More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 5 by IAmNotKevinLee IAmNotKevinLee

What's next?

Sarah's Turn!

Hello. I am the person who commissioned BreaktheBar to write the first three chapters of this thread. As such, I have automatic permission to write for this thread. My goal is to explore the SPH (Small Penis Humiliation) kink in a way that doesn't result with every character being mean-spirited toward the character with a small penis. There are moments where PE (Premature Ejaculation) happens as well. Hopefully me and BreaktheBar will be able to satisfy. Speaking of which, feel free to message BreaktheBar privately if you'd like to order a commission; they'll be happy to provide more details. Now enjoy!


As the bottle spun around and around, I eyed the people around me, hoping none had seen my growing erection in my shorts. Thankfully that was the case.The bottle soon stopped upon Sarah. She grinned in delight as she gazed around the table, letting all eyes fall onto her. All of that attention, I could tell she liked it.

"Let's kick it up a notch, shall we?" I saw Sarah pulling on her bikini top, teasing me and the other two men. Perhaps Miranda and Nicole too. One hard pull and she would be topless, exposing those large breasts to us all. "A dare please."

I noticed Matt's flustered face, as he tried to be respectful and not look there. "Hey Matt, is everything okay? Don't tell me the ****'s already hitting you." Nicole pouted a little, though a hint of amusement could've been there. If I knew her well enough.

"For fuck's sake, dude. We all know what you're doing." Tom rolled his eyes, taking another gulp of his drink. "Sarah doesn't give a shit if you're looking at her boobs." I notice Matt almost shooting a piercing glare at Tom. Not that I'd blame him though.

"Well I think it's respectable that he tried not to." Miranda chimed in, giving Tom a disapproving look. It was clear these two were polar opposites in terms of personality. A mother figure against an asshole of an athlete.

I was about to provide my own input when Matt beat me to the punch. "All right all right. We don't have to make a big deal out of this." He didn't give anyone a specific look, not even Tom. Though he decided to be the provider again. "Sarah... I dare you to kiss me on the lips. Three seconds." Tom almost palmed his face in annoyance.

"Seriously? What's with the boring stuff, man? How many exes and now a three-second kiss?" Tom started to complain, as usual. He probably wanted Sarah to take off her top or something along those lines. "Let me provide an actual good dare -"

"Give the guy a break, why don't you." I blurted out, coming to Matt's aid. "It's only the start of the game." Don't get me wrong, I'm up for some nudity, but Tom needed to chill.

"It's all right, hun." Sarah gave us the assuring look, though I felt like she looked at me in particular as she said that. Maybe it was just the angle and perspective. She turned to Tom, a smirk forming. "Lay it on me, stud." Just as I expected, two hungry and lusty people gazing at each other.

I probably wasn't the only one confused right now. So much for Matt getting to lock lips. Tom though, I saw his smirk, and I knew the inevitable was coming. "Why don't you take off that top and show us what you're hiding?" Yup. It was the 'remove top' dare.

"Really, Tom?" Miranda crossed her arms over her breasts. She inadvertently gave them a little boost upward.

Meanwhile for Sarah, she wiggled her eyebrows and began reaching for the strings. Part of me gulped; I've always wondered what they truly looked like. I felt my penis getting more erect by the second, almost full mast. Thank God this patio table didn't have a transparent top.

Speaking of top, once Sarah's hand reached around to her back, she winked. "Get ready..." Then she turned her head toward Matt's direction. "To pucker up, handsome." I swore I saw Tom's expression turn into disappointment. Miranda and Nicole were trying to hold back their laughter.

"Oh damn! That was smooth as fuck!" Nicole grinned in excitement. I had never seen her more enthusiastic about two other people kissing. Must be from the **** or the game itself.

Both of them stood up and moved toward each other. Matt took a deep breath and closed his eyes, allowing his lips to make contact with Sarah's lips. She took the initiative and control, returning the same enthusiasm with the kissing. Within those three seconds, she opted to make a further move and caress his hair. It felt like watching a makeout scene for minutes. The two were standing very close to each other, as he wrapped his hands around her lower back. Her other hand started to touch his entire back -

"All right you two!" Nicole **** them to stop. "There's always a chance for you two to get a room!" She teased them as she drank another gulp of her beer, though she seemed to be annoyed too. Maybe I must be reading too much into her emotions and current thoughts.

As the two separated, Sarah couldn't help but smirk at the cool nerd. "You liked having your hair caressed?" Matt's face flushed from that, perhaps the hardest so far tonight.

"Yeah. It felt nice." I had to give Matt a fist bump for that. When we turned to Sarah, she winked and poor Matt looked a little more embarrassed. A giggle escaped Sarah's mouth before she slid over a second beer bottle.

"You wet your whistle again. This should help." With that all done, the rest of us turned to the empty bottle.

I took a deep breath.

It was my turn.

What's next?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)