Shutting Up Courtney

“Hello?”

You hear the person on the other line answer their phone. Brooke’s put them on loud speaker so that you and Courtney could hear.

“Mmffmfmfmfpfftmf!!!” Courtney shouts in protest. Since Brooke placed her phone on the pillow where Courtney’s resting her head, the other person was able to hear it.

You’re not holding Courtney down or anything, so she can definitely take off the gag if she really wants to, but it seems like your earlier command made its mark on her and she doesn’t dare to remove it herself. Plus, your earlier threat of replacing Brooke’s panties with something else is a lot more threatening now since your erect cock is resting on top of her pussy.

“Wait. What was that?” The person on the other end replies.

“That… was Courtney.” Brooke answers. “Jay shut her up by gagging her with my panties.” Brooke adds.

“Holy shit!” The voice from the phone reacts. “I’m on my way!” They then shout.

“Oh~. No, no, no. You’re not joining us.” Brooke tells the other person teasingly.

“Then why fucking call me then!? — OW!” They shout angrily.

“What happened to chilling and relaxing?” Someone from the other end asks them in annoyance.

“Language, baby.” You teasingly remind your daughter, as Cassie seemingly does the same on the other end of the line. Despite your reprimand, you are curious what Brooke’s up to as well by calling your daughter.

“Well~, I was thinking… since you’re the resident cuck of the group, you got any tips on what a cuck would like to hear get done on their partner?” Brooke asks her teasingly. “I mean, we want to make sure Chad doesn’t get shortchanged by Courtney’s story now, don’t we?” Brooke adds with a persuasive tone.

“Oh you’re such a tease!” Stella replies.

‘You have no idea, baby.’ You think to yourself.

“Okay. What’s going on?” You can hear Cassie ask Stella.

“Hello? Who is this?” Cassie asks, apparently having been handed the phone by Stella.

“Hey, baby. It’s me.” You reply.

“Jay? What’s going on?” Cassie asks.

“Brooke wants tips—” You say as you rub the tip of your cock on Courtney’s entrance, “On how to cuck someone.” You continue, before glancing at your phone again.

Lust Score: 8 (+4)

“It’s my first time.” Brooke chimes in jokingly, as she plays with Courtney’s nipples with her fingertips.

“So you called Stella because… Oh~ I see.” Cassie says in realization. “You are such a tease.” Cassie adds with a chuckle.

“It’s not like you two can’t do stuff while you’re down there!” Brooke argues. “Edmund said guests in the presidential suite have their own private bungalow near the pool area, right?” Brooke tries to make her sound less of a tease.

…

There’s a long silence on the other line. It seems the two girls are discussing Brooke’s proposal privately.

“Fffpfftffpfpt” You and Brooke hear Courtney try to say. You’re tempted to take the gag off to hear what she must possibly be thinking of this development, but the idea seems to entice her a little as her score has gone up a bit.

Lust Score: 11 (+3)

“We’ll get back to you.” You hear Cassie say on the other line before they end the phone call. Brooke looks at you in confusion, not having expected that Stella and Cassie would drop the call.

“I guess they’ll get back to us.” You tell Brooke with a chuckle and a shrug.

“Well that didn’t go as planned.” Brooke says before she does a lip trill in disappointment.

“What was your plan anyway?” You ask, before you realize you’re starting a casual conversation while you grind the frenulum of your cock on Courtney’s clit.

“I was thinking it could get Courtney’s… um… horniness go up more quickly, if she hears Stella moan just from hearing you fuck somebody else over the phone.” Brooke explains. “If she doesn’t like it, well, that’s payback for letting me lose my beauty sleep.” Brooke adds on jokingly.

“Mmfffmfmfmffm.” Courtney mumbles, but obviously saying a clapback at Brooke.

“I guess we’ll have to do it the old fashioned way.” You say with an amused smile.

“Fffptpfptf” Courtney mutters again while gagged, as you rub your cock on the outside of her pussy a bit faster. She’s not at all wet yet, and with your cock not having been properly lubricated for this rubbing, you’re sure it’s not that pleasurable.

“My cock’s a little too dry for what I’m doing.” You tell Brooke, making her look down on yours and Courtney’s crotch area to see you rubbing your cock head on her pussy. “Can you help with that?” You ask teasingly.

Brooke doesn’t answer verbally and immediately proceeds to take action. Brooke mounts Courtney’s body, her perfect ass most likely resting on Courtney’s massive fake globes. Brooke bends forward to get her head near yours and Courtney’s crotch areas, before giving the tip of your dick a sweet peck as a hello.

You direct the tip of your dick right on top of Courtney’s clit, so that when Brooke flicks her tongue to tease it, her tongue also grazes Courtney’s sensitive nub. Brooke then begins to make out with your cock’s tip, covering it with her lips and using her tongue to coat your cock head with her saliva. All the while, you continue to slowly rub your cock along Courtney’s pussy, finally getting wet from the rubbing stimulation as well as Brooke’s tongue.

Lust Score: 16 (+5)

You shift so that you plant your balls on top of Courtney’s clit, and tell Brooke to lick them. Brooke does as she’s told, and starts flicking her tongue in the space between your balls and Courtney’s clit.

“Mmmmff” Courtney moans. You’re pretty sure it’s a moan since she’s beginning to breathe heavier now. You grab Courtney by the wrist and direct her hand towards Brooke’s face.

“Wet it for me… you dirty bitch.” You command Brooke, adding the latter unflattering term halfheartedly after you remember she likes being called dirty names. Brooke just smirks at your attempt at degrading her, before licking Courtney’s palm with her tongue. She even gives two of Courtney’s fingers a quick sensual sucking before giving her palm one last lick. Satisfied with the slickness she’s applied on Courtney’s hand, Brooke goes back to sucking on your balls. Afterwards, you finally direct Courtney’s hand towards your cock, and she immediately grips it tight without being asked to.

“Feel how big it is in your hand, Court.” Brooke starts teasing her. “Take note of how it feels. How even just stroking him is making you feel good. Remember every detail. How long it takes for you to stroke from his tip down to the base. Chad’s going to want to hear the fucking monster of a cock that’s going to fuck you silly.” Brooke continues. You can’t help but give her a playful self-disparaging look after she calls your cock a ‘monster’. Brooke plays it off, and gives you an equally playful smirk and wink.

“Mmmffufffummffifmffm” Courtney starts just casually muttering. You and Brooke look at each other in wonder at what she’s saying. Unable to not give in to your curiosity, Brooke dismounts Courtney and takes her panties off Courtney’s mouth.

“You were saying?” Brooke asks her.

“I said the warts on his dick spell ‘bitch ass loser’ in braille.” Courtney insults you as soon as she spits all the saliva that pooled in her mouth.

“I regret taking the gag off.” Brooke immediately says in reaction.

“Well, I regret that you didn’t cover my ears too. Why not just turn me into a full Helen Keller? That’s the only way I’ll fucking enjoy this anyway.” Courtney quips back.

You immediately glance at your phone after hearing her statement to check her score again.

Lust Score: 24 (+8)

That’s the biggest leap you’ve gotten so far, so you know a part of her must be enjoying this.

“Is that how you talk to all your clients?” Brooke asks her.

“Oh! I’m sorry! I must have missed the part where you’re paying clients.” Courtney replies sarcastically, letting go of your cock in the process.

“We’re letting you stay here with us overnight!” Brooke falls into Courtney’s trap and argues with her, instead of focusing on the task at hand.

“How about you repeat that sentence and point out to my dumb bimbo brain where you put cash in my pocket?” Courtney continues to be sarcastic.

Not wanting to lose sight of what it is you’re actually doing, you take your phone and get up from the bed. Your sudden movement seems to have taken both women by surprise, as they both stop their back-and-forth to look in your direction. You get off the bed and stand on the side, before pulling Courtney’s body towards yours and turning her body so that her head is pointing in your direction. You pull her head over the edge, allowing it to hang on the edge, before moving forward and placing your wet balls on her chin.

“I don’t like how you talk to my girlfriend.” You tell Courtney menacingly.

“Oh please. What’d you call her again? Oh right. We both know the ‘dirty bitch’ likes it.” Courtney replies smugly. Even though you can see Courtney’s point, you don’t want her sarcastic remarks to undermine that you and Brooke are in control here.

“Suck my balls, Courtney.” You command her.

“Make me.” Courtney says defiantly.

“Fine.” You reply, before placing your hand on her neck.

You slowly tighten your grip, slowly squeezing her neck with your hand, **** her to minimize the air she’s breathing. Knowing that wouldn’t be enough to get her to open her mouth, you pinch her nostrils closed between your fingers, forcing her to open her mouth. You allow her to breathe for a second, before shifting your balls into her now open mouth, forcing her to suck on them. You then grab her arm by the wrist one more time, before directing it to stroke your cock once more.

“I like this way of shutting her up the best.” Brooke jokingly shares. You direct Brooke to come to you with your fingers, and she mounts Courtney once more before you and Brooke lock lips for a sensual kiss. Your tongues wrestle in each other’s mouths, while Courtney’s tongue swirls around the base of your balls. Brooke takes your cock in her hand too, and she and Courtney double team your cock with their hands.

The three of you continue in this position for a few minutes, as you watch Courtney’s score steadily increase.

Lust Score: 34 (+10)

Your hands switch back and forth from Brooke’s ass, to her tits, to Courtney’s tits, as Brooke and Courtney’s hands continue to work your cock. It’s after a few more minutes that you and Brooke notice that Courtney stops stroking your cock, so you take your balls off her mouth so she can explain herself.

“Getting tired?” You ask her.

“Getting bored. When’s the fucking going to start?” Courtney replies defiantly, after taking in a deep breath.

“All you had to do was ask.” You tell her slyly, before directing the tip of your cock onto her lips. “You didn’t mention which hole you wanted to get fucked. So I chose for you.” You continue.

“HA! You make it sound like it’s a threat.” Courtney reacts defiantly. “I’m undefeated in the Oralympics, Love Coach. The only reason I let you gag me with Brooke’s panties instead of your cock was because I didn’t want you to blow your load too quickly. Chad would be so disappointed in—” Courtney starts to ramble smugly, before you finally cut her off.

“Just shut up and suck my dick, Courtney.” You command her, not hiding how fed up you are with her antics. Courtney obliges without hesitation and opens her mouth for you, willingly this time. You hold onto her neck for support, as you slowly inch your cock deeper and deeper into Courtney’s mouth.

You’re not gonna lie. Courtney wasn’t lying about being good at this. You can feel her neck muscles adapt as you feel the tip of your dick go down her throat, and she’s still not gagging. Once you feel your balls hit the tip of her nose, you realize you don’t have enough dick to go further down what feels like Courtney’s bottomless throat.

It’s at this point that Brooke’s phone starts to ring.

Brooke grabs her phone, then shows you that it’s Cassie that’s calling. She answers it and puts it on loud speaker, so you can hear what they’re going to say.

“We’re ready. What’s happening?” Cassie says over the phone.

“Well, I got my dick in Courtney’s—” You begin to answer, but you pause as you feel Courtney’s hands repeatedly slap your thighs.

*TAP!* *TAP!* *TAP!* *TAP!*

Oh right.

She probably couldn’t breathe.

“Are you… fucking… trying to… kill me!?” Courtney shouts in between deep bated breaths.

“Looks like you’ve finally found a cock you can’t beat in the Oralympics there, Court.” Brooke teases her, as Courtney continues to catch her breath from beneath you and Brooke.

Lust Score: 38 (+4)

Seems like she liked it though. Maybe she’s into erotic asphyxiation?

“Okay… uh~... what’s this about killing Courtney?”