Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 18

What do they want you to do next?

The blowjob challenge

I know,” Ash piped up. “So far he’s compared our tits and our asses and then felt, tasted and fucked our pussies. But he hasn’t compared anything we might do to him. Like a blowjob, for example. Maybe he should decide who gives a better blowjob?”

“Great idea, Ash,” Lizz giggled too. “So come over here, bro, let’s see if this helps you make up your mind.”

I couldn’t believe they wanted to keep this going. After just fucking the both of them, I wasn’t sure if I would be ‘up’ for it or not. But I didn’t really have a choice. The game had gone too far to back out now.

I walked over to the sofa and stood between the two girls. “So who wants to go first?"

They both grabbed for my currently semi-flaccid love stick and each tried to pull it toward herself. They were playing tug-of-war with my cock and while I felt flattered it really wasn’t helping it to get hard again.

“Hey, c’mon, make up your minds,” I protested. “Neither one of you is going to win this way. Guess I’ll have to choose. Ash, you go first.”

Lizz pouted and Ashley grinned. Ash got her hand firmly around my cock and pushed Lizz’s hand away.

“I told you he liked me best,” she teased Lizz.

“Well, get to it and stop wasting time, girl. I want to suck his cock too.”

Ash put her other hand on my slowly reviving member and pulled it up to her mouth She teased the tip with her tongue then licked up and down the entire length of my shaft. She swirled her tongue all around my thick rod while also pumping it with her hand using a kind of twisting motion. My staff was already throbbing and she hadn’t even gotten it into her mouth yet. As she continued working it with her hand, she slowly took it in between her soft lips moving down over the tip, past the glans then excruciatingly inch by inch. My cock was tingling and throbbing like never before as she swallowed me all the way in until the head hit the back of her throat.

“Oh god, Ash, that feels so good,” I moaned. I put a hand in her hair, just to run my fingers through it not to **** her onto me harder or anything. I wanted to let her set her own pace. She continued sucking, pulling back until I was almost out then pushing back down on my entire length all the way to the hilt. She sucked her cheeks in trying to make her mouth as tight around my cock as she could. She let my dick pop out for a minute while she caught her breath.

“So you like how I suck cock, James?” she asked unnecessarily. “I’m going to make sure I’m the winner.” She grinned, then wrapped her lips around my girth again and began earnestly bobbing back and forth on my stiff rod. She took my balls in one hand and massaged them firmly yet gently, leading to more shocks to run up my body.

I looked over at Lizz on the sofa and she again had her hand between her legs and was watching Ashley work my cock with a hungry look on her face. I was surprised to see her get up and slide over next to Ashley in front of me.

“I can’t take it any longer, I have to get in on this,” she moaned. She stuck her head between my legs and started licking and sucking on my balls while Ashley continued massaging my cock with her mouth.

“Hey, what is this?” I asked in surprise. “I thought you were going to do me one at a time?”

“Well, I guess we were going to, but I can’t wait any longer,” Lizz spoke in between taking first one testes into her mouth then the other. “I guess you’re going to have to make your evaluation based on who does the best while double-teaming you,” she grinned.

“Switch!” Ash announced, letting my cock pop free from her mouth and pointing it toward Lizz’s mouth. Lizz let go of my balls and grabbed my cock with both hands then began to slowly swallow it. In the meantime, Ash bent down and started taking my balls into her mouth one by one gently massaging them with her tongue. Lizz took me all the way in to her throat with no problem, her nose bouncing on my pubic hair above my surging staff. She squeezed the tip with her throat while swirling around the main shaft with her tongue. Then she started bobbing back and forth like Ash had done, only faster and harder.

The sensations caused by these two hot women sucking on my cock and balls was getting to be almost more than I could stand. “Oh jesus, girls,” I moaned. “You two sure know how to drive a guy wild. I’m not sure how much more I can take.”
They both paused and looked up at me with big grins on their faces. Then almost as if on cue, like they did this all the time, they began to simultaneously lick up and down the length of my cock while keeping their eyes on my face. They met for a kiss at the top of my rod, trapping my glans between their two pairs of lips. Then they started humming and moaning against my shaft as they moved back and forth up and down again. Electric shocks were running all through me now, my body actually starting to quiver as I came closer and closer to reaching the top of the mountain. I knew I was going to explode any minute now and I knew it was going to be a huge load.

“Oh god! Oh jeez!” I moaned. “Look out, girls, I’m about to explode,” I warned them. But they didn’t slow down at all but started taking turns back and forth sucking my aching member all the way into their hot wet mouths. After a couple of times doing this, I couldn’t hold back any longer. I pulled out of Ash’s mouth and before Lizz could suck me in again, I grabbed my hot throbbing cock with both hands and pointed it at their faces. I exploded with a fury, jet after jet of my hot jizz blasting into their faces as I aimed it back and forth covering both of them with my huge load of spunk. They opened their mouths and tried to catch some and swallow it but there was just too much and most of it ended up painting their faces, their hair and even dripping down onto their naked tits.

After I finally subsided and my body stopped shaking, they leaned back a little and started wiping my cum from their faces with their fingers and sucking it off in their mouths. Then they spontaneously started wiping it off each other’s face and sticking their fingers in each other’s mouths. When it was mostly gone, they wrapped their arms around each other and started French kissing, their tongues darting back and forth trading my cum between them.

I sank back down on the floor completely exhausted. The girls slowly separated with a big long string of my jizz hanging between their lips and looked over at me.

“Wow, James, that was quite a performance,” Lizz laughed. “I wish I had known before now that my brother was such a stud.”

“I agree,” Ash chimed in. “To think we’ve only been friends all these years and what I’ve been missing. Guess we’ll just have to try to make it up,” she winked at me.

We all sat there on the floor in a little circle for a few minutes, recovering from our latest sexcapade.

Finally, Lizz was the one who spoke up. “So, little bro, time to make a decision again. Who’s better sucking your cock, me or Ash?”

I had gotten so lost in sensations while getting a double blowjob for the first time, that there was no way I could have been evaluating anything. I hesitated, not having a clue what to say.

“So?” Ash asked impatiently. “Who’s it gonna be? And no copping out with ‘it’s a tie’ this time!”

So who do you choose?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)