Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 7

What follows from here?

Keeping things secret from Michael

Taylor shakes and quivers on the mattress, her ass still lewdly displayed before you. Her hole twitches and you marvel at what you’ve been able to accomplish with your new abilities. You’ve taken this stranger, a waitress who loves to cook, garden, and travel, and you’ve not only shifted her morals to cheat on her partner but also changed her into your eager fuck buddy. With your cock well drained and taken care of, it’s time to ensnare her completely.

“I can’t believe I just took you in my ass,” she pants, still short for breath. She allows her hips to fall to the bed and collapses with an exhausted sigh. “Michael always pestered me about it, so I’d built it up in my head as this big thing. But now…”

You laugh as she trails off and settle next to her, caressing her plump cheek. “How was it?” you ask, curious if her opinion on anal had changed. The hole in question, no doubt quite tender and sore, beckons you for more but you suppress the urge. With how powerful your orgasm had been, you’re momentarily spent.

She ponders the question. “Well,” she soon begins, “I won’t lie and say I enjoyed it, but…” she pauses long enough for a blush to creep on her now smiling face, “Once I got used to it, I was able to tolerate it more and see the pleasure in it. I didn’t finish, but when you came I never felt more satisfied!”

Her reaction excites you; she’s starting down the path of believing that satisfying sex doesn’t require her orgasm. “You seem proud of yourself.”

She nods excitedly, beaming. “Wouldn’t you be?”

You can’t help but grin. “Given that, would you rather only ever let me fuck your ass, or is it something you want to do with Michael eventually?

A guilty look flashes across her face at the mention of her other boyfriend, but she shakes her head and answers quickly. “I’d think I’d rather keep this between us” she tells herself, unaware of the ramifications of her choice. “...For now.”

Taylor quiets as her lust dissipates and the reality of the situation crashes back down onto her. She’d just cheated on her longtime boyfriend after agreeing to be in a relationship with a stranger. With how gung-ho she’d been when establishing your foundation, you wonder how much of that was influenced by her pent up arousal.

“So… now what?” she asks as she turns back to look at you, cuddling up against you on the bed.

You take a glance at the clock hanging on her wall. “I should probably get to class,” you mumble, unsure where to go next.

“I meant about us!” she retorts, sitting up to look down at you. “Stay. I want this to work and that means getting to know you beyond just sex.” She also spares a quick glance at the clock. “Oh good, it’s almost lunch time. Please, let me make you something to eat! It’s the least I can do for how amazing you made me feel just now.”

Her offer is tempting. With your newfound powers, you could have any girl you want. In any capacity that you want! Was it worth getting bogged down with the banalities of a relationship when all you originally wanted was to get your rocks off and test the limits of these abilities? How much more are you willing to corrupt this innocent girl?

“Let’s focus on Michael first,” you decide to prioritize, bringing her focus back to him. “Given the nature of our relationship, would you rather keep this a secret from him, for as long as possible, or tell him what happened as soon as you see him?

Out of all your hypotheticals, this one takes Taylor the longest to answer. For a moment, you wonder if she’s psyching herself up to spill the beans, but she eventually sighs and looks away, dejected. “Let’s keep this secret for now,” she answers, guilt dripping off every word. “I keep trying to sort out what I’m going to tell him but nothing seems enough. I can’t just nonchalantly walk up to him and casually drop the fact that I now have a second boyfriend. It’ll ruin him.”

You pull her close and kiss the top of her head in comfort. “Then we don’t tell him until the time is right.” Or until I have the chance to talk to him myself. You could use your powers to influence the situation now, but you didn’t want to kill the thrill of fucking this beautiful girl behind her boyfriend’s back just yet.

Taylor remains quiet as you start showering her with kisses. Under the ticklish onslaught, her resolve eventually breaks and she falls into a fit of giggles. Pivoting in your grasp, she turns to face you once again and forcefully kisses you in retaliation, eventually melting into your embrace.

A few deep passionate kisses later, she pulls away. “Stay a little longer” she pleads, her voice low and breathy. “Let me fill your belly with good food and then you can fill me with more cum.” Your hesitation pushes her even more. “Please! I’ve been so pent up. Despite what I said regarding my sex life with Michael, we have explored a bit in terms of oral. I can suck a mean cock. Please, use all my holes before you go.”

Well, with an offer like that…

Stay for round 2? Head to class? Something else?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)