Sarah, but Miranda decides to help

Your ears seemed to be ringing as you watched the nightmarish scene play out in front of you. A short time ago in the kitchen you were overjoyed at the prospect of dating your childhood best friend, but now all you could feel is an impossibly large pit in your stomach as she was manhandled by Tom - his strong hands gripping her firmly either side of her hips and using her asshole like a fleshlight.

Nicole looked nothing like the sweet girl you arrived with - her blonde hair was matted with Tom's dried cum, and swung uniformly as Tom slammed her on his cock, the newborn cumslut moaning loudly in time with his brutal use of her ass. Her hands held firmly onto the armchair's armrests to stabilize herself and give Tom the perfect angle into her ass and allow him to focus on lifting and slamming her down. Despite your ears ringing and a pit of emotions swirling inside you, you couldn't bring yourself to look away.

After what felt like an eternity, Tom slammed Nicole down and didn't lift her again. Confusion took you as Tom clearly hadn't cum yet, nor seemingly had Nicole. Suddenly you became acutely aware of your tunnel-vision on the scene in front of you as Miranda and Sarah crawled on all fours up to Tom's armchair. Both girls' pussy lips shimmered in the light, their arousal clear as day - you even spotted a clear stream running down Miranda's inner thigh. Sarah hopped to her knees to reach Tom and Nicole's ears and spoke softly to them, but you couldn't make out any words due to your ears ringing. Tom listened attentively and wolfishly smiled, whereas Nicole continued breathing deeply with an impatient horniness on her face, her eyes darting town to her pussy that was starting to slowly leak Matt's cum onto Tom's balls and the chair.

Tom and Nicole quickly moved after Sarah had stopped talking - Nicole planted her feet either side of Tom's thighs and drew herself off him slightly while leaning back into Tom's chest. This position allowed him to be able to thrust up into her without having to move her body, while her legs were spread, revealing her well-fucked creamy pussy to the waiting Miranda. Miranda, for her part, had drawn herself up to her knees and almost immediately dove in, eating Nicole out with vigor, audibly sucking Matt's cum from her folds.

Tom resumed his thrusting into Nicole's ass at the same time, causing Nicole to scream loudly and arc her back into Tom at the sudden dual stimulation. Nicole's half crust and half-sweaty hair was strewn all over Tom's neck, chest and face, but he didn't seem to mind, using his now free hands to grope one of Nicole's tits and grab her throat dominantly. You suddenly remembered Tom's previous dare as Sarah pulled Miranda's head away from Nicole's slavering twat, and kissed her deeply, visibly transferring Matt's cum from Miranda's mouth to Sarah's. Tom, realizing what was going on, used his hands on Nicole's throat to hold her head perfectly straight up.

"Open wide slut" he growled. Nicole hardly needed instruction, as her mouth had been open to release moans of pleasure since Tom resumed his reaming of her ass, but still eagerly opened her mouth as wide as it would go and lolled her tongue out, lewd moans still ekeing out from between her frenzied breathing.

Sarah completed the cycle by hovering her head over Nicole's eager mouth and gently spitting a mass of Matt's cum, her and Miranda's saliva and Nicole's own pussyjuice, directly into her mouth. Miranda had already resumed her work, eating Nicole out and harvesting the next mouthful of cum ad pussyjuice for Sarah to feed her. As Sarah finished feeding her, Nicole began visibly cumming without warning, her screams reaching fever peak as she played with the fluids in her mouth with her tongue.

"Cum for us you filthy cumslut!" Tom shouted at her while increasing his pace inside her ass, visibly **** Nicole as she arched her back and her toes curled into the armchair. Miranda moaned in surprise as Nicole's juices overflowed her mouth as the she reached her peak, with Sarah quickly pulling her off Nicole's pussy for a quick fluid-transfer kiss before Miranda dived back in, not missing a beat.

Nicole was still rolling through her orgasm as Sarah went to feed her the second load, and Tom was visibly busy fucking Nicole at pace, while seemingly trying not to cum himself. Sarah tried her best to use her hands to hold Nicole's head in place with her mouth open as she released the slimy mixture above the cumslut. From your position on your couch, you couldn't actually see much of Nicole's face after her orgasm began, her head thrown back and body arched, but as she began to come down from her high, it was clear that only some of the load had made it to her mouth, as Nicole's tongue licked out at her wet and slimy face to suck in what it could reach.

Tom's pace slowed as Nicole completed her orgasm, and his expression evened from strained pleasure to gleeful lust - clearly the risk of him cumming had abated with Nicole's rapture. Nicole was still non-verbal as her body settled into a more natural flush position against Tom, moans and labored breathing were the only noises she had made in some time. Still, the maniacal, evil glint in her eyes was present as she locked eyes with you for a moment before your view of her face was obstructed by Sarah leaning in front to lock lips with her and deliver her the final load of Matt's cum Miranda had been able to extract from her nethers.

Miranda, her job assisting Sarah complete, collapsed back from her kneeling position onto her back in the middle of the room, her head coming to rest on Matt's bare thigh, who was still lying where Nicole had left him. Miranda was breathing quickly, clearly having given her all in eating Nicole out. She seemed surprised at literally bumping into Matt. As you looked down at him, he'd clearly been witness to the degeneracy occurring around Tom - his cock was at half mast despite still being wet from Nicole's lusty riding barely fifteen minutes ago. Miranda shuffled herself along his leg until the back of her head was nestled below Matt's groin, and then tilted her head to the side so her lips were able to touch the underside of his half hard cock. She winked up at him before beginning to lazily lick the underside base of his cock, causing Matt to exhale quickly as his cock throbbed with the stimulation.

"... Dare!..." the one word breaking you out of your daze. Sarah had taken a seat in the middle of the double couch, spread eagle just as Miranda had been after she fucked Tom. Sarah's pussy was soaked and creamy - you idly reflect that she has been involved in most of the sex acts tonight but not cum herself. As she made a point of stirring up the names in the hat, Nicole pulled herself into a reverse squatting position on Tom and began fucking her ass on his length as athletically as she had Matt. To your alarm, she was smirking and seeking out your eyes, the evil glint in her eyes brighter than ever as her body flushed and shimmered with arousal sweat and exertion of working for her first anal creampie.

"Now...mmhmmm... give it to me stud.. NOW" Nicole moaned at Tom, her gaze not shying from you for a second as she picked up the pace, clearly impatient with the asshole she was currently fucking. You couldn't hold her gaze any longer, and looked to the floor as Tom began to groan. To your dismay, your gaze fell to Miranda and Matt, your crush and girlfriend's temptress still lazily resting on her back against Matt while rubbing her clit and fingering her pussy with two fingers as she licked Matt's now rock hard length teasingly.

Avoiding Nicole's penetrating gaze, you looked to the side, watching Sarah unfold a name with her eager pussy on display.

"The winner is.."