New Fetish New Year, Pt. 2

Yesterday…

“RIIIIIGGED!!” Stella jokingly shouts out, as the virtual wheel lands on Brooke’s name.

“The universe really is on your side, huh Jay?” Tanya teases you, getting a laugh out of everyone.

“I mean, the fact we’re even spinning this virtual wheel is already the universe being on my side, isn’t it?” You point out.

“You should really run for politics if this whole writing thing doesn’t work out.” Viv jokes.

“Okay! I’ll admit it’s something I’ve thought about doing with Brooke.” You admit to them. “With all of you.” You then add, to the chuckles of everyone.

“He just can’t help himself.” Tanya jokes.

“Ever the diplomat.” Becca adds on.

“What fetish should we spin for next?” Maddy interrupts the group teasing you, and gets everyone back on track.

“How about who should try being a domme?” Cassie suggests.

“Oof. Take my name out of that if it’s cool. I’ve tried it, and it’s not for me.” Viv tells Maddy.

“Oh! We forgot to ask if we’re all comfortable with all of this!” Maddy realizes, and you immediately look at Brooke to ask her if she’s okay with it.

“Oh! Don’t worry. I’m okay to try anal. Just give me time to prepare.” Brooke assures you.

“I can help with that.” Tanya tells her, while Viv and Becca offer their help as well.

“Anybody else not comfortable doing a specific fetish?” Maddy asks, and everybody shakes their head. “Okay, so that means you’ll be okay joining the cucking pair or the free use pair? Right, V?” Maddy double checks with Viv, who gives her confirmation.

“You wouldn’t mind being a sub, Becca?” Maddy double checks with Becca as well.

“Under normal circumstances, I would. For Jay, I can make an exception.” Becca answers honestly. Although she didn’t mean what she said to be sweet, you can’t help but think how sweet it was for her to say that.

“Okay then! It’s time to spin the wheel!” Maddy announces.

“OH! It’s me!” Tanya shouts in excitement, and you all can’t help but smile at her enthusiasm. “I already thought of the title you can call me too!” Tanya tells you excitedly.

“Are you going to be Mommy domme?” Cassie asks her.

“YES!” Tanya answers with a laugh, and Cassie can’t help but laugh with her.

“Have you always wanted to dominate me, T?” You ask her.

“I mean, not really. I just think it would be fun to boss you around for a bit.” Tanya admits.

“I’m actually quite interested in seeing how Tanya would be as a domme. I would say she has a natural talent for it. Now, I definitely wouldn’t mind subbing for her.” Becca shares her thoughts.

“Same.” Viv and Cassie both agree with Becca simultaneously.

“Can you put my name on the wheel when we spin for who’s going to be Tanya’s sub?” Viv asks Maddy.

“Beats the whole purpose of swapping fetishes if we put your name down for your own fetish.” Stella points out.

“We can always just try it whenever you want, V.” Tanya naughtily tells her with a wink, to the excitement of Viv.

“Okay, time to spin for who gets to be a sub to Tanya’s domme! Let’s see who the wheel chooses.” Maddy announces, before tapping the spin on the virtual wheel.

Once again, it begins slowing down on Stella’s name, but ultimately stops on…

“RIIIIIGGED!!” Stella jokingly shouts once again.

The present…

“Was fucking Brooke in the ass everything you dreamed it would be?” Stella asks you, while the two of you cuddle on Becca’s couch. Your other girlfriends were off doing their own thing based on what they said after dinner.

“Yes.” You answer her honestly. “You already knew that would be my answer though. Why are you asking?” You teasingly return the question to her, implying something with your tone.

“Did a part of you wish the wheel stopped on my name when we were spinning it for who gets to try anal with you?” Stella asks you, curious.

“No.” You answer her.

“Oh.” Stella reacts in disappointment.

“I didn’t really wish for any particular fetish to land on anyone. I’m willing to do anything for all of you. You know that.” You try to clarify what you meant. “Even if I did, and it didn’t land on that person, I’ll probably just ask them to try it with me some other time; now that I know it’s something I want to try with them. Like how Tanya and Viv basically scheduled a session together yesterday.” You explain to her.

“Do you want to try anal with me, baby?” You immediately ask her.

“I want to try everything with you too, Daddy.” Stella answers you before giving you a sweet kiss, which quickly turns into a makeout session… and just as quickly as it started, it was interrupted by a loud cough from near the couch. You both stop and look up to see Viv and Becca standing nearby.

“Apologies for the interruption, but there’s a situation that requires Jay’s attention.” Becca informs both of you.

“What happened?” You ask as calmly as you can, trying to not panic despite the wording of Becca’s sentence.

“It’s better if I show you.” Becca answers. You decide to stand up to follow Becca, and Stella was about to too, before Viv stops her.

“Wait! That’s why I’m here. I’m here to take your Dad’s place in your makeout session.” Viv jokes to Stella, who gives her a sarcastic ‘Har-har’ laugh in reaction.

“Shall we go?” Becca asks you, and you nod your head. As you walk to leave the living room with Becca, you hear Stella ask Viv, “So, what did they come up with?”

Becca leads you across her apartment, and you already pieced it together that whatever the ‘situation’ was, it involved Tanya dominating you in Becca’s dungeon; which Becca was obviously leading you to.

Once you reach the door to Becca’s sex dungeon, she stops before opening it.

“You know the rules of my private room, Jay. Anyone who enters it, plays the role agreed upon.” Becca reminds you, and you tell her you know the rules. “Good. You know Tanya’s role, and you’ll be a switch, depending on what Mommy wants you to do. Your safeword is the same, and Mommy has been informed of it.” Becca informs you.

“Any questions?” Becca asks.

“Why do I think it’s hot when you call Tanya ‘Mommy’?” You ask her jokingly, and it gets a subdued laugh from Becca.

“It is, isn't it?” Becca agrees with you.

“Too bad I’m not Tanya’s sub tonight. We can explore that kink of yours some other time.” Becca adds, before giving you a kiss on the cheek. “Have fun.” She then whispers to your ear, before walking away to leave you staring at the door to her sex dungeon. Not seeing the point of waiting any longer, you finally open the door to reveal the situation Becca mentioned.

You see Cassie wearing an outfit you normally don’t see her wear — crop top, pleated skirt, and knee high socks that she folded to only cover half her calves. It’s not completely a schoolgirl outfit, but you’re assuming that’s what she’s going for.

“Daddy!” Cassie shouts out. “You need to protect me from Mommy! She’s gone insane!” Cassie tells you in ‘pornstar-level acting’ kind of panic.

“Cassandra! Get back here!” You hear Tanya shout. Her voice cam from the sex dungeon’s bathroom, but she immediately exits it to show herself.

Tanya was wearing an all-latex ensemble— from her top that was basically a sports bra, her panties that just barely covered her pussy, as well as her arm-length latex gloves and thigh high latex platform boots. The only thing that wasn’t latex were the gold accents and jewelry she was wearing.

“Papi! You’re home!” Tanya acts in surprise.

“What’s this about, T-uh~… Mommy?” You ask her, both trying to act in character, and genuinely curious what scenario they came up with.

“I just saw our daughter’s report card! They're all C’s!” Tanya informs you. You hedge your bets and react like it’s the most disappointing news you’ve ever heard.

“You used to be a straight A student!” Tanya adds for context.

“Yeah, and now I have Cs.” Cassie answers her, cupping her breasts as she does, making the pun obvious.

“You think this is funny? You think this is a joke?” Tanya asks her.

“It is! I’m not even failing!” Cassie says defensively.

“You see that, papi? She’s a spoiled brat that needs to be disciplined!” Tanya tells you.

“You need to listen to your Mommy, baby.” You tell Cassie.

“¿Eso es todo?” Tanya asks you in disbelief. “Come here! Both of you!” Tanya then grabs you and Cassie by the wrists, and drags you both towards the bed. “Sit!” Tanya shouts as she half-throws you to the bed. You sit down on the bed like she commands, and she immediately pushes Cassie onto your lap. Cassie falls belly first on your lap, and you immediately understand what Tanya’s getting at.

“It’s time you start disciplining our daughter, papi!” Tanya commands you. You lift Cassie’s skirt up to reveal her white cotton panties.

“No! No! No!” Cassie acts in character. “Please no, Daddy!” Cassie pleads with you while moving her legs up and down, the naughtiness in her tone not lost on you. You pin both of her legs under your right leg so that they stop moving up and down. “No, Daddy!” Cassie continues to plead. You hike up her panties to reveal her butt cheeks, and begin to caress them with your palm. You raise your hand, and Tanya grabs your wrist, taking you by surprise. Tanya then seductively licks your palm before letting it go, and…

*SPANK!*

“Daddy! I’m sorry!” Cassie shouts.

*SPANK!!*

“Don’t! Stop! Daddy!” Cassie continues.

*SPANK!!!*

“Oh~ Daddy! Please!” Cassie pleads.

“Cassandra! Quiet!” Tanya commands her.

“I’m so sorry, Mommy. I’ll do better next semester!” Cassie continues to act.

“Still so undisciplined.” Tanya says with fake disdain. “Take her to the bed.” Tanya commands you. You put your arms underneath Cassie and carry her that way, before turning and laying her prone on the bed. Tanya saunters to the side of the bed, before getting on it to join Cassie. Tanya lays on her back, and spreads her legs wide right in front of Cassie. She then pulls apart the latex covering her crotch to reveal her pussy to Cassie.

“If you’re not going to shut up, then put that mouth to good use, Cassandra.” Tanya orders Cassie. Cassie crawls towards Tanya and nears her pussy, but hesitates from eating Tanya out. Tanya grabs her by the back of her head and pushes Cassie’s head into her waiting pussy. “Yes! That’s it! Use that mouth!” Tanya goads her, as Cassie begins to lick Tanya’s vaginal walls.

“You! Continue to discipline our daughter!” Tanya then commands you. You get on the bed with them, and Cassie raises her ass up while continuing to eat Tanya out to allow you to spank her.

*SPANK*

“That’s it! Stick your tongue out, girl!” Tanya orders Cassie, and holds her head down to her crotch, preventing her from breaking away from her pussy. “Spank her again!” Tanya commands you.

*SPANK*

As soon as your palm hits Cassie’s butt, you see her push forward and thrust her mouth deeper into Tanya’s pussy. Tanya moans in pleasure from this, and you immediately go for another one.

*SPANK* *SPANK*

*SPANK* *SPANK* *SPANK*

The combination of the sound of your palm hitting Cassie’s ass cheek, Tanya’s moans, Cassie’s moans, have definitely gotten you erect enough that your pants are starting to feel constricting. You continue to spank Cassie until Tanya lifts Cassie’s head up from her crotch, and Cassie has her tongue out, letting drool fall from her open mouth.

“Look at what you did to your Papi.” Tanya tells Cassie, who turns her head to look behind her to see the tent in your pants that’s been formed by your hardening cock. “You’ve upset him with your behavior. Take care of that for him.” Tanya commands Cassie.

“Yes, Mommy.” Cassie replies before she turns her body towards you. Cassie starts working on unbuttoning your pants, while Tanya pulls Cassie's panties down to her knees. Cassie moans as Tanya puts her fingers inside her.

“Such a dirty slut. Getting wet from her Papi’s spanking.” Tanya says condescendingly, as Cassie frees your cock from your pants. “You see how your naughtiness has affected your Papi?” Tanya asks Cassie, before giving her a spanking. “Use your mouth to calm him down.” Tanya commands her. Cassie immediately starts sucking your cock while Tanya starts to finger Cassie at the same time.

As Tanya pushes her fingers in, Cassie’s mouth takes more and more of your cock inside her. Cassie’s deepthroating follows Tanya’s pace of fingering, which has constantly been building up since they both started. After some time, Cassie couldn’t take it anymore and pauses while your cock was halfway inside her mouth as she finally cums from Tanya’s fingers. She moans with your cock still inside her mouth, and Tanya pulls her head back through her hair to goad her some more.

“Did you cum, you dirty slut?” Tanya asks her. “Did you cum while failing to do what I told you to do? Didn’t I tell you to calm your Papi down?” She asks Cassie. “Look at it!” Tanya orders Cassie. “It’s harder than before!” Tanya shouts.

“I’m so sorry, Mommy! You were just so good at fingering me.” Cassie answers shyly.

“Are you blaming me for your sluttiness?” Tanya asks her.

“No, Mommy! It was a compliment!” Cassie says defensively.

“If you want to kiss my ass…” Tanya says before turning Cassie to lie on her back. “... then kiss my actual ass.” Tanya completes her thought, before positioning her ass to be directly on top of Cassie's face.

Cassie rips open the latex even more to have access to Tanya’s bare ass cheeks, which she begins to start planting kisses on.

“If you can’t take care of your Papi with your mouth, then maybe he should start using the rest of your body.” Tanya tells Cassie.

“I’ll be a good girl for Daddy. I’ll let him use my body any way he wants.” Cassie says in such a naughty tone.

“Every word coming out of your mouth is dirty. You need to learn to keep that slutty mouth shut.” Tanya says before planting her butt on Cassie’s face, covering it completely. Tanya pulls Cassie’s crop top up to reveal her naked breasts for you, which the two of you begin to fondle.

“Don’t get distracted, papi.” Tanya reminds you, and you take that as your command to position yourself in between Cassie’s legs. You lift Cassie’s skirt up to show you her shaved pussy, and you immediately direct the tip of your cock to its entrance.

“That’s it, papi. Fuck your baby girl.” Tanya coaxes you. You finally take your shirt off before entering Cassie’s pussy deeper, and Tanya places her hands on Cassie’s toned abdomen and leans forward to get closer to you. Once your entire length is inside Cassie, Tanya gives you a kissy face while twerking her ass on Cassie’s face beneath her.

You and Tanya begin to make out as both of you do the same grinding motions with your hips, that are doing completely different things to Cassie’s body between the two of you. Your hip movements take your dick in and out of Cassie’s pussy while Tanya’s hip movements are causing Cassie’s open mouth to lick her asshole and pussy.

You and Tanya both begin to speed up after breaking away from your kiss, focusing on getting yourselves off using Cassie’s body. Cassie uses her hand to start rubbing Tanya’s clit while continuing to use her mouth to get Tanya off, while you hold onto Cassie’s hips to start fucking her more vigorously.

“Yes, baby! Make Mommy cum on your mouth!” Tanya shouts as Cassie’s hands go faster and faster in rubbing her clit, while you go faster and faster going in and out of her pussy. All three of you are beginning to moan constantly as each of you close in on your peaks. You take the back of Tanya’s head and pull her closer to you to make out with her again; while also pinching her nipple with your other hand, to help Cassie out in getting Tanya to reach completion.

It wasn’t long after that that Tanya orgasms and falls forward on top of Cassie’s body, her face now inches away from Cassie’s pussy that you’re continuing to fuck furiously. With Cassie’s mouth free from Tanya’s crotch, you can hear her moans more clearly.

“Daddy! Let’s cum at the same time, Daddy! Please!” Cassie pleads with you as you feel your own orgasm getting nearer and nearer.

“I’m there, baby! I’m cumming!” You groan in pleasure.

“‘I’m cumming too, Daddy! AAAAH~!” Cassie moans out loud, as both of you reach your orgasms simultaneously.

You finally pull out of Cassie after spurting all of your cum inside her, and a stream of your cum flows right out of her pussy. Tanya’s face being near as it is, immediately started sucking all of it out of Cassie’s pussy.

You lay back on the bed, happily exhausted from this session of fucking you just did with your two girlfriends. Cassie and Tanya follow suit and cuddle on either side of you, resting their heads on your chest.

“Did you have fun, papi? Was our scenario good?” Tanya asks you.

“Definitely. It was fucking hot. It was definitely fucking hot.” You answer Tanya honestly and enthusiastically.

“I hope you can keep going, Daddy.” Cassie naughtily tells you.

“I didn’t eat Mommy’s ass out for nothing.”

Poll Results:

This was a close race for both categories as well, where Cassie only beat Maddy by 1 vote, while Tanya beat Brooke by only 2 votes. However, not only did Cassie and Tanya lead for those respective fetishes overall, they also lead as a pair - getting 5 votes to be the sub/domme pair for this chapter. There was a three way tie for the next specific sub/domme pair, which were: Stella and Cassie, Maddy and Brooke, and Maddy and Tanya.

Thank you once again for participating in the poll!