Meanwhile, in Sarah's room...

As soon as John has closed the door, Sarah opened her mouth trying to speak, when Miranda interrupted her mid-way: "Could you at least put something on first? It's kinda awkward having a conversation with my naked best friend." as she finished, Miranda was surprised to see Sarah uncharacteristically blush at her statement, her friend was never one to be uncomfortable with her body, in fact she often seems to flaunt it as much as possible. And while normally she wouldn't stand in the way of that, the reason Miranda asked her to put something on was because she'd rather preferred not to have a constant reminder of the fact that Sarah was just naked in the same room with John.

Having pulled on a loose fitting t-shirt and a pair of panties, Sarah, seemingly regaining her confidence for the moment, sat down on her bed and turned to Miranda with an expression that almost said "Well? Can we get on with it?”

"What were you really going to talk to John about then?" and just like that Sarah's new-found confidence went straight out the window once more, remember what exactly she had been planning to talk about: the deal about having John share her and Miranda with Tom, something that Sarah just knows that given how things have been going between her and John tonight, Miranda would definitely not be ok with.

“I- I uhh…” Sarah struggled with herself, not truly sure how to proceed, her fear of possibly sullying her best friend’s new found love and resultantly their friendship eating away at her and stressing her out.

“Come on, Sarah, we’re best friends right? You can tell me?” Miranda got out as she slid onto the bed next to her friend.

“I don’t know, Miranda, I really don’t want you to think differently of me for this.” At this point, the pressure is really getting to Sarah, she’s shaking a bit and her eyes are welling up.

“Oh, Sarah, you know I’ll never judge you right? Whatever it is you can tell me, please?” Miranda pushed once more, putting one hand on her friend’s shoulder. And finally Sarah just couldn’t take it anymore.

“I have a crush on John too okay!!!” Sarah blurted out, unable to keep it in anymore. “I have for a while, he’s real nice and he’s the only one who treats me like a real person rather than just a sex object. But he’s always only got eyes for you Miranda, no matter what I do. So I got jealous, and I thought that if I could just pair you off with someone else, that maybe just maybe he’d look at me too, just this once.” Was all she managed before she collapsed into a crying, sobbing mess. After a couple seconds, she heard Miranda’s reply:

“Oh,” Miranda managed, a shocked expression on her face. After a couple minutes of silent contemplation, she raised a hand, then after pausing for a second, looped it around her friend pulling Sarah in close for a side hug. She slowly rubbed Sarah’s back whispering soothing words like “it’s okay” and “you’ll be alright” to help calm her down.

After a couple more minutes, once Sarah has calmed down enough that she’s no longer downright bawling, Miranda spoke up again: “Honey, we’ve been friends for too long, I won’t ruin our friendship just because you like the same guy I do, so don’t worry okay? You haven’t lost me yet. Besides, he is the complete package, handsome, just the right amount of muscle, pretty dick, and most importantly of all, a winning personality. So I’m not at all surprise or mad that you’d fall for him too.”

“Really? Thanks Miranda.” Sarah turned around to fully face Miranda and gave her a big long hug.

“Yep, but that couldn’t really have been what you called him up here to talk about did you?” Miranda looked back at Sarah pointedly.

“It’s not,” Sarah said, then she proceeded to tell Miranda about the whole transpiration of events from how she’s been mean to him the whole night and was trying to pair Miranda up with Tom to get him, to when John came up and asked her if she had a crush on him, and how he forgave her for everything despite all that she’s done tonight.

//A/N sorry guys I can’t really be bothered to write the dialogue anymore. I tried multiple times and just couldn’t find a combination of words that fit the way I liked so decided to just describe it instead.

When she was finished she sat there quietly, waiting for what Miranda would have to say.

“You know what Sarah? I think I’d rather agree with him, I forgive you too.”

“Wait really?”

“You know the saying love makes people do crazy things? Well that was your crazy thing.” Miranda giggled, Sarah looked torn between being mad at being called crazy and finding that funny for a moment before deciding to join in the laughter. “Besides, I can’t really judge you on that since I apparently would rather play a dare game and suck another guy’s dick than tell him how I feel.”

A/N Sorry not sorry for calling you out Miranda, but the whole thing was B.S. XD Although that really applies to the MC as well lmao

“On that note though, we do have to consider the nature of the relationship us two are gonna have with him aren’t we?” Miranda resumed, Sarah nodded hesitantly “I’ll say this, despite what you’ve done to us, tonight’s been an emotional night and there’s been a lot of **** going around, so I’m still willing to share him with you with a few conditions,”

Sarah’s eyes widened, “Wait really?” Once Miranda nodded, she continued, “But we don’t even know if he likes me back yet.”

“Girl, he’s been ogling you pretty much the whole night, so I’m sure that there’s at least something there don’t you worry. Now back to my two conditions: you don’t hog him all to yourself and you ensure he gives me the same amount of attention you get, both romantically and sexually.”

“That’s it?”

“MmmmHmmm, this is of course, given that he agrees with us, but do you think you can do that?”

Sarah paused to consider this for a moment. The real answer is she’s not sure, having never really been in that many serious romantic relationships before, Sarah’s inexperience makes her nervous about going into one with someone she’s had a crush on for quite a while, let alone going into it with her best friend. However, another part of her is quietly encouraging her to go for it. Chances like these, with a person as amazing as John comes around once in a millennium, and she would be a fool not to take it.

A/N: No I do not have a praise kink, it just seems poetic XD.

And that part of her won out in the end, so turning back to Miranda, she replied, “I’m game if you are. Let’s call him in and find out what he thinks.”