New Fetish New Year, Pt. 1

“What’re your New Year’s Resolutions?” Maddy asks all of you, as you all lounge in Becca’s kitchen; eating snacks, while hanging out, and enjoying each other’s company.

Like most of your final days from last year, most of your first day of this New Year was spent fucking. As much as you enjoy that part of your relationship with your girlfriends, you enjoy these moments of down time just as much. The girls decided to take a much needed break, and enjoy the amenities of Becca’s luxurious apartment.

You all exercised in Becca’s private gym together, spent some time helping each other cook for today’s lunch, and took a dip to relax in Becca’s heated pool. It’s almost as if all of you went on a free staycation just by staying over at Becca’s.

“I haven’t thought about mine yet, actually. I usually have the one, and last year was the first time I actually accomplished it.” Viv answers Maddy.

“Which was?” Stella asks her.

“Exercise.” Brooke jokingly answers, but Viv confirms it to Brooke’s surprise. “Wait, so your physique before going to my gym was just built on diet?” Brooke asks her in shock, and Viv nonchalantly confirms that too.

“What’s so shocking about that? I have a higher standard for food. I’m like that skinny guy from Ratatouille. If I don’t like what I’m eating, I don’t swallow.” Viv answers seriously, paraphrasing the quote from Ratatouille.

“There’s a cum joke there somewhere.” Stella says with a chuckle.

“What’s the joke? Jay’s cum is delicious. I can say it.” Viv jokes, to the laughter of Stella. You can’t help but rub the back of your neck at that one.

“You should really try it sometime.” Viv suggests to you. The immediate repulsion on your face gets her and Stella laughing much louder, to the amusement of your other girlfriends.

“That should be Dad’s New Year’s resolution! Try to enjoy felching.” Stella continues the joke.

“What’s felching?” Maddy asks.

“It’s when someone eats the cum out of someone’s pussy.” Stella answers.

“Consuming the creampie, so to speak.” Viv adds.

“Sucking the oyster out of its shell.” Stella continues.

“A hummingbird—” Viv was about to add until Cassie interrupts her.

“I think Maddy got it.” Cassie stops them in their tracks.

“Now that I think about it, that’s not a bad New Year’s resolution.” Tanya shares, to your shock. “I meant trying out new kinks! Not the felching thing.” Tanya immediately clarifies, upon seeing your look of horror.

“OH! Let’s do that! I’ve always wanted my own kink!” Maddy exclaims in agreement.

“Don’t you already have a kink?” Becca asks her.

“I do?” Maddy asks.

“Based on our shared time together, you don’t like stopping until you’re exhausted.” Becca answers.

“Or you’ve had multiple orgasms.” Viv points out as well.

“Or Jay’s the one that taps out.” Brooke piles on.

“Basically, a nympho. You’re a nympho, Maddy.” Stella puts it bluntly.

“You’re one to talk.” Cassie teases Stella.

“Exactly! We’re all incredibly horny for Dad and we—” Stella starts saying, but Cassie finishes her sentence for her.

“We recognize Maddy has a higher sex drive than all of us.” Cassie finishes Stella’s point.

“Combined.” Viv jokes.

The combined teasing from all your girlfriends has made Maddy quite red in the face in embarrassment, so Brooke and Tanya giver her a comforting hug that she has nothing to be ashamed about.

“I’m always game to try new things with you, Maddy.” You assure her too, which she gives you a smile of appreciation in return.

“It’s the New Year, right? Do you guys not want to try new stuff too?” Maddy asks the rest of your girlfriends.

“What are you suggesting?” Brooke asks her.

“I don’t know. I guess… maybe we could try swapping our kinks? I’ve always been curious about being submissive like V or cucking one of you like Cassie does with Stella. Anal’s something I’ve wanted to try too.” Maddy shares.

“Spoken like a true nymph— OW!” Stella was about to joke, but Cassie playfully pokes her in the ribs to stop her from teasing Maddy.

“I’m game. Fucking Jay with a ball gag on while Becca was watching was kinda hot. I wouldn’t mind being a sub again.” Cassie supports Maddy’s idea.

“So we just pick the kinks we want to do?” Stella asks.

“I’m not particularly interested in other kinks, to be quite honest. It’ll be hard for me to choose too.” Becca tells the group.

“Yeah. I’ve never thought about it either. I’m happy with being vanilla. I’m still game to try something new though, don’t get me wrong.” Brooke shares as well.

“We can just spin a virtual wheel so it’s random.” Maddy suggests, and everyone seems to agree on how it should be done.

“What are the choices? No one can swap with Brooke since she likes the vanilla stuff. Plus, I think we can’t swap with you either.” Cassie asks.

“You can’t swap mine either since all of you are on birth control except for Brooke.” Stella points out.

“You have another kink, sweetie.” Tanya reminds her.

“So cucking, being cucked, being a domme, being a sub, and anal.” Viv lists down the kinks some of your girlfriends have enjoyed during their time with you.

“That makes five. We need another two kinks for each of us to swap.” Stella says.

“Uh~” You start to say something, but hesitate. It’s enough to get your girlfriends to look at you though. “I was just thinking maybe one of the kinks can be like a free use set up?” You suggest.

“Yeah. I’m game with that.” Viv answers.

“What’s a free use set up?” Brooke asks.

“Jay gets to fuck you, no questions asked.” Becca answers.

“Isn’t that already our set up?” Brooke asks with a raised eyebrow, not joking in the slightest.

“It’s more of-uh being a fucktoy kind of scenario, right? You could be doing something else, and Jay will have his way with you, while you continue to do what you’re doing — like cleaning, reading, cooking. At least, that is the version from porn I’m familiar with.” Tanya explains to Brooke.

“That’s what I had in mind too, actually.” You confess.

“How about since it’s one of the things Jay wants to try, we can double it? Two of us do that free use fetish, so we end up with three threesomes and the one that gets anal can go solo.” Tanya suggests, and the group agrees with her suggestion as well.

“Okay! Let’s get New Fetish New Year started!” Viv shouts in excitement.

“I already opened up the virtual wheel. What’s the first fetish we should spin for?” Maddy asks.

“Might as well be anal since it’s the solo one.” Stella suggests, and nobody disagrees; so Maddy spins the wheel to find out who among your girlfriends is going to try anal with you. The virtual wheel begins to spin, and as it slows down, there’s a split second you thought the wheel was going to stop on your daughter’s name; but it continues to keep going just a little more and it ends up stopping on…

“RIIIIIGGED!!” Stella jokingly shouts, with her hands around her mouth to amplify the sound.

A few hours later…

“Jay?” Tanya grabs you attention, while you’re sitting on the couch fiddling with your phone. You look at Tanya and ask her, “What’s up?”, to which she asks, “Can you come with me?”. You immediately get up from the couch and follow Tanya. As you walk behind her, you’re beginning to realize that you’re on your way to Becca’s sex dungeon.

Oh, it looks like the fun’s starting tonight.

You keep quiet, not wanting to spoil Tanya’s build up of what’s about to come.

“Open the door, Jay.” Tanya tells you, and you don’t hesitate to do as she asks.

“Hey, Jay.”

“Oh! Hey~, Brooke.” You greet her back.

“Not who you were expecting?” Brooke asks you.

“Oh-uh, I just thought… since we didn’t agree on an order… and with Tanya…” You begin to fumble in explaining.

“They’re going to get their turn, just not tonight. I just had Tanya help me with a few things.” Brooke informs you, before completely turning her back towards you and bending forward, giving you a more explicit view of her ass. Brooke caresses her legs with her hands, making their way up as she goes upright, before resting beneath her ample ass cheeks. Brooke teases you with a pause, but eventually spreads her ass cheeks with her fingers to reveal a shiny red crystal-like foreign object where her asshole is supposed to be.

“Oh dear, God.” You react upon seeing it.

“Mmm, exactly what I wanted to hear.” Brooke tells you with a moan, as she begins to jiggle her asscheeks with her fingers.

You couldn’t hold back any longer and approach her, hugging her with one arm while your other hand starts caressing one of her ass cheeks that you pull in closer to your crotch. You plant kisses along her neck, making her moan even more.

“This outfit looks incredible.” You compliment her, and Brooke shows her appreciation of your compliment by grinding her ass on your crotch. Just the pressure of her asscheeks is making you grow quickly, and you immediately feel constricted in that area.

Not wanting to wait any longer, you princess carry Brooke towards the bed. Brooke lets out an audible gasp of surprise, but gives you a naughty smile before making out with you as you carry her towards the bed. You lightly toss her on the bed, and immediately start taking off your shirt, pants, and underwear.

“Someone’s awfully excited.” Brooke observes, as she props herself up on her elbows. “We teased Maddy about being a nympho, but you’re pretty slutty yourself, Jay.” Brooke teases you.

“Can’t it just be because I’ve always wanted to do this with you?” You ask her in faux shyness, while your semi-erect penis is twitching in excitement for what you and Brooke are about to do.

“You could have just asked.” Brooke tells you.

“I didn’t want to sound pushy. I’m fully aware that I’m the luckiest guy alive. I don’t want to sound like I’m not satisfied with what I have.” You explain, and Brooke rolls her eyes at your answer but still gives you a smile after hearing it.

“Then that’s on you then. I wouldn’t have said no.” Brooke teases you, while beginning to caress her pussy with her hands. “Especially after you’ve put a baby inside me… Daddy.” Brooke adds, before ripping apart the lace stockings she was wearing to expose her pussy and butt for you.

You get on the bed with her, and she goes upright while on her knees to look at you in the eyes. She places a hand on your cheek and caresses it with her lace covered hand.

“I’ll let you fuck me in the ass, tie me up, tie you up, cuck me, use me to cuck someone else, use me like a fucktoy, or whatever else you can come up with… I don’t care. I’ll say yes to all of it, if you ask. I love you, Jay. I can’t say that enough.” Brooke tells you sweetly, and you go in for a kiss. You put your hands on her ass and immediately squeeze them with your fingers. Brooke moans into your lips as the two of you continue to kiss.

Brooke slides the chain straps of her top to the side, and pulls dow the cups of her leather top down to expose her huge tits. You immediately lower your mouth down to suck on her nipples, your hands still not breaking contact with her asscheeks. It’s actually Brooke that pulls you off of her tits after a while, so that she can kiss you and have her lips make their way down your body.

As Brooke lowered herself, you challenged yourself not to have your hands break away from her buttcheeks at all. Once Brooke had herself in a doggy position, with her lips making contact with the tip of your cock, you had your arms outstretched to its full length to keep your grip on Brooke’s big beautiful buttcheeks.

“I’m ready, Jay. Put all of it in.” Brooke tells you. It confuses you, since she’s not facing the right way for you to fuck her ass, but you realize what she wants to do first. Your cock is already right in front of her open mouth, so you only had to move your hips forward to slowly inch it inside Brooke’s awaiting mouth. As you slowly inch it forward, you can immediately feel the slobber coat the tip of your cock and all around your shaft.

Brooke eventually lets out a gagging sound as you hit the back of her throat, but she doesn’t let you move back as she puts her hands on your butt to pull you back in. You begin facefucking Brooke a little, only moving your hips a little distance before pushing back in. Once you’re balls deep inside her, you slap her ass downwards before gripping it once again with your fingers.

Once you feel like your cock is fully and truly coated with Brooke’s saliva, you pull out of her mouth; and you immediately hear Brooke take deep gasps for air. She falls on her face, her arms too tired to support her, as she coughs in between deep breaths. You switch positions to get behind her, as she continued to have her ass up in the air.

You finally get a close up view of the buttplug covering her asshole, and you slowly try and pull it out. You move it in and out of her to get her asshole to relax some more, before the base finally begins to widen her asshole and you can pull the buttplug out fully. Brooke immediately moans in pleasure as her asshole begins to pucker up, showing you how pink it is.

The site before you was too tempting for you to wait any longer and begin to eat out Brooke’s asshole.

“OH FUCK!” Brooke shouts, already feeling a great sense of pleasure from getting her asshole licked. Brooke has recovered enough that she starts rubbing her clit with her fingers as you continue to lick her asshole.

“Your tongue feels so good, Daddy!” Brooke moans in pleasure. “I can’t even imagine how good your cock must feel inside it!” Brooke shouts, turning you on even more. You stop eating her out, and you go upright to try and direct your cock into her asshole to finally fuck her anally. “There’s lube near the pillows.” Brooke tells you.

You take the lube and let it coat your cock, as well as her buttcheeks, before placing your cock in between her buttcheeks and squeezing them together.

“Do you think this would be slick enough?” You ask Brooke, as you hotdog her buttcheeks with your cock.

“Stop with the tease!” Brooke pleadingly shouts, while letting out moans as you move your back and forth between her asscheeks. You can even feel her asshole pucker as you move.

“Tell me you want me to fuck your ass as much as I do.” You tease her some more.

“I do! I want you to fuck my ass so badly!” Brooke shouts.

“All you have to do is ask.” You continue to tease.

“Aaaw~, please Daddy! Can you please fuck my asshole?” Brooke begs you.

As soon as she does, you spread her buttcheeks instead of squeezing them together and slowly direct the tip of your cock to her entrance. With how slick it is with the lube, and her asshole puckering to suck your cockhead in on its own, it wasn’t all that hard to fully get your cock inside Brooke.

You can tell Brooke’s cumming just by having all of your cock inside her asshole. You’re not one to talk though, as Brooke’s tight asshole is massaging your cock to the point it wants to cum. Thankfully, the tightness of her entrance is like a vice grip on your shaft that prevents your balls from getting any cum to rise up.

Once you’ve gotten more used to her tightness, you begin to move a little, like how you were face fucking her earlier. Not wanting to move too much in case you might hurt your girlfriend. Brooke’s asshole continues to massage your cock inside it with its constant puckering, and you finally feel confident enough to speed up.

“OH~ GOD! YESSS!” Brooke moans in pleasure. Once you realize that Brooke’s asshole isn’t showing any resistance, you speed up even more and start fucking her normally. With the lube still in your hand, you let it drizzle down between her asscheeks and let the excess fall on your cock as you move in and out of her asshole.

Brooke fingers clutch the bedsheet in pure bliss as Brooke lets out a guttural moan of pleasure, as she can’t seem to stop cumming. Brooke keeps taking deep breaths after her orgasm, but it’s not long before she’s groaning out once again, and you can feel her entire lower body shake from the intensity of her orgasm.

You grip her waist and finally speed up to bring yourself into climax as you can feel Brooke’s asshole becoming more and more relaxed. Brooke was about to shout a loud “FUCK!” in pleasure, but it seems to get hung up on her throat and she only lets out a bated breath as you finally get close to cumming.

“I’m cumming Brooke!” You shout out as you pour all of your seed inside Brooke’s asshole. All you can hear is your own grunt as Brooke seems spent from getting fucked hard in the ass. Once you feel all of your cum has been expelled out of you and into Brooke’s ass, you take out your cock to the immediate dripping of it outside her ass.

You fall to your side, and pull Brooke’s motionless body to its side too; effectively spooning her into a cuddle. Brooke seems knocked out from the intense orgasms she experienced, and you’re not too far behind as you feel exhausted yourself.

You give her a gentle kiss on the cheek as a thank you for letting you do this with her.

“I love you too, Brooke. I can’t say that enough.”

Poll Results:

As you can see, Brooke tied Stella in the vote, and it's why I had to reference Stella being close to being the one who was going to try this out with her Dad. As for why I chose Brooke instead of Stella, it's because Stella was the lead vote getter in something else while this was the fetish Brooke dominated for majority of the voting period before Stella made a fourth quarter comeback to tie with the last vote.

Again, thank you to everyone who participated! It was nice to see the level of interest people have over certain characters doing certain things.