Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 5 by zechs195 zechs195

Who is it?

A rival from school

The car parked in front of the light and I knew it must be here for me. I was scared, but I had to believe they just wanted money. At least that’s what I hoped. I knew I had to protect Penelope either way.

Finally the door opened and out stepped a red headed woman about my age. I immediately recognized her as Ginger, she was on the basketball team with Penelope and I. The hope that this was about money became a lot less likely. Ginger also came from an incredibly wealthy family and she was without a doubt the meanest woman I had ever met. I put my eyes down praying that if I closed them and opened them again it would be someone else, but it was still her.

She approached very slowly and I wasn’t sure what to say, I was afraid to speak first. She was smiling ear to ear and she did nothing to hide the sadism in her eyes.

“Melany, funny meeting you here.”

She knew she had all the power here, still I wasn’t about to let her walk all over me.

“Ginger, what do you want?”

She giggled a little.

“Oh, I just had a little video to show you.”

She took out her phone, and played with it for a moment before flipping it to face me and turning it sideways. It was Charlie’s bedroom and Penelope and him were making out. After a minute or so he reached for the bottom of her shirt.

“Is this okay? If you’re not ready, I don’t want you to feel like you have to do this.”

Charlie was so sweet. I knew he wasn’t in on this.

Penelope just smiled and said “I love you, Charlie. I promise I’ve thought this through. I’m more than ready, I want this.”

Ginger hit the fast forward button and the video sped up. They made out passionately and I turned my head as I felt I was violating them just by viewing the video.

“Watch, watch it all or I will send this out.” Said Ginger.

“This isn’t right, she wouldn’t want me watching.” I said weakly.

“Okay, fair enough. Who do I send it to first? Her father and her pastor? How about Facebook?”

“Don’t…” I whispered.

“Then watch.”

I turned my head back and watched the accelerated video after Ginger unpaused it. They slowly took off each other’s clothes, there were hurried breaths, kissing, and tender romance. After they were fully nude, it felt even more invasive to be watching, I had to **** myself to keep my eyes open as I felt incredibly guilty. Penelope had large pale breasts, and Charlie had a decent sized dick. After more kissing Penelope started giving him a handjob while Charlie seemed to ask for consent again, it was hard to make out the exact words with the video going so fast, before reaching between her legs. There were moans of passion of expressions of love and it seemed like they had a really special time.

Things started getting more sexual and I started to turn away again. Ginger reached out and grabbed my chin and I did nothing to resist as she turned it back.

“Hot, isn’t it?” She asked and I said nothing.

As it continued Penelope got on her hands and knees and I could see the side of her ass in front of him and she started sucking his penis. He rubbed her back and gently massaged her breasts. Sometime later, she laid back and he got between her legs and started exploring her womanhood with his tongue as she moaned in passion.

After it him going down on her for several minutes he got up and grabbed a condom. He asked for consent again and I tried to turn my head but Ginger grabbed my face again. The next thing I saw was Penelope accepting him inside her. They made love and were kissing tenderly the whole time. She was held him close to her as he slowly and gently and penetrated her. There moans and kisses and sweat, and eventually Penelope arched her back digging nails into him and it seemed like she came, a short while later he did too. They started cuddling and Ginger stopped the video.

“What do you think?” Asked Ginger.

“I think I shouldn’t have watched that. I don’t think anyone should watch that.”

“Well so far it’s had only had three viewers. You, Steven, and I.”

Steven was Charlie’s older brother. He must have set up the camera.

“How many more viewers do you think it should have?”

I choked back tears as I realized how fucked I was.

“None…”

“Okay, well only you get to decide that. If you follow all of my instructions then no one will ever see it. I promise.”

I nodded hesitantly.

“So you’re acknowledging you’ll follow all my instructions?”

Does she agree?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)