Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 17 by OppositeOfMiddle OppositeOfMiddle

Who wants it?

Monica wants it

Monica looks at Rachel. She says, “Do you mind if I have a ride, then you can have him the rest of the night?”

Rachel says, “Sure. Get some of that aggression out. I’m more of a sweet and cuddly girl.”

Monica tells me, “Sit back on the couch so I can ride you.”

I sit on the couch, and she walks over to me. She lowers her pajamas pants down her thick pale legs. She places on knees up onto the couch and straddles me. She rubs her wet pussy against my cock, and she leans in and kisses me.

She sighs, “It’s so hot tasting another woman’s pussy on your lips.” Her tongue licks across mine.

She guides my cock into her, and she sits back on it and moans. “Oooh fuck. You’re feeling so big tonight. You looked so hot manhandling Phoebe! Mmm. I have such a hot husband.”

As she praises me, her wet pussy works up and down my cock. I reach behind her and squeeze her thick ass. She moans, “I love the feel of you inside me.” She leans forward and presses her tits into me. She whispers in my ear, “I bet you look so huge in Rachel’s skinny body. Your dick is as thick as her forearm. Mmm. I wish I could watch her come all over you. Oh fuck. Yes right there.”

She grinds against me, reaching closer and closer to the edge. “Mmmm Chandler. Fuck I didn’t know it turned me on so much seeing how hot you were with other women.”

I whisper into her ear, “After you come, I’m going to shove my cock in Phoebe’s mouth and explode down her throat.”

“Oh god yessss!” That image helps send her over the edge into orgasm. She moans and then rolls off me onto the couch, and tells me, “Go do it!”

I stand up off the couch, my erection dark and throbbing. Phoebe is sitting in the chair. She looks at me, and says, “What are you going to do with that?”

I say, “Open your mouth.”

Phoebe slides off the couch and gets down on her knees. She gives me such an innocent look, then drops her jaw. She looks up to me with a wide mouth. I tilt my cock down, and guide it into her mouth.

She bites her teeth down on my cock. I yell, “Fuck!” Probably not a good idea putting my cock into this viper’s mouth.

She chuckles and opens her mouth wider, taking her teeth from my shaft. I push in deeper. I keep pushing until my hard cock is fully in her: my tip down her throat. Phoebe reaches up and grabs my ass cheeks, pulling me closer into her face.

Oh fuck it feels so good in her mouth. I’m so close to coming. Then Phoebe’s finger presses against my asshole. It makes me jump, and my hips thrust, slamming my cock hard into Phoebe’s throat. I moan in orgasm, feeling my cum spurt into her. I grab the back of her head, and hold myself inside her until I’m finished.

Phoebe’s nails scratch into my ass cheeks. I finally pull out on pain. She coughs in a fit, trying to catch her breath. Tears stream down her face. In anger she reaches up and slaps my sensitive balls.

I groan and drop to the ground.

As I’m recovering, Rachel talks to Monica. “Maybe we should lock them in a room, and see who comes out in the morning.”

Monica laughs, “Is it messed up that I don’t want Chandler to do any of that to me, but I love watching him do it to Phoebe?”

“Yeah it is,” laughs Rachel. She helps me to my feet. “Are you ready to get cleaned up, and then we can snuggle?”

Then from her knees, Phoebe looks up at me, “Or do you want to do what they suggested? Spend the night with me, and let’s get all this sexual tension out.” She reaches out and her nail trails down my cock. “I still haven’t gotten to feel this inside me yet. And I want to feel it in every hole.”

Oh shit. Do I go with the vicious Phoebe, and maybe end up in the ER after a night of wild sex? Or do I go with the sweet and sexy Rachel, and make love until we fall asleep in each others arms?

Which woman do I choose?

  • No further chapters
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)