Incorrigible

*DING-DONG*

…

*DING-DONG*

…

*DING-DONG*-*DING-DONG*-*DING-DONG*-*DING-DONG*

“Ease up on the doorbell!” You say in a loud whisper right after opening your front door.

“Brooke!” You then shout in surprise, not expecting her to be up this early after the night of drinking she had. “H-how are you feeling?” Jay asks.

“What? I knew you’d be up already. So it’s not like I’m waking you up.” Brooke tells you, ignoring your second question entirely.

“Yeah, but the others are still sleeping.” You remind her, unable to hide incredulousness from your voice that you had to explain that to her.

“Oh?” Brooke asks, feigning surprise at first, before she can’t hold back the devious smirk that signals what she’s about to do next.

*DING-DONG*-*DING-DONG*-*DING-DONG*-*DING-DONG*

“Get in here!” You shout, pulling in Brooke by the waist so she can stop ringing your doorbell. Brooke yelps a bit from surprise, but immediately starts laughing from possibly annoying her co-girlfriends by prematurely waking them up. You begin to laugh too. Other than her infectious laugh, you do start finding the humor in what she did too.

“You are incorrigible.” You jokingly tell Brooke.

“I don’t know the meaning of the word.” Brooke replies, putting on a deeper voice than normal. “I mean I do, but I didn’t want to ruin your reference.” Brooke then quickly adds.

*THUD*

“Freeze!” You both hear Viv shout, causing the two of you to turn towards her. Viv’s aiming finger guns at both you and Brooke, her legs in a wide stance with her knees bent, and showing off that she hasn’t bothered to dress herself after your activities last night.

“Vegan Police!” Viv finally adds, jumping on the Scott Pilgrim movie reference bandwagon.

You immediately laugh at Viv’s absurdity, but quickly regret that decision once you realize that Brooke isn’t laughing. You turn towards her and see that Brooke’s squinting her eyes in anger. Whether it’s the joking kind of anger… you’re not sure yet.

“Oh yeah, B~...” Viv says teasingly, before showing you and Brooke that she’s still wearing the Wonder Woman bracelets from her ‘costume’. “You missed out on the Fuck-This League orgy.” Viv tells Brooke with a similarly devious smile from the one Brooke had before.

“You did it without me!?” Brooke asks you, as she repeatedly slaps you on your arms and chest.

“Ow-ow-ow!” You immediately exclaim, while Viv cackles in satisfaction. “We didn’t do anything without you!” You say to defend yourself.

“Well~, not anything.” Viv immediately undermines your defense.

“But we didn’t do the costumed orgy!” You rephrase, finally getting Brooke to stop. But the reprieve is short lived. Brooke bends down to pick up Viv’s Wonder Woman one piece, still lying on the floor in a heap after she undressed last night. Brooke dangles it in front of you like it’s a smoking gun.

“Viv was the only one who brought a costume!” You explain. “I didn’t even get to see her in it-OW!” You unnecessarily tried to add, getting a harder slap from Brooke this time.

“Alright, alright. I lied. We didn’t do the Fuck-This League Orgy.” Viv finally joins your side of the argument. “But we did have an orgy.” Viv immediately takes it back, instigating Brooke further.

“Can you shut the fuck up, V?” You finally address Viv, after getting another slap from Brooke.

“Well, Daddy… I am incorrigible.” Viv teasingly replies. “Make me.” Viv adds, before giving you an air smooch.

“Can you guys keep it down?” Cassie suddenly, and groggily, says from behind the couch. She pops her head up from behind the backrest and raises her hand to say to Brooke.

“What are you doing on the couch?” Brooke asks Cassie.

“I-uh… I guess I fell asleep here after last night.” Cassie says, tucking a wild hair strand behind her ear, clearly embarrassed.

“We left her there cuz… well~... we ALL can’t fit in the bed.” Viv explains, laying on the implication very thick.

“I swear to God if Cassie’s naked behind that couch…” You hear Brooke mutter under her breath, before she exclaims in shock. Stella’s bedroom door swings open right next to Brooke, revealing Stella in all her glory behind it.

“Can you guys have your loud discussion somewhere farther away from my room?” Stella asks in annoyance.

“Do you normally sleep in the nude or are you just happy to see us?” Viv asks her teasingly.

“I’d ask you the same thing but I already know the answer.” Stella quips back.

“¡Buenos días!” Tanya suddenly greets everyone, appearing from behind Viv after exiting your bedroom. Tanya’s greeting is immediately followed by Maddy calling out to her from inside your bedroom.

“I told you you don’t need to get dressed, Maddy. Everyone’s still naked.” Tanya calls out to Maddy. Maddy then shyly exits your bedroom, covering up her breasts and privates as she’s not as comfortable yet with this level of public nudity.

“Alright. That’s it.” Brooke says in frustration, before swiftly taking her top off.

“Oh~, I like where this is going.” Viv giddily comments.

“Nope! Nuh-uh. This is MY turn.” Brooke quickly tries to lower Viv’s expectations. “None of you get to join.” Brooke tells all your other girlfriends.

“But we still get to watch, right?” Viv asks Brooke.

“What is wrong with you?” Stella asks Viv.

“Where do I even start?” Viv asks back. “Also! Kind of rich coming from you.” Viv points out the irony in Stella’s question, getting Cassie to chuckle.

“Pants off, mister!” Brooke directs you.

“Not exactly the best way to put me in the mood, Brooke.” You jokingly tell her.

“Thank your lucky stars Becca’s not here to hear you yuck her yum.” Viv tells you.

“Where is Becca anyway?” Maddy asks.

“Pft. Like she’s not naked here somewhere.” Brooke says dismissively, before pulling her own shorts down to fully join all the other girls in their birthday suits.

“Did she even come by last night?” Cassie asks, finally joining her co-girlfriends being naked near the entryway.

“I don’t think so.” You answer, before looking towards Viv.

“Don’t look at me.” Viv tells you.

“You’re the one who stayed behind with her in the restaurant.” You point out.

“Yeah, but she had her own ride. Pretty sure she went home.” Viv tells you.

“Wait, so Becca wasn’t in the orgy?” Brooke asks.

“Technically~, it was a reverse gangbang.” Viv corrects Brooke.

“I technically~ don’t care!” Brooke fires back in annoyance, and Viv just smiles at getting underneath Brooke’s skin.

“You’re the one who asked.” Viv points out to annoy Brooke further.

“I wasn’t asking about the technicalities of group sex!” Brooke shouts back.

“Alright!” Tanya intervenes between the two. “Whatever it was we did last night—no, Brooke. Becca wasn’t here for it.” Tanya finally answers Brooke.

“Oh.” Brooke says in disappointment.

“What’s wrong?” You ask, picking up on Brooke’s tone.

“I mean, it’s one thing if you all did it without me and I’m just taking my turn. Now it feels like I’m just one upping the other person that wasn’t in on it too.” Brooke explains.

“By that logic, Becca already had her turn in our office anyway.” Viv tells Brooke, getting Brooke to squint her eyes as she considers Viv’s argument. “And if you really~ think about it…” Viv then says, before closing in on Brooke to whisper something in her ear.

“You’re the only who didn’t get fucked last night.” Viv loudly whispers into Brooke’s ear, and you can see the look on Brooke’s eyes that she took that phrase as a challenge.

Brooke quickly moves Viv aside and gives you a look of determination, a look that you can only return an awkwardly scared but still definitely aroused smile to. Brooke then pulls your boxers down, springing your penis into action.

“We have ‘lift off’!” Viv shouts encouragingly. Brooke gives you a look that you can only interpret as ‘Seems like I got you in the mood just fine’, and you give her a shrug that can only say ‘There’s like six hot naked girls here!’

*DING-DONG*

“FUCK ME!” Brooke shouts in annoyance.

“That was the plan.” Viv jokes.

“Well, at least Becca’s not gonna be left out from watching me take my turn.” Brooke comments in frustration as she heads towards the door to open it. Since you were all gathered around the entryway near the front door, it didn’t take Brooke long before she swung the door open. Problem was, Brooke didn’t seem to realize that if it wasn’t Becca who rang the doorbell, then… well…

“AHHH!”