Her first dick measuring contest

Pushing my cock into her tight opening, I say, “Tell me about the contest.”

She sighs, “It’s going to be tough to concentrate with that in me but I’ll try.”

She wiggles against me, pushing me deeper into her. She moans. I feel so comfortable inside her.

“It was back in college. Some random Friday night. Between 3:00 and 4:00 am when everybody should be in bed. Me and my girlfriend were in a corner room of a frat house. Six guys were trying to wait it out to see who could fuck us. I guess that figured that whoever didn’t go to bed got the right to sleep with us. We were all drunk and high. I bluntly asked, ‘How many of you are trying to fuck us?’

“All six raised their hands. They were shy about it. I suggested a contest. We’d go to bed with the biggest dicks, but we wouldn’t just go by their word. We’d have to measure in front of everyone. Unbelievably all six agreed. I told them to pull their pants down, and not to touch themselves. If they could get hard without touching themselves, we would allow it. But with five other naked men in the room; it wasn’t happening easily. The measuring was diabolical. We didn’t have a ruler. We had one-on-one matches. The guys had to face each other and hold their dicks in front of them. Then we’d decide who was bigger.

“It was a very insightful contest. The one guy who got hard made it into the top three, but there were two guys who towered over the rest and they couldn’t be more different. One guy was small in stature, but his dick was a rope, hanging almost to his knees. The other guy was more than a foot taller than him, and had a tree trunk between his legs.”

Fucking her at a good pace, I ask, “Which one did you fuck? The small guy or the giant?”

She moans at my pace, “Both. Then the other four guys. My friend only fucked the short guys with the long dick, but I ended up fucking all six. They stayed up so late. They deserved a treat. They just needed to bring their own condom.”

She arches into me as I bury myself even deeper into this well used pussy. “You are the most generous slut. Too bad I never met you in college.”

The thought of her fucking six guys in a single night drives me wild. Those guys must still talk about her. I wonder what nickname they gave her.

“Did any of them make you come?”

“No, but the attention felt good,” Phoebe sighs.

“Am I going to make you come?”

“Oh yeah. I’m so close,” she wraps my arms around her. “Hold me tight as I come.”

The door opens, and the light turns on. Joey booms, “Alright. Game’s over. Get back to your room.”