Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 19 by grimbous grimbous

You have to keep it up, but with who?

Abigail, but she destroys your ego. SPH Style.

"Ahhh...don't stop you two..." Abigail hisses through the pain of the stinging tendril. "...ssssss...I don't think I was active enough...we have to keep it going or we get punished..."

You guide Nuru off of you. Her mouth slides off you with a slurping 'pop'. She has a strange expression on her face, her eyes darting to you then to Abigail.

"Not active enough eh? Well let's fix that then!" You say as you grab Abigail and lay her down in front of you, she laughs despite the recent pain of the tendril and opens herself wide to accept you. "I can't wait, a real human man!" She confesses. "I have dreamed of this. I really have."

You position yourself. "Are you ready?" You ask Abigail.

"Uh huh." She whimpers, biting her lip as she readies for you.

"Umm...Abigail...I should really warn you...about him..." Nuru says from behind you.

Ignoring Nuru you place your cock up to Abigail's wet slit. You look at her, she stares back excitedly. Absolutely giddy with anticipation. You press forward, driving your cock into her. You slip right in.

You...slip...right...in. All the way. Do not pass go, do not collect $200.

You are balls deep and you hardly brushed a wall.

She smiles up at you with that same look of excitement and anticipation. "Go ahead. Please. I can't wait!" She nods again and bites her lip. "Stop teasing..."

You are stunned for a moment. You take a few test thrusts into her gaping hole...and the realization suddenly hits you. You remember the massive tools of most of the futas. You remember the girthy veiny tentacles and tongues ravishing Abigail just hours before, each one was at least twice as thick as you and plunging as deep as they could go. And there had been two of them up her snatch! Who knows what other creatures she has experienced in her time here. Day after day, year after year of all manner of alien. All of the women here would already have had multiple lifetime's worth of sexual experiences that you couldn't even imagine yet. Or hope to compare to!

To make matters worse these women have been here so long, with so few men around, that they had completely forgotten all about the fragile male ego. They also had absolutely zero sense of boundaries or discretion when it came to discussing sex. They just spoke what they thought, pure and unfiltered.

"Oh wait...there you are. You are in. I can hardly feel you." She giggles. "Sorry, I just had that visitor yesterday." She keeps giggling for a time before bursting out into all out laughter, at least the convulsions of the laughter made her tighten up a bit. "It's just so...so...TINY! Can you see this Nuru? It's so tiny!"

"I saw it, I had it in my mouth remember? I tried to warn you! Visitor yesterday or no...that is really REALLY small." Nuru says guffawing, joining in the hilarity. "I thought it was just the rum and the bad angle last night, but no...that's just sad."

"I wasn't looking down there when you were erect with the futa." Abigail admits as she composes herself. "I was watching your face...I was worried about you."

'Fuck this! I'll show her!' You think. You pull all the way back then slam all the way in...all the way out, all the way in...all the way out, all the way in. You absolutely plow as hard and deep as you can. Slop...slop...slop. A crude wet noise accompanied every thrust into her spacious pussy. Her soft rippling tits with their big pointed brown nipples flop and jiggle with each impact.

"Yeah! That's it." She nods. "Keep it up and you'll be hard in no time. Come on."

"He is hard Abigail." Nuru informs her.

"Yeah right!" She laughs. "I mean fully...you know, engorged."

"Guys!" You grunt. "God dammit! I'm perfectly average for a human!" You feel a hot blush spread across your face. You try to stop, to pull out, but you instantly get the lash. SNAP! "Ah!" You are **** to keep on fucking her, your rod nearly falling out of her loose cunt with each back stroke.

In your mind the tickle around the edges was now a rapidly growing fuzzy tingle. The more your shame grew so too the tingle, the empathic visitor had found something it liked! It found something that really got it horny.

"Woah! Did you guys feel that? Whatever we are doing our visitor likes it. It really likes it!" Smiles Nuru. "And I'm not even doing anything. Whatever we are doing it is working for it. You two keep having sex and we'll keep talking. Save some for me though, I want try your little guy too."

"I wonder what it is the visitor likes?" Says Abigail curiously, then addressing you. "It must be something going on with you. Am I making you feel good? You're not doing anything for me yet...on account of your penis being so ridiculously tiny."

"Guys!" You grunt once more. The tingle was growing to an ever present buzz. This visitor was really getting off on the emotions it was picking up right now. You had had enough, you go to yell at the girls, to give them hell for belittling you, to tell them how hurtful their words are. Nothing comes out, not even a croak. The collar...the fucking collar! The alien knew you wanted to stop what was happening but it was enjoying this way too much. You stop fucking in protest and instantly get the lash once more. SNAP!

You can't even scream in pain at the horrible electrified tendril. You start slamming into her once more, the slurp slorp of your driving into her ruined cunt filling the room. Your face burns with indignity.

"Don't stop, it will hurt you! Just keep going." Abigail says as she settles into the bed some more and tilts her hips up to give you maximum possible penetration. She has a determined look on her face. "It's okay, I know you're just getting warmed up. From what I remember of human men it gets bigger as you go...A LOT bigger!" She smiles up at you. "Thank goodness, imagine if we had to do this with only that puny thing? Ha ha ha." Her laughter causes her wide tunnel to contract, allowing you to feel her a bit more. "C'mon give it to me! Show me! Oh God, I can't wait to feel it!"

Nuru is now sitting beside the two of you cross-legged, chin resting on one hand. "Abigail..." She says patiently. "...umm Abigail. I don't...I don't he gets any bigger. He was hard in my mouth and it stopped growing pretty damn quick." She looks at you. "That's it isn't it? That's all you've got? You're cock...it's fully erect...it's really that small isn't it?"

You try to respond, but of course you couldn't. The collar blocking all forms of communication. Oh how you wish they'd just stop talking. The alien is actually physically shaking a bit, it's tendrils swinging around it's main body. That bastard was having a fucking ball!

Abigail, sweet kind Abigail, tries to defend your honor. "Nuru...you stop teasing him! He's going to get a lot bigger, you'll see! A lot bigger! There is simply no way this is all he's got! I think I already feel him growing a bit." This of course wasn't true. "It kind of tickles, it's really quite nice. I only had two partners before I left Earth, but I remember human men getting bigger and bigger and bigger. It was so very long ago however, but I definitely remember them being very satisfying. Not like this at all."

You keep thinking. 'Shut up, please just shut up so we can get through this!' She had no idea the disgrace she was heaping on you.

She looks at you. "Come on...I know this can't be it. I know you can't be this small. Just relax, let it happen. Am I doing something wrong? Come on, let me feel you!" She really bears down on you with her kegel muscles, you feel the walls of her pussy constrict around your meat. "I can't remember that last time I felt such a teeny tiny sex organ."

You keep pounding away at her, sliding your meat back and forth down her fleshy tunnel. It felt good, no doubt, but so fucking loose. A crude wet slurking sound accompanies each thrust. You constantly worry about popping out. Oh how you wish you could stop.

"Why aren't you talking? Are you okay?" Abigail asks. "Why isn't he talking Nuru? Am I doing something wrong? Something's wrong."

"I think that's just man sex for you Abigail." Nuru says. "It's all business with them. I'm pretty sure it's normal, I wouldn't worry."

"Oh, okay then. They were kind of the strong silent types now that I remember."

"Yeah, even moreso during sex. Men are even more alien than...well...most aliens. They're weird." Nuru rubs her shoulder. "Don't worry, we probably won't hear from him again until he cums. I'm not even sure he can hear us."

"He talked last night...with the futa." Abigail replies.

"Yeah, but he finished so quick he probably wasn't able to get into a proper state of mind. And more importantly, you're an actual human female. Probably something hormonal." Nuru informs her.

"Okay...I'm learning. It's been so long. Men are so strange." She smiles and addresses you. "Although...it would be really neat if you could...you know...get to full size. Really really neat. I'd really like that. Please? So we both can enjoy this." You pound into her hard, plunging to your absolute limit, to little effect.

Nuru sighs, exasperated by Abigail's naive faith in you. "I'm telling you Abi...that's it...that's all he's got. That's the whole damn thing. Hell, judging by last night he's probably halfway done already. Do you want me to help? I could get my hand..."

Nuru was really getting Abigail's dander up now. "Would you please stop teasing him Nuru! No wonder he can't perform. He only came that quick last night because it was a futa. I've heard they are really crazy on the inside." She begins pushing her hips up against your thrusts. "Show her...show Nuru how wrong she is. Come on! Please!" There is an almost **** quality to her pleads, her fantasy was unraveling.

Nuru lays down beside Abigail, both hands behind her head looking up at you. "Don't listen to me then. Go ahead big boy...prove me wrong."

You are grunting and fucking. You start to feel the point of no return approaching in your balls. Your face is still flush in embarrassment, the alien is vibrating and starting to hop around a bit. The buzzing in your head floats over your mind, exploring and delving into your humiliation. You stop once more, this was all too much!

SNAP!

You get back to it, the searing sizzling pain spreading through your back. Her white tits with her big brown nipples bounce up and down as you ram into her, her face displays not a hint of passion. The women keep up their friendly chatting, like a Sunday afternoon in a cafe. You keep up your fucking, clenching your jaw and doing your best to enjoy what you could of the experience.

"Wow, our visitor is so happy! This is great. It's something going on between those two." Nuru says indicating you and the alien.

You actually see disappointment creep into Abigail's sweet face as the truth really sets in. "That's...that's really it? That's all you've got isn't it? I just seem to remember...differently. I remember it...really filling me up." She sighs. "It's been so long. Of course I'd forget. So...you say this is an average man..."

She looks to Nuru. "Was Micheal this...lacking. Was his so small?" Abigail asks.

"I dunno, he never even came near us, you know that. He was always with the special ones." Nuru answers. "But, uh, they seemed pretty happy with him...and I don't think..."

Special ones?

"He said he's average size Nuru." Abigail again defends you. "Micheal was probably just the same. Earth men are just this size, and that's okay. It's not so bad really, it kind of...uh...it feels just ducky. And sometimes he rubs it just right..."

"Hey, I've been here longer than you, so I'm not sure what average is...but...." Nuru clears her throat, she rolls over and whispers loudly in Abigail's ear, convinced you can't really hear anything anyways. You can hear every word. "I got to see an Earth sex movie as a gift a few years ago...all the men in it were like a foot long."

You keep pumping away but this was so humiliating! The hollow slurp slorp slurp slorp of your fucking filling the hut. The buzzing of the creatures arousal hummed in every crevice of your mind.

Abigail gives her a concerned sideways glance then looks back to you. "Oh, I do wish you'd say something. Anything. I feel like I'm doing something wrong. Look at his expression Nuru. Something's wrong. Maybe that's why it won't grow. Maybe the size is based on how much he likes someone. Can you talk? Please talk to me."

"Forget it Abi." Says Nuru as she rolls onto her back, hands behind her head. "He's in sex mode now, it probably shuts off the higher functions in his brain or something. Can you even hear us? Hello? Anyways, the show I saw it was all moaning and grunting once the action started. The women were real happy, but I mean the guys were all like twice his size."

"Twice his size you say..." Abigail's voice trails off for a second. "That would be at least decent. That would be big enough. But...it's not even so much the length..."

"Oh I know...the girth, or lack there of." Nuru holds up a finger and a thumb in an O above them. "It's only about so thick."

"No...no stop...that's it? Really, that's it!?" Her eyes shift from Nuru's hand to your face, her look going from one of humor to one of dismay. "That's it?"

"That's it." Nuru answers. "I can reach all the way around so my fingers touch. I know I've got long fingers, but still."

Obviously Abigail's imagination had back filled most of her actual memories. She was still coming to grips with this whole situation. Curiosity gets the better of her, she asks Nuru. "And...how long?"

"I dunno. Five, six, maybe seven inches tops. At least he's bigger than the futa from last night."

"Yeah...not by too much though. I really imagined this to be so different." She looks at you again. "It's really that short AND that thin? Wow. That's too bad...for me I mean. If you can hear me I'm just disappointed for myself. I was hoping for so much more, something I could really feel, ya know? Oh well, just do your best, okay? I'm still enjoying it. You do your best."

Nuru offers some consolence. "You did just have a visitor before bed Abigail."

"That's true, I am pretty stretched out from yesterday. Maybe it would feel better with Nuru?" She asks you. "Would you do better with Nuru? Maybe you like her better? Do you think you could satisfy her better?"

"Ha!" Nuru snorts. "I suppose...maybe. It's been way too long for me since I had a visitor. Maybe he could..." She looks again. "...maybe not." She laughs and slaps your shoulder. "Why is your pecker so goddamn small? Maybe it's a disorder."

You keep your hips moving despite the constant **** on your dignity. The tendrils whips were too painful to stop, besides the collar would just make you do it if you stopped anyways. The creature was now wiggling side to side. It was absolutely relishing your distressed yet sexually aroused emotions right now.

Their complete oblivious honesty is really what made the shame so bad. They weren't saying this stuff for affect, like a dirty talking whore trying to get a rise out of you. It was just their genuine honest reaction. They truly had no clue of the ego destroying brutality of what they were unleashing on you. They were just discussing a thing they found really interesting in the most direct way possible. You wished SO much that they'd just be quiet, that they'd just shut the fuck up, but they just kept on talking and talking.

Abigail starts making excuses for you. "He just had sex last night, maybe it takes some time to get big again. And besides, it's his first day here."

You were getting really close now. You are moaning and huffing as you pick up the pace, slamming yourself into her slack sucking pussy with all you had.

"His first day? What's that got to do with anything?" Nuru chides and giggles. "First day doesn't change his teeny baby wang."

"It's not a baby wang Nuru, it's just really super um...petite, okay. He said it's average Nuru. And...I dunno...maybe it...." She looks at you.

You grunt and huff some more, you were right on the edge.

"My, you're really getting into this now! Are you okay? I think this is it Nuru, he's about to really show us what he's got!" Abigail is really happy, hope springing eternal. "Oh thank goodness, thank goodness! Let me feel you!"

"Oh shit. He's about to cum." Observes Nuru, correctly. "I didn't even get my turn. You're cumming already...aren't you?" She sighs in exasperation.

Abigail titters. "Oh stop Nuru...No...he's just getting into it that's all. Oh boy, I can't wait. Now we can really get started. There's no possible way he's cumming this fast, I mean since he...."

You try to cry out in passion but can't. You shudder as you spray your thick creamy load into Abigails lax cunt, painting her walls with your hot white jizz. Grunting and spasming you as you jerk wildly on top of her. You hunch onto her as you finish, sweaty and panting.

"What are you...are you...Oh no!" Cries Abigail. "Noooo. Not yet! We were just getting going...awwww... You did just cum. That's it? Really? That just...can't be it, can it? So short, so thin, and no stamina either? Ohhh nooo...this isn't how I dreamed of this at all." Then she gives you a sad but benevolent 'good for you' sort of expression.

You cock twitches and pulses, flopping around inside her. You feel your warm seed flowing out around your balls. The enveloping buzzing in your mind has never been stronger, it is at a fever pitch. The alien is repeatedly jumping half a foot of the ground, it's tendrils spiraling around it. It seemed to be having some sort of climax too.

"Was it good for you?" Nuru jokes to Abigail. "It was for them." She indicates you and the alien.

Both girls share a good long laugh, though Abigail's is laced with disenchantment. It seems that for Abigail this was like meeting a favorite celebrity only to find out they are a flawed asshole. Her fantasy has been burst.

She is really quiet while you catch your breath, your deflating cock instantly flaps out of her spacious pussy. She finally gives you a tight hug. "I want you to really listen to me. I don't care how small you are. I don't care if you can never satisfy me with your penis. I don't care you hardly last any time at all. I like you so much, even if you are really bad at sex. Okay? You hear me? I really like you."

"Really, really bad at sex." Nuru chirps.

"Yeah..." Abigail is **** to agree. "That could never satisfy me, even at my horniest and tightest...but you know what?" She strokes your back. "He did his best. Didn't you? You gave it your all and that's what counts. I'm sure a woman back on Earth would have loved that. Nuru and I don't care how inadequate you are in bed, okay? We're still your friends, okay? I'm really so happy it felt so good for you." She adds cheerfully. "Really, I mean it, good for you! You did real good."

She was encouraging you like a Mom at her kid's soccer game. Terrific.

You try to respond, to say anything, but nothing comes out. Did the alien still have plans for his playthings?

Does this SPH go on?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)