Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 11 by 12shadesofnight 12shadesofnight

What's next?

House rules

“Fuck, that’s it,” you mutter in between soft grunts of pleasure. You leisurely place a hand on Cassie’s head, then grab a fistful of her hair as you cum down her gagging throat.

Red-faced as she chokes on your meat, Cassie looks up at you with tears rolling down her beautiful face as she coaxes all of your cum out of you. She coughs as you hold her face to your crotch, but doesn’t put up any resistance even as it starts to change color.

Feeling that most of your cum has spilled down her throat, you pull her exhausted face off of your cock, the softening length of it shiny with spit and cum. As soon as her lips clear your cock, Cassie coughs raggedly and heaves in a huge breath of air as the final few spurts of your jizz land gently across her lips and nose.

You grab Cassie’s phone from the side and quickly take a few photos of her messed up face.

“That felt great, didn’t it? You loved every second of being held down there,” you say with a smirk.

Cassie laughs weakly but genuinely as she continues to wheeze, her hands on your thighs the only thing holding her up.

“I-I sure did,” she replies once she’s able to speak. “I love this cock! I love how weak and delicate it makes me feel."

“I bet you do, Babe,” you say with raised eyebrows. “You want me to grab you and fuck you wherever, whenever, and however I want. And you're going be a good girl for me when I do, won't you?"

“Do you want to take this to the bedroom?”

Your smile widens at her enthusiasm.

“Do me a favour first,” you say with a lighthearted laugh. You turn the phone around and show her her own freshly-fucked face in the photo. “Send this to Adam. Don’t worry, I’ll handle it if he gets mad at you.”

“Mm, okay,” Cassie agrees simply, taking her phone and working on following your directions with one hand while stroking your slightly-softening cock with the other. “But I’d like it better if he didn’t get upset in the first place. I’m into this as long as everyone’s enjoying themselves.”

At the display of consideration, you’re reminded of how cruel you’re being right now. You and Adam go way back, and Cassie has been sweet and friendly since they he introduced her to you. Even though they are unable to realise how you’re manipulating them, the magnitude of your betrayal is clear to you.

With your power, you could go after any girl who strikes your fancy. You don't have to corrupt the one woman your best friend adores.

It's just too bad you really really want to.

“...Don’t you worry about that. He gave us a free pass, you should trust that this is what he wants.” You pause and consider your next words carefully. “I think he understood that we’d have done this sooner or later, you know. He knows that we've always been sexually attracted to each other.”

Cassie blinks as she finds herself pushed onto her back on the rug of the living space, with you sliding your knee between her thighs and forcing them open. You brace yourself with your left arm above her head and gaze down at her startled expression.

“Let's not lie to ourselves: you and I wouldn't walk this back if he begged us to. As much as we value him, we'd both pick sex with each other before our relationships with him,” you declare. “He knows this and isn't letting go. No matter what happens between us, he’ll just have to live with the consequences.”

Your smile widens when her expression goes from surprise to warmth, and you see her climb slightly up the rug and grasp your penis gently before lining the pulsating, hot glans against her wet slit.

“Mmm, you’re right. And I see someone’s ready to go again,” she purrs, licking her lips and raising her head to kiss you before locking her arms around your neck and her legs around your hips loosely. "What was I thinking? I can't imagine letting go of you."

“That's right,” you whisper breathily as you lower your hips, smoothly penetrating her wet folds yet again. You groan as her cunt wraps around you lovingly, squeezing and massaging your shaft as it sinks into her depths. “You're on track to becoming my house slut."

“Geez, that sounds so weird and kinky at the same time,” Cassie sighs with pleasure as she stares into your eyes. “...Mmm... I’m not usually such a pushover...”

“Not with anyone else, only with me.” You kiss her ear gently as you pump into her. “It feels natural to obey me, doesn’t it? You can’t even imagine going against me.”

Yesss,” Cassie moans. “It does! Please, harder!”

You sigh as Cassie tightens around you and softly kisses your collarbone as you fuck her faster.

“Of course. I'll take my slut as hard and fast as I want to,” you whisper to her, and she locks her legs around your back and her arms around your neck securely. "Because you want to feel my affection, my lust. That validation is your ****."

You grunt and Cassie squeals as you slowly bring her upright, first on your knees and then, with the support of the couch and living room table, to your feet.

“Give it to me.” Cassie looks at you sexily as she grinds against your body. “Please? Let your slut make you feel good.”

You laugh as you start walking towards her and Adam’s bedroom and enter it. Cassie whimpers as you throw her onto the bed and climb on after her.

“You’re such a cutie, Cass,” you mutter as you pin her down once more.

Cassie blushes, but before she can reply you capture her lips with a searing kiss.

“You’re going to start wearing less clothes around the apartment... Or lingerie, if I’m in the mood for that,” you growl. “Make sure I can easily cop a feel of these...” You place a hand on her chest and squeeze. “...And your ass, too.”

“I will!" Cassie whimpers between moans.

“You’ll be wet and ready for me whenever I want you.”

“Whatever you want,” Cassie moans back, hooking her legs around you again. “I’m close... please, harder!”

You don’t need to be told twice, and pick up right where you left off. Cassie yelps as you plow into her cunt, and begins mewling quietly as she stares at you with love and worship in her eyes.

Maybe it’s the several orgasms she’s had already, but Cassie holds on for much longer this time, pushing back against your thrusts and matching your rhythm without cumming... But eventually, she can’t hold back anymore.

“Jooohn,” she cries out helplessly. Her nails dig into your back, her eyes bug out, anf she’s leaking a whole mess of juices. “I'm close!”

Your pleasure spikes, and you allow your control to slip.

Cum!

Cassie surprises you by pulling your face down and kissing you just as your orgasms hit, and you moan into each other’s mouths as the pleasure washes over you. Jet after jet of thick, warm cum packs into Cassie’s welcoming cunt as your sweaty bodies writhe against each other.

Cassie’s strength finally gives out, and she lets go of her grip on your body and splays underneath you, letting go of your lips and smiling in a complete daze.

“I- I love you so much for this,” she laughs, and winces as your cock jerks inside of her sensitive pussy. “W-wait, gimme a break. You’re going to kill me if you get hard again.”

You quietly roll off and lay down beside her, before pulling her exhausted body close to yours.

“Relax,” you say with a laugh. “I need to rest too, despite what John Jr. might tell you.”

Cassie doesn’t respond, already fast asleep and breathing slowly on your chest.

A few blissful minutes later, you close your eyes and join her.

What’s next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)