Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 18 by sthgsmith sthgsmith

Do you let Matt fuck you?

Yes

You stop plunging into Miranda and try to relax. Nicole has done a good job of loosening you up, but it’s still a tight fit. Luckily, you’re both well lubed up. Miranda comes down from her sex daze and looks at you with a puzzled expression, wondering why you stopped. She then looks around you and takes in what’s happening, her face brightening. Her hands travel all the way to your asscheeks and they pull them apart. Your position already has you open enough, but her enthusiasm shows how turned on she is at the idea of this bisexual daisy chain.

You feel Matt’s dick slide past your rim and slowly fill you up, a couple of inches at a time, then one back. This makes you think it’s not his first time fucking someone in the ass. You turn your head to look at him. He's focused on the point connecting his cock and your ass. You look down too. It's hot. Then your eyes meet Matt's. He gives you a soft smile, somehow looking even more shy than you feel. It's the most **** you've ever seen him. You’re thankful that he’s easing you in and didn’t just stick the whole thing in all at once. After all, he’s still your best friend and cares about you. That seems to be a trend tonight – your friends taking your friendships to completely new territory but also to the highest levels of pleasure.

Your thoughts go back to Nicole. When you stopped, her hand did too. Everything came to a halt, almost ritually, to allow Matt to completely invade your hole. However, you can feel her fingers still inside Miranda. She gradually starts caressing your balls with the rest of her fingers, while placing soft kisses all over your ass and Miranda’s hand. Her other hand rests on Matt’s own buttock encouraging him in his ministrations.

Then, finally, Matt’s hips hit yours. You hiss as you feel him throb completely inside of you. You’ve never felt so full, but it feels so good. This drives Miranda crazy. She bites her lip lustily at you with a grunt and starts grinding her hips, impaling herself on your cock and Nicole’s fingers. From her position, she can’t do much, so she enlists the help of her own hand to rub her clit. For you, though, it’s almost too much. Her horny mews, the squelching sounds, the smell of sex, the sweaty bodies, both sets of hands on your backside, the new sensations, the fullness… you’re close to the edge and you wish you could stay there forever.

Soon, once he feels you’re used to his girth, Matt starts moving as well, slowly taking his thick cock out of your ass, then putting it in again. Nicole’s hand resumes its in-and-out motion as well, fingerfucking Miranda’s ass in earnest, but not for long. Her fingers are replaced by her tongue that licks all the way from Miranda’s now empty hole all the way up to Matt’s, via your own cock and balls. She starts rimming him loudly, leaving you three to find your rhythm.

Matt’s clearly getting excited as he starts pounding you now. It’s difficult at first trying to _get used _to being fucked while also trying to fuck and be fucked. In the end, once you’ve cleared your head enough, you’re able to get ahold of your erratic movements and work in tandem with both your lovers, falling into a nice rhythm.

Nicole’s tonguing has stopped, and you wonder where she is, but the question quickly falls to the back of your mind as the pussy and cock around you help ground you in the moment. However, she soon reappears in your field of vision as she comes from your left and places her pelvis in between your and Miranda’s faces. Miranda quickly understands what she wants and starts lapping at her clit. With her inviting round ass in front of your face you look up and into her eyes as she turns her head to you.

‘Wanna return the favor, bestie?’

She spreads her asscheeks and your see her wrinkled hole wink at you.

Return the favor?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)