Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 17 by OppositeOfMiddle OppositeOfMiddle

What do we choose?

Give us some help

Joey answers, “You helped out Ross. Can’t you see we’re throbbing for you.”

Phoebe smiles looking down at our cocks, “Oh I can’t definitely see how eager you are. I just wasn’t sure if the excitement was for me or each other.”

“How can I not be excited for you?” I ask. “You’re so sexy. I want you in my lap, riding me.”

Phoebe says, “You know what one of my fantasies is? Getting stuffed by two big cocks. You guys definitely qualify if you want to try.”

Joey stands up, “I’ll get the lube.” He runs off to his room, his massive cock flopping side to side.

Phoebe twirls her finger around my cock head, “Unfortunately you don’t get to fuck my ass tonight. I’m worried how this thing would stretch me. Joey has been in my ass plenty of times so I’m not worried about his.”

“Holy fuck, I can’t wait to watch this,” Ross says. “No way you’ll be able to fit them both in you at the same time, even if they are in different holes. You’re way too small. Maybe Monica could do it.”

Did he just take a jab at my wife’s size? I ignore it, but I’m also curious if this will work. Phoebe is a petite woman. Her pussy will be a tight fit without someone else jammed up her ass.

Phoebe says, “We’ll make it work. Either way we’ll have fun trying.” She grabs my hand and brings it down to her pussy. I prod a fingertip between her lips and feel her wet moan. She moans, and bends forward and kisses me. Her tongue aggressively swirls into my mouth. Her teeth bite on my lower lip. She’s ravenous.

Joey sprints back into the room with lube and a condom. Out of breath, he asks, “Alright babe, how do you want to do this.”

Phoebe stops kissing me and answers, my fingers still in her pussy. “I figure that Chandler stays sitting on the couch. I’ll ride him, bend forward a little. And Joey you’re so tall, you shouldn’t have a problem with the angle of getting into my ass. While Ross did rail me out the fire, you’ll have to warm me up again. Lots of lube and lots of fingering.”

After her commands, she didn’t waste any time mounting me. No additional foreplay. She straddled my hips, and angled my cock. She slowly slides down on it. Fuuuuck. Who knew a slut could this be right after getting fucked by every walking dick. Her warm walls grip my cock.

Phoebe moans, “Oh Chandler I’ve been waiting for this for so long. Mmm I never imagined you’d have such a thick cock. I loooove it.” She sits until I’m fully inside her. She closes her eyes and enjoys the feeling.

The feeling is amazing, but I can’t resist. I reach up and twist the piercings on her nipples. Her eyes opens and she cries, “Ahhhh fuck,” and slaps me on the chest. She bites her lip. “You naughty boy. You’re lucky I like pain.”

Joey walks up behind her. She jumps, and my cock almost pops out. She yells, “Warm up your finger first, hunny!”

I look around her and watch Joey blow on his fingers, then lower his hand to his wife’s ass. I feel his hand graze the bottom of my shaft. Then Phoebe moans as her husband’s finger enters her. Her breathing increases, and she says, “Oh this is going to be fun.”

Her hips ride me, and her pussy walls squeeze my cock, but there is a new feeling. I can feel the bulge of Joey’s finger press against my cock. _Fuck me. _If that what it feels like with just his finger, no way there will be enough room for his massive dick.

“Adding another finger,” Joey says.

Phoebe moans, “Oh fuck. Oh my god I already feel so full.”

“Come lube up my dick for me,” Joey asks Ross.

Ross walks over and takes the lube. He rolls the condom onto Joey hard cock, and then squirts a ton of lube onto it. Ross stands up and says, “That’s why I was your best man.”

Joey makes eye contact with me, and says, “I hope you’re ready for this.” He pushes his wife forward so she is bent over and her ass presents to him. She rests her head on my shoulder.

Through Phoebe’s pussy, I can feel his large mushroom head push into her asshole. Phoebe grunts and lets out a little cry. Joey asks, “Are you okay? It’s just the tip right now.”

Through clenched teeth Phoebe answers, “Yes. Take it slow.” She has stopped working my cock, and sits still on me as her husband pushes it. The pressure from his dick on my cock feels tremendous and I let out a little moan. Phoebe screams then bites down on my shoulder as her husband pushes his massive cock deeper into her.

He stops thrusting and rests. He asks again, “Are you okay hunny? You feel so fucking tight.”

She lets go of her bite. I know she broke skin, and I over and see blood. She moans out, “Fuck me. Fuck me.”

Joey looks at me and smiles. I feel his cock, slide out and then back in. It feels incredible on my cock. I close my eyes in pleasure. He’s fucking his wife’s ass and jerking my cock at the same time. Fuck I’m now going to be able to last much longer.

Neither is Phoebe. While her moans are giving some pleasure, her face shows that she’s in pain. She is getting stuffed so hard in both her holes.

Joey grunts, “No homo but the feel of your thick cock is gonna make me come. Holy fuck she’s so tight.”

He comes first. I feel his cock throb in her asshole. That feeling sends me over the edge. I come inside Phoebe. My cum pumps into her. I grunt, and feel Joey slide out of his wife’s asshole.

Phoebe sighs in relief, then starts working her hips. Her pussy slides up and down my cum covered cock. Her clit rubs against me. She presses her tits into my mouth, and I suck until she comes. She grips and pulls my hair as she screams. “Mmm oh my god!”

She goes limp on me, and rests her head on my shoulder. My hard cock is still deep inside her. Her chests breathes up and down. She keeps muttering, “Oh my god. Oh my god.” Over and over again.

A bedroom door clicks and swings open. Footsteps prod across the floor. My wife’s voice asks, “What’s going on out here? I thought we were done for the night after the fun out by the campfire?”

How do it answer?

  • No further chapters
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)