Sex with an Audience, Pt. 2

“Okay… uh~... what’s this about killing Courtney?” Stella asks after hearing Courtney’s shout.

“Don’t worry about her. She just choked on your Dad’s dick.” Brooke jokingly answers Stella’s question.

“HA!” You can hear your daughter react over the phone. “Amateur.” She says teasingly.

“Like a fucking lesbian teenager like you gives better head.” Courtney retorts. “Also! That better not be a fucking video call or you motherfuckers are paying extra!” Courtney adds.

“I was told you shut Courtney up?” Cassie points out, not so subtly suggesting that’s what she prefers.

“Speaking of, you have musty ass pant-mffffmmffppttmf” Courtney starts to mouth off again before you stuff the head of your cock into Courtney’s mouth again.

“That’s better.” You say, while Courtney’s initial protests turn to her just shamelessly sucking on your dick.

“Wait, how come Courtney doesn’t know this is just a voice call?” Stella asks, curious; before Cassie gasps in realization what might be the reason for that.

“You have her blindfolded, don’t you?” Cassie asks rhetorically, already insinuating how naughty you and Brooke are being with Courtney. You confirm to both of them that you do, in fact, have Courtney blindfolded.

“Kinky.” Stella comments.

“Okay. Anyway, you guys said you were ready? Care to elaborate on that?” Brooke addresses your two girlfriends on the other end of the call.

“We um… we decided to try this meeting halfway type of thing first.” Stella replies.

“What she means is - since I want to try stuff when it’s just the two of us, and she’s not comfortable doing stuff without Jay’s involvement; we agreed that maybe we could do this first and see if it helps her get more comfortable. Jay’s technically with us, and Jay’s technically cucking her too, so…” Cassie then starts to explain.

“Oh~, I get it. I guess we’re killing two birds with one stone with this.” Brooke says in understanding.

Three, technically; but who’s counting?

“How are we going to do this exactly?” You ask them, while Courtney mutters stuff under her gag.

“Well, it was kinda Brooke’s suggestion, so we thought you guys had a clear idea about that.” Stella replies.

“Oh! Uh~... I was kinda winging it by calling you earlier. I was just thinking you’d play with yourself while you listened.” Brooke admits with an embarrassed chuckle.

“That’s doable.” Cassie replies on behalf of Stella. “Just tell us what you’re doing, and I’ll handle the rest.” Cassie adds, brimming with confidence in her voice.

“Well, since you’re the one who has more experience in doing this, how about you suggest stuff we should do. Like Jay said, I’d like some tips.” Brooke suggests further.

“Um~... yeah. Sure. I can do that.” Cassie replies with some hesitation.

“Please tell me you’re in a private and secluded area. The last thing I want is for you girls to—” you say full of concern, before Stella cuts him off to reassure him.

“We’re back in the suite, Daddy. Cassie’s not daring enough to risk it in public.” Stella assures you, while also seemingly teasing Cassie in the process.

“I’m with Cassie on this one, baby.” You reply.

“Yeah, yeah. I got it.” Stella replies dismissively. “It’s not like we need the extra spice anyway. This whole weird set-up seems spicy enough as it is.” She adds.

“Oh~, I think we can turn the heat up a whole lot more.” Cassie jokes.

“Agreed. It’s still pretty mild on our end. How do you suggest we turn the heat up, Cassie?” Brooke teases.

“Tell me, what are you guys doing now?” Cassie asks.

“I have my fingers rubbing Courtney’s pussy, and Jay has—” Brooke starts to describe to the girls, before she gets interrupted by Cassie.

“Call him Daddy, Brooke. He likes it when you call him Daddy.” Cassie informs her.

“Does he, now?” Brooke looks at you teasingly, an eyebrow raised in wonder, and you can’t help but give her a smug shrug in admission. “You like having your cock inside a professional whore’s mouth, Daddy?” Brooke asks you with a dirty tone.

“The amateur slut I had last night did way~ better, if I’m being honest.” You reply with a wicked smile that Brooke returns.

“Oooh~, Daddy’s talking dirty!” Stella reacts, surprised by how you addressed Brooke.

Courtney doesn’t seem to like the comparison much, and takes the initiative to prove herself to you. She places her hands on your ass cheeks and pulls you in further into her awaiting throat after hearing you compliment Brooke’s skills over hers.

“Someone’s competitive.” Brooke notices, getting the girls to ask what’s happening. Brooke informs them that Courtney just took more of you deeper down her throat after you chose Brooke’s skills over Courtney’s.

“Well, since it seems your guest wants to get stuffed, stuff three fingers in her cunt while Jay stuffs her mouth with his cock.” Cassie suggests over the phone. “While I~, stuff this cunt.” Cassie adds.

It seems Brooke and Cassie shove their fingers inside the respective pussies they’re playing with at the same time, as Courtney and Stella seem to moan simultaneously. Courtney’s moan is muffled by your cock being down her throat though.

Cassie suggests that you start massaging the outside of Courtney’s neck, so you can feel how far your cock has reached inside her. She instructs Brooke to do the same, and tells her to push down on Courtney’s lower abdomen while her fingertips push up inside Courtney to squeeze her muscles in between.

“MMMMMFFFF!!” You hear Courtney moan in pleasure, goading you to start moving your hips back and forth to fuck her face. All the while, you describe everything you’re doing to your girls, getting them to moan in response as well. You and Brooke continue to play Courtney in this position for a few minutes, as you watch her score increase little by little; only for it to seemingly get stuck right before the fifty point mark.

Lust Score: 49 (+11)

“Let’s change it up.” You announce, taking control this time. “Check if our guest is wet enough… slut.” You order Brooke, tacking on another unnecessary dirty name for her.

“Oh~, she’s getting really wet with my fingers, Daddy.” Brooke replies, seemingly relishing being able to call you Daddy.

“How about you check how wet she is with your tongue?” Cassie suggests, and Brooke doesn’t take a second more after hearing your suggestion to lean in and work Courtney’s cooch with her mouth. Seeing how eager to please Brooke is, you decide to place your hands on Courtney’s fake tits and lean forward to get a closer look on Brooke working her tongue on Courtney’s clit while she finger fucks her.

Brooke’s eyes stare right at you, as she flicks her tongue back and forth on Courtney’s clitoral hood, before sucking on Courtney’s now erect clit; making a sound like she’s sucking it with a straw. The noises Brooke’s making harmonize with the gagging moans of Courtney, as you haven’t stopped slowly moving your hips back and forth on her throat. Meanwhile, the moans of your daughter are constantly coming from Brooke’s phone as well.

“Taste how delicious you are, Stella.” You hear Cassie tell your daughter, before sucking sounds proceed to come out of Brooke’s phone.

“There’s an idea.” Brooke then pops up from Courtney’s pussy to say. “Want to taste this whore’s cunt, Daddy?” Brooke asks you, before sticking her tongue out to entice you.

“Language, Brooke.” Stella jokes over the phone.

Since you’re already leaning towards her, it doesn’t take much effort, other than moving a few more inches forward, before you and Brooke sloppily make out with your tongues. You and Brooke start to move your heads around, taking in deep breaths through your noses, as you both wildly swap spit. Unfortunately, it doesn’t take long in this position before Courtney starts tapping out from having the tip of your dick right down her throat, that you have to abruptly break away to keep Brooke’s roommate alive.

As soon as you free Courtney’s mouth from your cock, she immediately takes deep breaths that sound wet and slimy. It’s not much of a surprise that when you look down, your cock is covered in slobber so thick, there’s a strand of saliva still connecting your cock to Courtney’s lips.

You glance back at your phone and realize that your theory that Courtney likes getting choked may have some legs to it, as her score jumps another double digits after she taps out from **** on your dick.

Lust Score: 63 (+14)

+50 Lust Points. Total: 150 (For reaching the 50+ Lust Score goal with a person)

“You girls should see how much slobber is on Daddy’s cock.” Brooke says teasingly to Cassie and Stella.

“You should see how wet my fingers are from Stella.” Cassie teases back.

“It’s time for you to return the favor to your roommate, Courtney.” You tell her, while grabbing her by the hair to get her head level to the bed, as she’s still catching her breath. You can’t see her eyes, but you imagine she has a glassy look after being asphyxiated like she was.

You move towards the other side of the bed where Brooke is, and give her gorgeous ass that’s on display a loving tap.

*SPANK*

You then give her pussy a quick lick to check if she got wet from this, and your tongue is immediately welcomed with her slickness. At least you’re assured that Brooke’s getting turned on by this too.

“Sit on her face.” You tell Brooke. “Don’t let her breathe.” You add, hoping that your theory is proven correct, and that Courtney will have her score increase much faster because of it.

Brooke shifts on the bed so you and her can pull Courtney by the legs to get her lower body closer to the side where you are now. Brooke also gets a pillow and raises the back of Courtney’s head for her, before sliding the pillow beneath it.

Before Brooke does what you told her to do, she approaches you first and gives you a passionate kiss.

“You know this is the wildest thing I’ve ever done?” Brooke asks you in a whisper near your ear after your kiss. She has a bright wide smile, but also a disbelieving look in her eyes.

“Last night was pretty wild, I think.” You argue.

“Yeah, but not like this.” She says with a chuckle. “I didn’t expect my first group thing with you would be with Courtney, but I guess it’s a great way to ease myself into that kind of thing.” Brooke jokes.

“You’ve shared a guy with Courtney before?” You ask in shock.

“Not what I meant!” Brooke says with a chuckle. “I just mean that it’s not immediately with four other women all at once. That’d probably be too overwhelming for me.” Brooke admits.

“Then I’m glad we’re hitting another bird with this stone.” You tell her, before giving her a kiss. As the two of you break away from each other, you see how happy Brooke looks with the smile she gives you.

“I’m going to sit on her face now.” Brooke confirms, before giving you a quick peck on the lips. She then moves on the bed so that Courtney’s face is right between her legs. “Hey, girls.” Brooke addresses Cassie and Stella over the phone. “I’m going to shut up Courtney with my pussy now.” Brooke informs them.

“Way ahead of you, Brooke. Cassie can’t talk right now.” Stella replies over the phone, and you imagine that your daughter’s getting her pussy eaten out by Cassie at the other end.

“On three.” You tell Brooke, and she gives you a nod that she understands what you mean. You slowly count from one, and as soon as you say ‘three’, you penetrate Courtney’s pussy while Brooke lowers her pussy onto Courtney’s mouth.

You start moving back and forth inside Courtney, while Brooke starts grinding her pussy on Courtney’s tongue that she stuck outward so Brooke can grind on it easier. Brooke also seems to have her thighs squeeze on Courtney’s cheeks, not spreading her legs wide to constrict Courtney’s breathing.

You also decide not to do a steady pace while fucking Courtney, deciding to instead do short quick bursts of pounding her, before taking breaks to make out with Brooke. The quick bursts seem to tease Courtney a lot more, resulting in her Lust Score rising bit by bit with every burst.

Lust Score: 75 (+12)

You continue this position for a few more minutes, before switching it up when Cassie and Stella inform over the phone that they’re now sixty-nining each other, giving you the idea to place Brooke and Courtney in the same position.

Brooke and Courtney switch positions so that Courtney’s the one on top so you can fuck her doggy; while Brooke is right beneath Courtney’s pussy, sticking her tongue out to lick the underside of your shaft as it moves back and forth on Courtney’s pussy.

With Courtney being on top of Brooke, Brooke still doesn’t allow Courtney to have free use of her mouth, wrapping her legs around the back of Courtney’s head to **** Courtney to continue eating her pussy. Despite Brooke’s efforts though, as soon you can’t help yourself to start fucking Courtney at a steady pace, Courtney’s mouth is too busy moaning to eat her out anymore.

“AH~ SHIT! FUCK ME HARDER! I’M SO CLOSE!!” Courtney shouts as you start building up speed pounding her now dripping wet pussy.

Lust Score: 83 (+8)

Stella and Cassie seem to be more engaged in their own thing, than participating in yours, as they’ve barely shared what it is they’re doing together, but instead just let out constant moans over the phone.

“FUCK ME HARDER YOU CUCKING SON OF A BITCH!!” Courtney shouts, prompting you to spank her ass.

“Don’t tell me what to fucking do!” You shout back, as you do exactly what she says and fuck her as hard as you can. Brooke focuses her attention on Courtney as well, as you feel her flick her tongue back and forth beneath you, presumably on Courtney’s clit.

Lust Score: 92 (+9)

“I’M ALMOST THERE!” Courtney informs you again. “TELL ME I’M PRETTY!” Courtney orders you.

What?

“DON’T FUCKING STOP! JUST TELL ME I’M PRETTY!” Courtney shouts at you again.

“What? I don’t…” You say in reaction, confused that she’s suddenly requesting such a thing.

“Court, are you alright?” Brooke asks from beneath you and Courtney.

“I can’t cum unless you say it! Please! JUST TELL ME I’M PRETTY!” Courtney shouts pleadingly.

“Fine! You’re fucking pretty!” You shout back, before you finally kick into the highest gear you can go, squeezing her ass cheeks while you pound her as hard as you can.

“More! I’M ALMOST THERE! CALL ME YOUR PRETTY LITTLE PRINCESS! Ask me to cum for you!” Courtney adds, and you stop questioning her requests and just do them.

“Cum for me, my pretty little princess.” You whisper into her ear, after you lean forward to get closer to her.

“~AAAAH~! I’M CUMMING! DON’T STOP! I’M CUM—” Courtney starts to shout, but you push her head down onto Brooke’s pussy to get her to stop.

“Shut up!” You shout commandingly, as her groans are muffled by Brooke’s pussy. What doesn’t sound muffled are the shouts of pleasure coming from the other end of the phone, as it seems Stella has reached her orgasm.

You don’t stop pounding her and you hold yourself back from cumming as well, as you notice a small hiccup on your phone.

Lust Score: 99 (+7)

You pull Courtney’s body up through her hair, forcing her to lean her back on your body.

“Are you on birth control?” You ask her aggressively, continuing to fuck her from behind.

“Don’t you fucking dare!” Courtney shouts defiantly. In response, you place your hand on her neck and squeeze. **** her lightly. Enough to restrict her breathing, but not enough that she can’t answer you when you ask her again.

“Answer the question.” You tell her. Courtney tries to take in bated breaths, but whatever air she takes in gets wasted by having to moan from your continuous pounding. You can see her eyes just trying to look in your direction, as you watch her struggle for air.

Finally, her resistance weakens, and Courtney gives you her answer — “I... am... hngngh-khhll”, as her eyes roll onto the back of her head, and tears start to streak down her cheeks. You stop your squeeze on her neck, and look at your phone for confirmation.

Lust Score: 100 (+1)

+50 Lust Points. Total: 200 (For reaching the 100+ Lust Score goal with a person)

You don’t hesitate any further and unload inside Courtney’s pussy.

You and Courtney gasp at the exact same time, as you fill her pussy with cum, while she finally gets an opportunity to properly breathe. You stay inside Courtney for a few more seconds, before pulling your dick out of Courtney; releasing your semen onto the awaiting tongue of your girlfriend.

“Drink it all, you cum dump.”