More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 18 by Cheesers123 Cheesers123

Did you do it in time?

Yes

For a few seconds, you just sat and caught your breath. Miranda stared back up at you, doing the same thing. It felt a little silly, that you were as winded as she was even though all you'd done was pump your dick for a few seconds whilst she had been **** on it, but shooting that load had really taken it out of you. Understandably so, because without even being able to see the volume you'd produced, you could tell that it had been the biggest load of your life.

At your side, Nicole sighed again, a girlish sound that you weren't used to hearing from her. One final time, her lips brushed against your cheek, before she used her hand in your chest to push yourself upright. All the things she'd said, all the unexpected filth that you'd heard, it almost felt like a dream already. You couldn't believe that sweet, delicate, Nicole could have said all that.

In your lap, Miranda licked her lips, closed her mouth, and swallowed one final time. In a flash, the last of the biggest cumshot of your life disappeared down her throat, off to join the rest of your cum in her stomach. Your crush just smiled when she was done. Patting her silken haired head one last, you finally raised your eyes off of her. It was time to face the music.

Everyone was staring at you, again, or maybe still. Your attention had been stolen by Miranda (and Nicole as well) for so long that you had no idea if they'd ever looked away from you, or not. One thing that had changed that you could notice, was their expressions. Sarah still looked the same, smirking playfully at you form beneath a mask of cum, but Matt and Tom were different.

The two other men in the room looked positively bemused by you.

"So," you croaked, "did I do it?"

Matt and Tom both smiled mockingly at that, the latter snorting through his nose.

"Wellllll," Sarah began, "you started cumming with about 2 seconds left. You kept going for a while after that, but I'm feeling generous, so I'll say that counts." Happy as you were to succeed, others were less impressed by your accomplishment.

"Wow, 18 seconds," Tom said, "that must be a record for you, John." Matt chuckled in response, something you had never seen him do at anything Tom had said before.

Your first instinct was to snap back at him with a witty retort, perhaps some comment about how having two girls sucking your dick made it pretty hard not to cum, but then you thought better of it. The two of them were smiling at you now, rather than scowling. Being the butt of the joke was preferable to being the target of their ire, and it also reduced the chance of either of them throwing a punitive dare your way, or otherwise bringing the party to a close with an angry outburst.

If them thinking you were a quick shot made them feel better about how you overshadowed them, then so be it.

"Hey, what can I say," you threw your hands up, "there's some very hot ladies here tonight." As you spoke, you sat back more comfortably on the couch. You had to resist the urge to put your arms around Miranda's and Nicole's shoulders, even though you knew they would let you. Despite your restraint, the two of them leant slightly towards you anyway, Miranda's long, brown, hair brushing over your shoulder.

"Yeah, too hot for you to handle," Matt joked, making Tom laugh in return.

Their words would have stung a lot more if it weren't fact that you'd only came after being edged for even longer than the two of them had for their dare, and that you had resisted head from two girls instead of just one. The two beautiful, young women at your flanks also helped to numb the pain. Still, you bit your tongue and let them have their moment.

"Enough teasing," Sarah waved off Matt and Tom, "John was just doing his dare. I've got to admit, I like it when a man does what he's told." From underneath her sticky, white, façade, Sarah shot you another wink. When she got to her feet a moment later, you almost thought she was walking over to you to get to work on making your dick hard again. Instead, she walked past you towards the living room door.

"I'm gonna go wash all this cum off before it sets," she explained, "feel free to play on without me, I'll only be a minute." With that, she sauntered off to the bathroom, barely blushing at all despite being covered in cum.

"Guess it's my turn now," you said, leaning forward to get the hat off the table.

"Yeah, and if you're as quick with dares as you are with everything else then we might be done with your dare before Sarah even gets back," Tom laughed again.

Locking eyes with him as you reached for the hat, you could still see a little hint of venom behind his words, but you weren't going to call him out for it. Instead, you just smiled wryly at his joke like it didn't matter to you in the least, before grabbing the hat by the brim.

For now, you were just going to play the game, keep a low profile, and avoid stepping on any toes. Before the night was through, however, you would make Miranda yours, and Nicole and Sarah too, if you had your way.

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
Thank you for reading, I hope you enjoyed this chapter. There's only one more chapter to go in this thread, before we change over to another one. If you want to read that chapter now, read the first new chapter, or if you'd like a say in what I write next month, then please consider joining my Patreon. In addition to early access, you can get voting and poll naming rights, allowing you to put your most wanted chapters up for a vote to be my next subject.

https://www.patreon.com/Cheesers123

Who do you draw?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)