Ask her for consent

“Doe. You are so wonderful. So beautiful. You are the only woman for me. I don’t think I’ll ever love another.” You tell the angel as you are humping her. “I need you. So please. Let me fuck you.”

“I can’t.” Doe whimpers.

You don’t get it. Her body and tone of her voice say she wants your dick, but her words say the opposite. What is holding her back?

“Why?” You say, adding some desperation in your voice for dramatic effect.

“You humans have it easy. Since you were never meant to be perfect you can make any mistake you want and be forgiven for it. As an angel I was not just made to be perfect but am also expected to be perfect. The slightest sin is enough to get me cast out of heaven forever.” Doe explains.

“And sex is a sin?” You ask.

“If I let you in there, I’ll lose my hymen.” Doe says as she looks up to you desperately. “When that happens, I won’t be perfect any more. Don’t get me wrong. I care for you deeply. I … I love you. I want you. But since only perfect beings can enter heaven, losing my virginity will mean I lose my chance to return home forever.”

So that’s the reason. Having sex with you means far more than losing her virginity. Dammit, why does heaven need to have such stupid rules. Then again, if you did take her virginity, she’d be staying here with you forever. Would that really be so bad for her?