Petting and more.

"Touch me, Daggertooth. I want you to pet me."

Ashley smiles and runs her fingers through Annabelle's soft pubes. At this point Tibby is just lying on top of you, watching with rapt attention. You're looking their way too, but your attention is divided between what's happening on the other side of the bed and the way Tibby's hips slowly grind against you. Your arms are draped over her back, and every now and then your head comes up to kiss a random part of her face before you look over to the other two again.

After a while Tibby is fed up with this back and forth and gets off you. Lying on her stomach next to you, she can peek over your body and kiss you without taking her eyes off Ashley, who has moved on from playing with Annabelle's hair to lightly grazing her pussy. While she watches, Tibby works your cock out of your pants and begins to slowly stroke it, and now it's Ashley and Annabelle who start glancing your way.

Apparently an unspoken challenge is made between Tibby and Ashley, leading both to increase their movements. Tibby pumps your shaft vigorously while her other hand snakes under your shirt to caress your abdomen and chest, while Ashley's fingers spread Annabelle's vaginal lips and plunge into her with loud schlicking sounds. She manages to surprise Annabelle again when she leans down to suck on her breasts. She sucks one nipple into her mouth and releases it with a wet pop, then nibbles on the other before sucking it into her mouth too.

Nobody is speaking anymore. The game is forgotten as your neighbour moans softly while one of your pets fingers her, the other breathing in your ear as her hand flies up and down your shaft. Without letting go, Tibby repositions herself so she can lick the tip of your dick. Seeing this, Annabelle gets a little assertive and pushes Ashley away from her breasts. The bunny girl allows her head to be guided between Annabelle's legs, where she immediately starts eating her captive's pussy.

You want to keep watching, but Tibby chooses this moment to take her hand off you and take you into her mouth. You groan and close your eyes, unable to do anything but enjoy the blowjob until you hear the sounds of an orgasm next to you. Tibby keeps sucking your cock for a while, but the kitty pulls back before your own orgasm nears. You open your eyes to see her grinning at Ashley, who is sitting up between you and Annabelle. "Should we...?"

"We should. Let's get him up!" Before you can ask what's going on, each pet grabs a hand and pulls you into a sitting position, then tugs on your arms to turn you around and get you closer to your motionless neighbour. Annabelle doesn't stir until you're almost upon her, and lazily spreads her legs to let you crawl between them.

Your rod, slick with Tibby's spit, points straight at her. "Are we- is this OK?" you ask, suddenly nervous.

"I'd stop you if it weren't," Annabelle laughs. "Come on John, don't get bashful all of a sudden."

Before you can respond, four hands push gently against your back and you stumble forward, your mushroom head bumping against the waiting woman's crotch.

"Hey, easy girls," you mutter as you pull back to position yourself properly. "Not that I don't appreciate the encouragement."

The hands stop pushing, but two of then dart forward to grab your penis and rub its tip between Annabelle's lips. It seems the only way to make them ease up is to go ahead, so that's exactly what you do. Your pets' hands slip off your dick as you push it into Annabelle, penetrating your neighbor for the first time. Her internal muscles ripple as if to welcome you in, and she smirks up at you when she sees your reaction. She's doing this on purpose!

Well two can play at that game. You flex, making your dick shift inside Annabelle. She pulls you in deeper with a moan, and you smirk right back as you start fucking her. It feels surreal, having sex with your neighbor while your pets, still dressed up as pirates, stroke your back and egg you on. You're determined to give them a good show, thrusting energetically to get a noisy reaction out of Annabelle.

When you reach out to grope her big tits too, Ashley and Tibby start pushing on your back again to make sure you don't slow down. You wobble a little from the unexpected ****, which makes Annabelle laugh - until you make the next thrust extra rough and give her nipples a good pinch. The noise she produces makes you think you've hurt her, but then she shouts for more and you give it to her.

The girls gasp as they watch you pound away, twisting and pulling on Annabelle's puffy nipples. Each jolt of pain makes her muscles contract, squeezing your dick inside her and increasing the pleasure for both of you. Soon she's screaming for a different reason, and your orgasm quickly follows hers. It's a good thing Annabelle is on the pill, because you have no chance of pulling out with how tightly her legs wrap around you. She pulls you close and holds you there, forcing you to bottom out inside her as you fill her pussy with your seed.

It's not until your balls stop twitching and Annabelle's legs release you that you realize you've been applying the same amout of pressure to her nipples. Letting go of them, you pull out and sit back on the bed, your dick wilting to half-mast between your legs. By contrast, Annabelle's nipples are more puffy than ever and have taken on a sore red hue. Maybe you overdid it a little near the end there.

The girls coo sympathetically and move to sit on either side of Annabelle, gently massaging her breasts and stroking over the pale skin of her stomach. Your dick twitches occasionally as you listen to Annabelle's sighs of satisfaction and relaxation, but other than that you just sit there and wait for your breathing to slow.