Tom

"Tom." The girls announce his name as one before returning his name to the hat and turning to face him. He's clearly happy to be the center of attention again as he smiles smugly and spreads his legs wide, showing off his own fat cock that's at least as big as yours. Turning to face each other again Miranda and Nicole begin whispering to each other in irritated tones. "How about you go over there and-" "Maybe you should suck-" "Why don't you let him fuck-" You can only catch the occasional sentence fragment but you don't like what you hear. It seems they're both trying to get rid of their competitor using Tom, and even though you want their bickering to cease you don’t really want it to be to Tom’s benefit. Their whispering continues on for a little while longer before eventually ending with “Deal?”, “Deal.” Although what kind of deal isn’t yet clear to you.

"Alright Tom," Nicole begins, not looking him in the eyes as she speaks "we dare you to make us cum." Her words make you feel like you drank a dozen shots at once, you’re so confused that you stop breathing for a few seconds. You're not sure about Miranda but you know Nicole hates Tom, you have no idea why she'd agree to any deal that involved this. "Whoever cums first is the loser," Miranda continues where Nicole left off, "and they have to sit next to you for the rest of the night."

"Sounds more like they’re the winner to me, I make their legs shake and then they get a front row seat to the show." You hate that Tom is referring to himself as “the show” almost as much as you hate this dare. You can’t believe that their petty jealousy has driven the pair of them to be this stupid, especially Nicole. You can scarcely believe that she'd subject herself to that asshole's sexual ministrations just to try and thin out her competition to get to you. "Alright, so I guess Nicole and I can sit over there and-" Miranda begins, gesturing to the space on the couch beside Tom, only to be cut off as he gets up.

"I have an idea." He cuts her off, taking an unexpected step towards her. He takes both girls by the wrists and, while they're still too stunned to fight back, he pulls them over to the arm of the couch. "You, bend over here." He takes Miranda and easily manhandles her into position, manipulating her body like a doll. He positions her bent over the arm rest with her elbows resting on the seat cushion, her tight booty and wet little pussy raised in the air. "This is how I fucked the Anders sisters." He explains, stepping behind Miranda so his big dick comes ominously close to her slick pussy. "W-wait, you're not just fucking me!" Miranda protests, covering her pussy with one hand as she does. "Why not?" Tom asks, prodding that protective hand with his prick.

"The dare said I had to make you cum, you didn't say how." He prods her again as he speaks, like he might use his hard dick like a battering ram and **** Miranda's hand aside. "Nicole, tell him that's part of the rules." Miranda pleads to her erstwhile enemy, looking up at her with wide eyes. Nicole seems to deliberate for a lengthy few seconds, like she was really considering just letting Tom fuck Miranda, but eventually her morality or her internal girl code wins out. "No. You can't just fuck her." Miranda visibly relaxes at Nicole's words, her hand retreating from her **** area. "You can still rub your dick against her though." Nicole adds, making Miranda's eyes go wide again as Tom does just that, slapping his hard erection up against her tender pussy.

"Alright, now Nicole, you get in position." He turns toward her and beckons her closer with one hand. "What’s my position?" Nicole sounds like she’s scared to know the answer as she takes a hesitant step closer, looking at how Miranda ended up. "Put your hands on Miranda's shoulders." Cautiously Nicole does just that, bending over Miranda as she does. "Now, give me those legs."

Tom suddenly stoops down to lift Nicole at the waist, practically throwing her over his shoulder as he hoists her into the air. Her eyes go wide as she suddenly takes off, her hands grasping tightly to Miranda's shoulders as she yelps in shock. Reaching up with his other hand he takes her right leg and throws it over his head so that her thighs rest on his shoulders with her pussy less than an inch from his face. With her hands still gripping on to Miranda's shoulders for dear life there’s nothing Nicole can do to cover herself as her wet fuckhole is presented to Tom. She's too surprised to speak coherently and instead she stutters in indignation at the bold move. Tom is so tall that even with Nicole's arms stretched out straight to Miranda's shoulders she’s still at a slight forward facing downward angle, the only thing keeping her from slipping off is Tom's strong grip on her waist.

You're dumbstruck by this unnecessarily lewd position that Tom has put your crush and your best friend in. It looks like a scene straight out of a porn video and if it wasn't for that earlier discussion you'd think Tom was actually fucking your crush. Miranda is bent over the couch with her weight resting on her elbows with Tom pressed right in behind her, whilst Nicole bridges the two, doing almost a pushup with her hands on Miranda's shoulders and her thighs on Tom's. "No way you fucked the Anders girls like this." Sarah chimes in, somehow unsurprised by the pornographic position but only questioning the legitimacy of it's heritage.

The Anders girls were a set of four (admittedly hot) sisters who became local celebrities after pictures of their O-faces, allegedly taking mid public-fucking, surfaced online. "I fucked two of them. Or fucked one and ate the other if you want to get technical." Tom scratches his head with the hand that was on Miranda's hip, reaching around Nicole's leg to do it . "You know those girls are sluts, you heard how they fucked their way through that frat on the beach on spring break." When Tom says that Sarah wrinkles her nose, sitting forward on Matt's lap. "I'm still not sure I buy that whole story," she says, "if there was a sex frat filled with hung guys I'm sure I would have heard about it before." Matt looks uncomfortable behind Sarah, even though he's currently enjoying the benefits of being hung around Sarah.

"Maybe they keep it from you because they know if you found out they'd have to spend their weekends just fucking you nonstop." Matt's face looks even angrier when Tom says that. "Anyway, can I get on with my dare? Nicole might be scrawny but that doesn't mean I can hold her like this forever." The word "scrawny" makes Nicole glance over her shoulder in irritation but she says nothing, seemingly still too embarrassed by her position to speak. "It's not my dare." Sarah replies. "Ask the girls if you can start."

"Alright girls, ready to see stars?" Tom asks, pulling them both back against him. They roll their eyes as one, both in near disbelief that they're about to let Tom do this. "Yes." They reply in humiliated unison. Tom doesn't need any more encouragement. He opens his mouth and runs his tongue languidly like a dog over Nicole's wet pussy, making her thighs tense around his head as she lets out an unintended squeak. At the same time he begins sawing his hard dick against Miranda's slit, parting her slick folds with one hand as he does. Miranda lets out an involuntary noise too and you see her hands tightly squeeze the cushion she's resting on.

You almost can't believe what you're seeing. Nicole and your crush are both being pleasured by Tom and the worst part is that they asked him to do it. Their motive for asking him might have been some petty power play but that doesn't make watching them squirm and moan for him feel any better. From your seat across the room you get an unremittingly clear view of the three of them in profile, the two naked girls pressed closely to Tom. Nicole's cute features are scrunched in concentration and, even though you can only see half her face, you can tell that both her cheeks are the same deep pink. Miranda's face is a similar color (although perhaps not as pink as Nicole) with a lock of loose brown hair trailing across her face even as her eyelids flutter and she bites down hard on her bottom lip.

You're spared from the sight of Tom's face as he devours Nicole's virgin pussy by her thighs that surround his head like earmuffs, twitching occasionally in pleasure. The sound of him practically making out with her pussy is still audible though, mingling unpleasantly with the girls restrained sounds of pleasure. The room is silent besides the three of them, making it impossible to ignore the girls little moans and exclamations when Tom finds and exploits a tender spot of their bodies. Another giveaway for when Tom touches their clit or g-spot is how their eyes flash wider for a moment and their pretty faces are painted with shock before they can control themselves. Maybe they had both underestimated Tom and hadn’t expected this to feel so good.

Despite Tom’s clear skill in making them squirm the dare drags on for one agonizing minute after another, made to feel even longer by the gnawing pit of dread in your stomach from having to watch. You know from experience how stubborn Nicole can be and it seems Miranda has a will to match, both of them proving unwilling to give in to Tom’s ministrations. Tom, for his part, doesn’t seem to mind the girls resistance. Instead he seems to relish lavishing Nicole, a girl who always hated him, with his tongue and teasing Miranda, a girl who always rebuffed him, with his cock. Their wetness soaking his shaft and dripping down his chin is proof enough that what he’s doing is working and it’s only a matter of time until one of them climaxes.

Looking at it going on and on you start to really think about who’s most likely to win. You would say that Nicole is probably in the worse position due to being on the receiving end of a mouth and tongue, which can be a lot more dexterous than a dick and some fingers, but due to the size difference she has to be on top. With that said Miranda doesn't seem to be having an easy time either, Tom's dick or his fingers having found a weak point that makes her smile despite herself. With her hair a little messy, her eyes half closed, and the corners of her lips upturned into a smile she looks so sexy that you can almost forget who's making her look that way.

The girls become less restrained as the dare continues. Their moans become louder, their faces redder, the little quivers that chased through their bodies become unmissable trembles. You see Miranda subconsciously arching her back for Tom whilst Nicole's toes curl behind his head, clear signs that Tom is making them feel good even as they try to hide it from him, and each other. Although you can't see it Tom has now focused his attention on to toying with their clits. Reaching around Miranda's body he parts her wet folds with two fingers to get access to her precious pearl, pushing aside her clitoral hood to caress it directly. The gush of her pussy on to his hard cock that still pushes against her serves as proof that it's working.

For Nicole he sucks on her sensitive nub with his lips, circles it with his tongue, and even nibbles ever so gently on it with his teeth, making the petite blonde haired girl go cross eyed as she kneads Miranda's shoulders like a masseuse. Her legs squeeze tightly around his head, either trying to hold him back or pull him in. To get at her clit from behind his face is almost buried in her pussy, and he occasionally has to come up for air and give Nicole a moment of respite. It's during one of these air breaks that Tom pulls Nicole's firm ass cheek to one side to spit on her tight asshole. Nicole's whole body jerks and she squeaks again just like she did when Tom started licking her. Your little friend blushes even deeper and you can tell that asshole is smiling as he ravages her clit with renewed vigor.

It's been almost 5 minutes now. Matt and Sarah whisper amongst themselves as they stare at the trio while you can only watch in silence. The girls defenses seem to be almost completely eroded by now. Miranda can barely hide it anymore, her every exhalation sounding like an exclamation of pleasure. Above her Nicole seems to be holding on more stoically, or at least as stoically as she can with her clit being lashed by a skilled tongue.

Still, her façade seems to fall apart as her mouth falls open.