Learn to Lie

Your comment to Sabrina that she wasn't doing it for you elicited an interesting response. "Asshole" was the particular word she used. You did just tell her you needed her to have sex with you. Then, as she selflessly rode your cock, she fucked you so well that you came after only a few minutes. Then you lied and told her you didn't cum because she wasn't good enough. You had to admit, it was kind of a dick move. After you collect yourself you decide to make your way back in to the main house.

As soon as you step through the sliding glass door you were met by Kim. Kim, arms folded, her right foot tapping against the ground, looked pissed. "I saw you out there with Sabrina" Kim said. "You came; now get the fuck out of my house you dweeb!"

In an attempt to defuse the situation, you counter Kim's accusation. "Kim, I didn't cum. I tried too but Sabrina just wasn't hot enough. Seriously, you can ask her." Kim grabs your arm and drags you back to the hot tub. "Sabrina, please tell me this fat loser came inside you." Sabrina, a look on her face suggesting she just did something that was going to make her sick, responded to Kim. "Actually, he didn't. Apparently I don't do it for him." Kim released your arm. "Oh shit, I'm so sorry John. It's just that, I was sure that Sabrina got you off. I even saw you do that shiver guys do before they cum."

You play nice with Kim. "It's okay Kim, it was cold which was why I shivered. I can see how you thought that." Thinking the exchange was over, you start to walk away. Kim quickly trails behind you. "Wait, so what are you going to need to cum? I thought Sabrina was the only person who got your dick hard tonight?"

You didn't answer Kim for about 20 seconds. You instead just stood and appreciated how awesome this night had been. Here you were, standing in the middle of your first high school party. You were completely nude and you just had sex with a beautiful classmate. Now, you have Kim Boogler, one of the most popular girls in school, asking how she could help you cum again.

Kim quickly snaps her fingers in front of your face. "John, hello, Earth calling. What do you need to cum?"