Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 5 by BeckyS BeckyS

What's next?

Rejection can be Tough

Paige walked over to Stephen nervously the next morning before class, still with no idea why she was doing this. Maybe she had some disgusting kink she hadn't realised until now that made her want to fuck the geekiest guy she could find. It didn't matter, she would fuck him once to get it out of her system and then be done with it. She just had to make sure nobody ever found out. At least he should take next to no convincing. She was about to make his wildest dream come true.

"Hey, nerd. Want to cut class with me?" Paige cornered Stephen at his locker. She was talking as quietly as she could and made sure nobody else was in earshot "I'm sure we can find something more fun to do."

Stephen froze up in shock for a moment. Megan had told him this would happen. If she was able to predict something as implausible as this then her advice to play it cool was probably worth listening to. He needed to resist his overwhelming urge to go wherever Paige wanted to and wait for the bigger pay off.

"No thanks, I take my education seriously"

Paige was dumbstruck. She was never rejected by guys, ever. And the first time she ever got shot down it was by someone she was embarrassed to be seen talking to. She mostly wanted to yell at this loser, but part of her found his refusal strangely alluring.

"Okay, then, after class" Paige rolled her eyes "Do you understand what I am offering here?"

"I think so yes, but no thanks. You called me a nerd. I would never sleep with a girl who disrespected me."

Paige literally wanted to slap Stephen now. But again part of her liked it when he was dismissive of her. What could it possibly be that was making her feel that way, she wondered.

"Okay, sorry. You're not a nerd. I wouldn't ask a nerd out" she apologised as convincingly as she as managed "Okay, how about we hook up at a time that is convenient to you and I let you fuck me."

"Let me?"

"Okay, sorry. Not let. I want to."

"You want to what?"

"I want to fuck you" Paige blushed at what she realised she had just said and who she had said it to. Why was she even negotiating with this freak? And why was she loving him putting her in her place so much.

"You're embarrassed by me!"

"No, that's not it.."

"Then why were you whispering?"

"Alright then, I'll shout it I REALLY WANT TO FUCK YOU STEPHEN PLEASE ALLOW ME TO FUCK YOU!"

All of a sudden the corridor fell silent and Paige realised that all eyes were on her and Stephen and that everyone was waiting in suspense for his response to her unbelievable request. Paige just really hoped he couldn't say no at this point, partly because it would be the greatest humiliation of her life and partly because she wanted to fuck his brains out right now. But as far as Stephen was concerned everything Megan had told him was coming true. It only made sense to stick to the plan.

"Sorry Paige, I'm sure you are a really nice person but you just aren't my type."

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)