Tom (Sarah's sadistic scheme)

Before Sarah had even drawn a name, her head was spinning with ideas. First and foremost, was that she needed a way for Matt to bare his short cock willingly (or at least seemingly willingly) to everyone still at the party. Although Miranda had promised to keep her conniving little plan secret, if she just yanked down his boxers and laughed at his wrinkled dick then her reputation would still be ruined. Worse, Matt could probably lodge a complaint with the University that would put an end to any hopes of an academic career.

Sarah might have been a party girl, more interested in sucking and fucking big cocks at dorm parties than studying, but she still wanted to graduate.

So that meant her most obvious course of action was to dare him to remove his underwear and pass the whole thing off as just part of the game. The only problem with that was a shy dork like him would undoubtedly cover his shame, and Sarah wanted everyone to get a good eyeful. Instead, she would get him used to the idea of having his dick out first, so that everyone could get a good, long, look. Already, she could picture him swaggering back and forth, his teeny tiny thing wagging in the air like a puppy's tail.

Her new primary objective was to make being naked seem normal. Herself and Miranda were already making a good start on that front, the both of them sitting there topless, soft breasts nearly on full display, but there wasn't exactly much in the way of male nudity. Even Matt's bare body was now tucked away under a blanket.

If she wanted Matt to flaunt his flaws, then that would have to change. Starting with whatever she drew now.

Spiraling her fingers around the rim of the hat one final time, Sarah seized a name and drew it out to read. A smile split her pretty features as she read the perfect name for what she had in mind.

Tom.

Not only was he used to being naked (or at least pantsless) around Sarah, she knew that she was going to enjoy the view too.

"Tom," she said, making eye contact with him as she returned his name to the bowl. A wolfish grin appeared on his face as he tore his attention away from Miranda's 36C boobs. Sarah's own eye flashed to that pair of perfect tits before she continued speaking.

"I think that four boobies has got to be enough to equal one dick," she explained, "so I dare you to get yours out." At her words, Matt stiffened beside her, although not his cock as that was already rock hard under her fingers. It was clear from the betrayed side eye he gave her that he did not like this dare, but after Sarah returned her head to his shoulder he seemed to relax again.

Meanwhile, everyone else reacted to her dare in a variety of different ways. Miranda blushed and smiled, John frowned and rolled his eyes, Tom laughed with his typical confidence-bordering-on-arrogance, and Nicole went wide eyed and made quick repeated glances to the large lump in the center of Tom's lap.

"You've been a good girl holding out for this long, Sarah," Tom laughed as he got to his feet," I suppose you deserve a show." Sarah made eyes to Miranda as Tom stood up, trying to tell her nonverbally to watch closely, since this was the guy she'd been telling her about. Whether Miranda got the message or not, her attention was quickly brought to the bulge in Tom's crotch as he teased open the metallic teeth of his zipper.

With one hand, Sarah kept teasing Matt's little dick, whilst the other gripped the blanket tightly in anticipation. The waiting was almost her favorite part, the building suspense, her rising lust, it made her so horny that she almost forgot she was playing with Matt's little toy. "Hopefully, the sight of a real man's cock doesn't scare him too badly," she thought with a smirk, "now that he's shown me his pathetic prick, I want to humiliate him before I get rid of him."

Tom's zipper popped open, and as she watched his thumbs went to the waistband of his underwear for the coup-de-grace.

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
Thanks for reading, I hope you liked it. If you want to see what my Patrons voted for Tom to pull out, the consider subscribing to my Patreon to get the answer a week in advance. There's also another poll available on my Patreon for members right now, so if you want to vote in a poll for yourself, then feel free to join. The more the merrier!

https://www.patreon.com/Cheesers123