Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 40 by reaper13 reaper13

Should Jenny tell her?

She leaves out the part where the guy was black.

Jenny is not sure if she should tell her cousin. As far as she knows she could end up filling Penny’s mind with the idea to start having sex herself. Between the two of them, she really is much bolder. She might just do it simply to prove she’s just as bold. Suddenly Jenny’s imagination shows her an image of a naked Penny getting her white pussy penetrated by a black dick.
“Wait a minute.” Jenny thinks. “What if I motivate her to want to have sex … and then convince her to get herself blacked.”
The idea of convince her cousin to spread her white legs for a black dick makes Jenny’s lips curl into a smile.
When Penny sees Jenny smile she says, “You’re thinking about it right now, right? You’re first time? Oh my god, I’m so curious. Please, tell me.”
Jenny sighs through her smile and says, “Alright.”

“No way.” Penny says. “You mean with the friend of your best friend’s boyfriend?”
“Behind their backs too.” Jenny continues. “He twisted his ankle, I proposed to get him back to his room and that’s where it happened.”
“Ooooh, so first he got you alone and then he came on to you, huh?” Penny guesses.
“Well aaaactuallyyyyy …” Jenny starts.
“No.” Penny interrupts while switching her position to sit on her knees. “You did not seduce him. You are not bold enough to seduce a guy.”
Jenny rolls onto her back and admits, “You’re right. I did not seduce him. I just asked if I could see his dick.”
Penny spreads her eyes open and asks, “And he showed it?!”
Jenny sits on her knees now as well and says, “Well, he did ask me to strip for him first.” While moving her hands sexy through her hair.
Penny mouth opens wide from shock.
“You got nude in front of him?”
“How else was I supposed to get him hard?” Jenny shrugs.
“Yeah, it’s official. You’re bolder then me now.” Penny compliments her cousin. “I don’t think I could get naked in front of a guy. Even with the promise of seeing his dick.”

“So what did it look like?” Penny then asks.
“What do you mean?” Jenny asks confused. “His dick looked like a dick.”
“Yeah but, was it big, was it small, …? Dicks can have all kinds of shapes, you know.” Penny replies.
“Well, it was pretty big.” Jenny tells her cousin. “And black.” She adds in her mind.
“How big.” Penny asks.
“Big enough I could only get the tip in my mouth.” Jenny answers.
“No way.” Penny immediately replies. “No way, you did not give a guy a blowjob before me.”
All Jenny can do right now is snicker at her cousin’s reply.
“Oh em gee. You totally gave him a blowjob, didn’t you?” Penny relents, accepting Jenny’s revelation.
“He was also black.” Jenny thinks again.
“Well how was it?” Penny asks.
“This is it.” Jenny thinks. “This is my chance to make her ant to do it.”
“It was amazing.” Jenny explains. “I held his shaft with both my hands. It felt so big and strong, but the skin was so soft. And when I had it in my mouth I licked the tip with my tongue and it tasted so great.”
Jenny then places herself in the same position she was when she sucked Greg’s dick and starts bobbing her head up and down. This causes Penny to giggle and secretly wish she had a boyfriend she could try it out on herself.

“What else did you do?” Penny asks.
“Well, after that his dick went into my pussy and there you go. I was having sex.” Jenny explains.
“Did I mention he was black?” Jenny thinks again.
“How did it feel?” Penny asks excitedly.
“Like my pussy was being spread to its maximum.” Jenny explains. “I felt so full and I enjoyed every minute of it.”
Jenny then sits on her knees and raises her shirt to show off her belly button. She points at it with her finger and says, “I could feel his dick all the way up here.”
Penny’s mouth falls open from shock.
“No way.” Penny gasps. “You didn’t get ripped open?”
Now it was Jenny’s time to giggle.
“Oh god. If I were to get a dick so huge inside my pussy I think it would just split me in half.”
Jenny smiles and thinks, “If only she knew it was a black dick.”
“Jesus, I am like so jealous of you.” Penny whispers.

“Really? You’re jealous of me having my first fuck?” Jenny asks.
“Yeah.” Penny replies. “And by such a huge dick too.”
Jenny smirks and thinks. “Good. The idea of having sex is planted in her brain now.”
“Suppose you had a guy with an erect dick for you right now, what would you do with him?” Jenny asks.
“Hmm, let’s see.” Jenny ponders. “I would start by giving him a handjob. I totally want to know what it feels like.
Jenny imagines her cousin’s fingers around a black dick.
“Then I think I would give it a boobjob.”
Jenny imagines her cousin without her bra and a black dick between her white boobs.
“Then I would suck on it like you did.”
Jenny imagines Penny with her mouth wide open and a black dick sliding in and out of it.
“And finally … gosh, I don’t know. I don’t think I should just lie there and let him put it in me. I’d probably let him fuck me from behind. Or wait, I could straddle him and put his dick inside my pussy myself.
Jenny imagines Penny getting her pussy penetrated by a black dick in all three scenarios.
“This is it.” Jenny thinks. “If I can’t convince her now, I probably never will.”
“You know,” Penny says with a grin. “If you really want to, I think I might be willing to share my boyfriend with you.”
“Really?” Penny asks hopefully.
“Well yeah.” Jenny says. Having a guy’s dick inside me was so amazing. It gave me the best orgasm I had. And well, you’re my cousin. Of course I want you to have a great first time too.”

Does Penny accept her cousin’s offer?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)