You and Miranda

Three huge shocks

Sarah produces the first slip from the hat and brings it up to her eyes to read. “Miranda!” A little “woo!” From your left makes it clear that Miranda is more than happy about getting into the action. “Aaand . . . John! Aw, now I wish I hadn’t made you cum,” she pouts and eyes your limp cock in mock sadness before putting the hat down again. “Oh well, now you can return the favor. I dare you both to make me cum.”

"Ooh, this will be fun!" Miranda declares, hopping to her feet and pulling you up by the hand as well. You're glad that Miranda isn't jealous about this, but when you spare a glance back at Nicole you see her already sulking at being left alone. Before you can say anything to Nicole, or ask Sarah how exactly she wants you and Miranda to pleasure her, the buxom red haired girl gets to her own feet. With no shame or hesitation whatsoever, she unbuttons her jeans and shimmies them down her legs, struggling for a second to get them over the ample curves of her thighs. With that done the only thing covering her precious honeypot is a tiny pair of lacey black panties, panties that are soon yanked down too. A noticeable string of moisture clings briefly from Sarah's slit to her panties before breaking, as her underwear drops to the floor. Like it was the most natural thing in the world Sarah bares her neatly trimmed red pubes and her perfectly plump little pussy as she steps quickly out of her underwear.

While your jaw is still hanging open, Sarah sits back low on the couch, her legs parted widely and her crotch pressed forward so her wet slit is on full display. “Come on then. I’ve been waiting for this all night,” she exhales, running two fingers through the short hair of her bush to gently part her labia. You can’t help but stare at the sight, it’s like finally getting to be on the receiving end of a dare has made Sarah lose her mind. Miranda, however, hardly bats an eye as her friend shows off her wet little box like a pornstar. Instead she rolls her eyes and drops to her knees, so calm and unsurprised it’s almost like she’s done this before. You start to picture your crush on her knees with her brown haired head between the soft thighs of one of the sexiest women on campus, making Sarah twitch and moan as she shows off the benefits of friends-with-benefits. Before you can think about it too much you’re compelled to join Miranda in the same submissive pose, her hand still wrapped in yours forcing you to your knees alongside her between Sarah's spread legs.

Looking up Sarah's nude body you meet her dominant gaze and feel completely at her mercy. Maybe you and your crush should have matching collars to show who you belong to for now. Sarah even clenches a fist that rests on her thigh, almost like she was holding your invisible leash. “Mmm, don’t keep me waiting anymore!” She whines, something close to madness in her eyes as she squeezes her teeth down on her bottom lip. "Come on John. What Sarah wants, Sarah gets,” Miranda punctuates her every third word by planting her lips on Sarah's inner thigh, slowly kissing her way up to her friends body. Stunned, you follow suit. Back to back you and Miranda teasingly advance towards Sarah's hot opening, tiptoeing your worshipful mouths along her smooth thighs. Approaching Sarah's pussy your space to maneuver gets smaller and smaller, even with her slutty legs spread wide. Soon you and Miranda are pressed cheek to cheek kissing the plump mounds of her outer labia.

Now facing Sarah's pussy head on you hesitate for a second, unsure if you should just dive in yourself or try to work together with your crush. Miranda, however, doesn't hesitate. Resting her head on Sarah’s thigh she opens her mouth to begin lapping at her friends sensitive pussy with languid strokes of her tongue, giving you a look that screams “What are you waiting for?” Laying your own head on the soft pillow that is Sarah’s opposite thigh you mirror Miranda’s actions, the tips of your tongues almost brushing against each other as you both trace around the rim of her fuckhole. With both of you licking at the same time like this neither of you can get very deep, but you suppose that’s not the point. Having both of you at her service probably feels hotter for Sarah than just one of you eating her pussy perfectly.

Sarah's groan of pleasure combined with her hand on the back of your head seems to confirm that assumption. "Mmph yeah, eat me. Eat my pussy like you're starving." She whispers through gritted teeth, using her hands on your and Miranda's heads to pull you in closer, encouraging or demanding you to go deeper. As the space between you and your crush shrinks your tongues inevitably collide, falling and sliding over each other as you both try and tongue-fuck your red haired mistress. Your faces are drawn closer and closer together as you double penetrate Sarah with your tongues, swapping spit and girlcum as you French kiss her pussy.

You're not sure who moves first but at some point you inevitably find your tongues drawn into each others mouths rather than Sarah's pussy. You sloppily makeout with your crush between Sarah's thighs like you were both possessed by the same irrepressible urge at the same time. You only stop when you're interrupted by Sarah. "Hey lovebirds! If you want to makeout with something, makeout with this!" She points to her pussy, still dripping with need. "Yes ma'am," you break the kiss with a sigh, a little bit of spit or Sarah's honey connecting your lips to your crushes for a moment. Without sparing another glance at your crush or anyone else you lean down and dive back into her honeypot with your tongue. "Ooh, I love a man who knows his place," Sarah purrs, closing her eyes and leaning back her head as you and Miranda return to worshipping her.

The next interruption to Sarah's pleasure comes from outside your trio. "John move your ass, I'm trying to see something," Tom calls out, tilting his head in an attempt to stare at the action between Miranda and Sarah. "What, you want me to move my ass for you? Like this?" You sway your hips and do your best (or worst) twerk, deciding if he's going to be a dick then you're going to mess with him. "That's kinda weird bro," you add, glancing over your shoulder at him to see him going red as Matt and Nicole laugh at him. "Man, fuck you. Just eat Sarah's pussy, that's all you're good at," Tom replies petulantly, his macho pride definitely wounded. "Fuck! He really is good at it," Sarah compliments you, running her fingers through your hair as your tongue returns to her sweet, wet box.

"You stay up here, I know what else Sarah likes," Miranda whispers to you, her lips still shining with girlcum and practically pressed against your cheek. You continue licking Sarah's pussy like a good boy as Miranda lowers herself, crawling under you. Running her hands along her friends body she grabs Sarah by the ass and pulls her toward the edge of the couch with a grunt of exertion. The beautiful red head girl giggles at the movement and them gasps as Miranda reaches her true target. Below you Miranda parts Sarah's bountiful asscheeks before running her tongue over Sarah's tight ass hole. "F-fuck! I'm so glad I told you about that," Sarah moans, grabbing her long legs by the back of the knee to hold them up and apart.

Posing like that with her legs spread in the air she truly looks like a pornstar, a description that a slut like Sarah would probably be happy with, but you still decide to be a gentleman and give her a hand. Firmly, you run your hands up her legs, making sure to grope shapely thighs as you go, until you reach her hands. Then you take over holding the weight of her legs, allowing her left and right hands to go back to groping her tits and running through your hair respectively. To better center yourself on Sarah's pussy you throw a leg over Miranda, straddling her as she eats Sarah's ass.

It came as a complete surprise to you when your big dick fell between Miranda's ass cheeks. You hadn't considered it at all as you'd thrown your leg over her, but now you were almost mounting her doggy style. Your dick had already started to regain it's hardness as you lapped at Sarah like her pussy drippings were a magic potion of erectile rejuvenation, and now nestled in that warm and comfy place it quickly throbbed back to it's impressive full size. A fact that Miranda fully appreciates, moaning into Sarah's ass as her own squeezes around your fully regrown cock. You do your best to keep your full attention on pampering Sarah's pussy, but the feeling of every twitch and flex of your crushes ass against your sensitive cock makes that difficult.

In an effort to ignore your crush backing up against your erection you redouble your efforts on eating Sarah's tight pussy. Now that you've got that hot opening all to yourself you're able to penetrate her much deeper, sending your tongue adventuring up her channel and hearing her groan in response. Running your tongue over every sensitive nook and cranny inside her you pay attention to when her moans are loudest and you pay extra special attention to when her grip tightens on your hair to hold you in place. Returning to that tender spot Sarah's grasp on you increases once more as you lash at it quickly with your tongue, earning yourself a deluge of her honey that flows down your chin. Undoubtedly some of it drips down to anoint Miranda's hair below, but she ignores it to continue rimming her friends hot ass. After a little while longer of attacking Sarah's weakpoint you pull up to catch a breath and move to her clit, only to be caught off guard by a nose full of the scent of sex and Miranda's sweet perfume.

Her perfume, Sarah's musk, her hot body, Sarah's tasty pussy, the smack of her lips as she kisses her ass, Sarah's moans of joy as you both pleasure her, it all comes together to make you so irresistibly fucking horny. Your cock feels like a hot rod of iron between Miranda's cheeks, a rod that you need to douse in something tight and wet before you explode. You move your hips like a thoughtless animal, frotting between your crushes soft ass cheeks. She begins to twerk in response, much better than you did, bouncing her perfect bubble butt around your fat cock.

Heedlessly you take one hand off Sarah's leg, allowing it to fall draped across your back, as you reach under and around your crush. Still orally assaulting Sarah's clit you grasp one of Miranda's 36C tits and firmly knead it. Your crush moans into Sarah's ass and she moves her own faster, less like she was twerking and more like she was bucking back against you desperately trying to be fucked. "Fuck, the pair of you are so fucking filthy!" Sarah groans, running her heel up your back in an attempt to pull you in. With half your face still buried in her pussy you look up and make eye contact with her again, seeing in an instant just how close you and Miranda have gotten her to climax.

Looking at her sparkling eyes and beaming smile you can't help but remember what she said at the start of the dare, about wishing your dick was still hard. Feeling it twitch against Miranda it's certainly hard now, should you give Sarah what she asked for and make her cum how you know she wants to?

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
Happy Halloween! I hope everyone has a scarily good time, and I hope you enjoyed this chapter. If you were hoping for a scarier chapter to sink your fangs in to then please check out my Patreon. Over there you'll find not one, not two, but TEN unique Halloween sex scenes, ready for the new afterparty adventure I've written. John is in for a race against time if he wants to keep Sarah and Miranda from being seduced by John Doe. If you want to see all the content for that right now then please consider becoming a Patron.

https://www.patreon.com/Cheesers123