Let's See What John Thinks

“Ok,” Miranda said, “I have a plan to tell him, just follow my lead okay?” And after getting a nod from Sarah, Miranda raised her voice and said “John! You can come in now!!”

//Switching back to your POV

As you open the door into Sarah’s room, you see her and your crush sitting on the bed, Sarah having apparently pulled on a loose t-shirt over her upper body while they were having that conversation.

You have to admit, having two beautiful women staring at you, a mysterious gleam in their eyes you can’t quite place, is making you a bit nervous. So, you try to break the tension with a remark, “So, what did I miss?”

“Well, we talked,” It was Miranda who spoke up. “And Sarah told me about her feelings for you, and also explained her behavior throughout the night. After hearing her out, I decided to forgive her as well.”

“Great,” you said, “so where do we go from here?”

“I suppose the first question is, do you have feelings for Sarah as well? I want your honest answer.”

You pause for a moment, mulling over your words carefully, for fear of damaging your relationship with Miranda if you admitted the truth of which you yourself had just discovered several minutes back. Finally, you decided that honesty is the best policy, so you say “I do, actually, I just realized it outside while you guys were talking. I’ve never actually looked at Sarah that way before, but hearing her admit her feelings to me opened my eyes to new feelings I didn’t know where there.” Turning to look at Sarah with a soft smile on your face, you continued, “I couldn’t deny the fact that you’re an incredibly beautiful woman Sarah, or that we have an extremely good chemistry together, chemistry which I found myself wanting to explore.”

This caused Sarah to blush a deep shade of red as she closed her eyes and sighed contentedly, letting herself bask in the fact that her longtime crush returns her feelings.

“Ok, so I suppose, since you like both of us, and we both like you, you’ll have to choose.”

“Wait what?”

“You know, like choose who to date? Don’t worry we talked, we’ll accept whomever you pick.”

You paused to think for a moment, well aware that your next words could change the relationship between the three of you forever.

“I- I-, I can’t,” you spoke up finally, after a long pause to think, “I like the both of you equally so I just… Can’t bring myself to choose.”

“Huh,” Sarah speaks up, much to your confusion, “seems you called it Miranda.”

“That I did.” Miranda said, nodding surely, confusing you even further.

“Hold up, what’s going on here?”

“Well, you see, when Sarah admitted her feelings about you to me, I actually agreed that if you were okay with it, we’d like to share you.”

You couldn’t believe your luck, here you were, having a crush on two incredibly beautiful women, with whom you thought you’ve just ruined your chances with due to saying that you can’t choose, and now they’re saying they want to share you? You feel so much euphoria coursing through your body right now you could be floating. Anyhow, you decide to further clarify the terms of your relationship.

“So this will be like a three-way?”

“Well sort of, we’re both dating you and while I may be down to play with Sarah sometime if we’re in the mood, we’re not dating each other. Now before we go into this, I’m gonna need you to promise us both one thing.”

“And that is?”

“That you’d give us both equal amounts of love and attention, that includes romantically and sexually.”

You pause to think for a moment, and since it’s a no-brainer, you reply. “Of course, I’ll try my best to be the best boyfriend you two could ask for, since I already know that you two are going to be the best girlfriends a guy could ask for. I also promise to give you both equal amounts of attention.”

“Great, then I suppose this makes it official then,” Miranda said

“Ok,” you replied, then looking at Sarah you asked, “Sarah, may I kiss you first?”

And chuckling heartily at the way Sarah’s eyes light up at your words as she nods enthusiastically, you decide to close the distance between you and the bed then, sitting down on Sarah’s left side, you leaned in to kiss her. The moment your lips touched was like a jolt of electricity, you can feel butterflies running rampant in your stomach. You’ve never expected to feel something this intense for someone who wasn’t Miranda, but here you are, kissing Sarah, and loving every second of it. And as you part, it hits you: Sarah, absolute bombshell and a sex goddess, has decided to commit to an exclusive relationship with you. While she wasn’t your objective tonight, you feel incredibly lucky that she decided to settle down with you, and you make a silent promise to yourself that you will treat her as best you can and be the awesome boyfriend that she deserves.

“Did you like it?” You asked.

“Gods yes,” Sarah sighed dreamily, her eyes watering slightly from how emotional the moment was, “I’ve been wanting to do that for so long, thank you for that John.”

“My turn now?” You heard Miranda speak at the same time you feel her pressing into your left side, having moved during the time you and Sarah were kissing. Instead of answering, you just turned your head and connect your lips with hers.

The feeling was… Amazing. With Sarah, you have just recently discovered that you feel like you like her, that, combined with the fact that she is a very attractive woman gave you the butterflies you were feeling. But when you were kissing Miranda it seems like the entire world shrunk down to just you and her and this indescribable feeling of pure bliss. A couple minutes later you part, needing air. Foreheads resting together, you smiled brightly at Miranda as you breathed out. “At the risk of sounding like a broken record, I’ve been wanting to do that for so long too, Miranda.”

To which she just giggles and pulls you back in for another kiss. And once again the entire world is shut out and it’s just the two of you, a situation you would’ve no problem being stuck in forever, but yet again, the world decides to barge in in the form of Sarah. This time however, she’s not aggressively pushing against Miranda like she was before, back then she was jealous and trying to win you over. Now, her relationship with you secure, she takes her time to gently and tenderly insert herself in the middle of your two tangling lips, turning it into a loving three-way kiss. You could get used to this side of Sarah, you realized. Not the sex goddess that sleeps with literally everybody in school, but the loving and gentle woman whose company you’re very much coming enjoy. Breaking the kiss, you open your mouth to tell Sarah as much when Miranda cuts you off.

“You know Sarah, that was a lot better when you weren’t trying to push me off his mouth like earlier.” You just looked at Miranda, surprised that she would call her friend out like that, but before you could get a word in, Sarah replied.

“I know, and I’m sorry, I was just jealous of you two and how close you just seemed to be getting.”

“It’s okay Sarah, it’s all in the past now, and we’ve already forgiven you so let’s just all move past it alright?” You finally said, turning to give a warning glare to Miranda to drop the subject. Both girls responded with a nod. “So now that that’s settled, shall we go back down to the party?”

A/N: So I decided to end the chapter here in order to leave it as a branching-off point, with them having options to choose from from here. What do you guys want to see? Shall they go down and continue the game? Or shall Sarah send the other guests home and then stay up here to have a little lover's romp? Lemme know down in the comments