You fucked them both! Now what? (only pick the second time)

I rolled over onto the floor and held myself up in a half-sitting position with my hands on the floor behind me. I look at both gorgeous girls and can't believe what just happened. I fucked both my best friend and my sister. I could never have imagined this in a million years.

My reverie was broken by the sound of Lizz's voice as the two girls sat up on the couch facing me. We were all still gloriously naked.

"So, who's the winner?" she asked, cocking her head to the side. "Whose pussy is better, me or Ashley?"

Jeez, getting so caught up in the moment of fucking both girls I had totally forgotten that I was supposed to be evaluating their pussies. I had already declared that Lizz had the nicer boobs but that I like Ashley's ass better. But I had no idea how I could judge this one, they were both totally fantastic. Could I cop out and declare it a tie? Would Lizz go for that?

“Jeez, Lizz, I kinda lost track of the contest, what with fucking two hot girls and all,” I laughed. “I mean, like, you were both great, what can I say? Can we just call it a tie?” I asked hopefully.

Lizz and Ash just looked at each other then burst out laughing. It seemed like the girls were ganging up against me now. I wasn’t sure where this was going to go.

“Really, James?” Lizz cocked her head. “A tie? No, you can’t get out of it so easy. I guess we’re just going to have to continue this contest. What do you think, Ash?”

Ash giggled, looking at Lizz and winking. “Yeah, I agree. He needs to make a decision one way or the other. What should we make him do?”