Valiantly!

Ashley and Annabelle are rolling around on the bed as they fight. It's more of a gropefest than an actual battle; Annabelle's hands are all over Ashley's ass and Ashley won't let go of her tits. But each is trying to dominate the other by rolling on top of her opponent and pinning her down.

Tibby stops struggling to free herself as she watches the fun with you. A few minutes later one of the pirates on the bed gains the upper hand.

Ashley straddles your stacked neighbour, takes her hands off the woman's bountiful breasts, and uses them to hold Annabelle's arms against the mattress over her head. Then she leans in close, whispers "I win," and plants a kiss on her defeated foe's lips.

It's meant to be nothing more than a teasing peck, but Annabelle isn't down for the count. Snapping her arms up, she captures the bunny's head and holds it for a longer kiss. After making out with her for almost a minute, Annabelle lets go and allows a red-faced Ashley to sit up. "NOW you win. I surrender."

"That's your idea of surrender?" Ashley exclaims. "...I like it."

Drawing back a little, Ashley twists around to look at you and smirks when she sees how you defeated Tibby. "So, Captain Barefoot, what are we going to do with our captives?"

"Hmm." You think. "Maybe you should make sure she's not plotting ****. The best way to tell if she's serious about surrendering is to kiss her some more."

"How is that supposed to prove any-" Annabelle's question is cut off by Ashley's lips.

"I surrender too you know," Tibby says suddenly.

"Is that so?" you ask, turning her around to face you.

"It is! May I have some kisses too?"

The jacket-bound pirate lass gives you the most adorably hopeful look, so the answer is clear. One hand on her shoulder, the other reaching around to rest on the back of her neck, you pull Tibby in until your lips touch. She kisses you eagerly, opening her mouth and drawing your tongue into her mouth to play with hers.

After a long, wet kiss you smile at the former mutineer. "You are serious about surrendering. Want to join the others on the bed?"

"Yes please!"

Chuckling at her eagerness, you free Tibby's hands and take one to lead her to the other kissing couple. Ashley stops smothering Annabelle in affection long enough to watch you sit on the edge of the bed, where you guide Tibby onto your lap before you lie back and pull the cat down with you.

When you start making out again, Ashley sits up and unties her shirt, baring her bra-clad chest for everyone to see. Next she gets to work on Annabelle's blouse, popping open one button after the other and then pulling Annabelle's bra down so nothing hides her large breasts. "Since you surrendered these treasures are mine to play with!" she declares as she gives them an enthusiastic grope that makes Annabelle gasp.

"Taking the term 'treasure chest' a little too seriously aren't you?" Annabelle asks through a soft moan.

"Nothing little about it," Ashley laughs. "Your ship is equipped with some big cannons!"

"It's just too bad I didn't get a chance to fire them before I was boarded," Annabelle sighs sensuously.

"I may have boarded you," Ashley admits as she pinches a nipple. "But I haven't made it below deck yet. Let's see what treasures you're hiding down there!"

Annabelle makes a surprised sound when the bunny girl lets go of her tits and starts tugging at her leggings instead, but she still lifts her hips to help Ashley pull them off her. Her panties come off with them, revealing that she's grown a tuft of pubes since the last time you saw her naked. They're a lighter shade than the hair on her head, and look incredibly soft. An impression Ashley confirms when she reaches down to pet Annabelle. "Ooh, so soft. Do you want your captor to play with this, An... I mean Bell?"