“No." (virgin route)

Without thinking you respond “No.” cupping your sister’s head and pulling her in to plant your lips on hers once more. Your sister lets out a soft moan into your lips. Her hands tighten on your hips turning and pushing you, while Sarah’s and mouth withdraw.

Unwittingly following your sisters lead you vaguely feel something bump against the back of your thighs. You soon find out as your sister suddenly pushes you, breaking the kiss, a gasp torn from your mouth at the lack of stimulation and the sensation of falling, before it is quickly broken by your sister’s bed.

Mind clouded by lust, stiff nipples, and glistening peach displaying your arousal you blink up at your sister and Sarah.

“Your brother’s an idiot” Sarah says, as she sits down on the bed next to you and her hands begin to caress you. The comment slowly penetrates your mind; as you find yourself staring at her body now clad only a matching pair of lacy underwear.

Opening your mouth to defend yourself all that comes out is a startled groan as Sarah’s finger slowly pushes past your nether lips. “No surprise there” you hear your sister says as she settles on the bed on your other side, your eyes are locked on Sarah’s as her finger enters you.

“So tight and wet.” Sarah says smirking down at you. Before her finger gets too far it encounters resistance. Sarah’s pauses for a moment before her eyes go wide and she stares at you “You’re a virgin?” she asks surprise coloring her voice.

“What? No way” your sister says. Glancing over you find yourself staring directly at your sisters breasts. Now naked as you are she looks at you.

“See for yourself” Sarah says pulling her finger out of your, drawing a low gasp from you. The gasp turns into a moan as your sister’s finger enters you and again encounters the same resistance.

“My brother left a cute horny virgin all alone.” she states shaking her head looking over at Sarah and then down at you “Where did my brother go?” she asks.

Mind racing you try to think despite your lust addled mind. Telling her the truth would be awkward given that her finger is still inside you. Or come up with something else...