the pair of them straighten up from the hat with a single slip of paper held between them, one of them holding one corner whilst the other holds the opposite.

What have Miranda and Nicole drawn?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)