The softball player, McCall

You opened the door, expecting to see Felicia's cheerful face, ready to help you get ready, even though there was still two hours to go and you didn't think you needed two hours to prepare. However, it wasn't a happy Felicia, it was an angry--and then confused--McCall.

"Is she here? Is Archer here?" is all she said, trying to look over your shoulder into your apartment.

Time to play dumb. You stared at McCall, not really knowing what to say at first. She didn't recognize you in this body, at least. Time to ask questions and deflect! "Excuse me, who are you? And no, I'm the only one here."

McCall put her hands on her hips, some sort of plan forming in her head, shifting gears at this sudden turn of events. "I had a friend who said they saw her enter this apartment. I'm... on the softball team and wanted to congratulate her on her performance today. I'm Josie McCall. And you are?"

You frowned, squinting a little. "You can call me John." Clearly, she came here to do something that lived up to her threat from before, but now that you were in front of her, she needed a different plan of attack. She sniffed at the air, then looked down to see a pair of smaller shoes near the door. And then, glancing just beyond you, a familiar looking baseball glove to one she saw at the field earlier...

Josie's demeanor took a full one-eighty. You guessed that she guessed that you were still something to 'Archer'. "And maybe you two are, what, dating or something, John?" Josie pushed a hand against your chest, causing you to step backwards as she made her way into your apartment, looking around like a wolf hunting a rabbit, before snapping back to you.

"Err... sure, I guess. Like, it's just a--"

Josie interrupted your explanation with a kiss to your lips and a hand down your pants. This was... unexpected, to say the least. With her practiced caresses, your dick came to life in a matter of moments, and Josie chuckled lightly to herself as she kicked the door shut as she whispered seductively in your ear. "I think you can do better than her. I want to be that for you. Anything you want, I'll give it to you. And believe me when I say I'm very flexible and my stamina is unbounded." She gives you a little shove, causing you to scoot back a few steps, while Josie started to take off her shirt.

This was her plan? She was going to make the other half of you jealous by seducing this half of you so you'd do what, break up with yourself? It probably seemed stupider to you when you knew that you that John and Jane were the same person. Lots of stupid going around today, most of it your fault apparently. ...Although you had to admit, Josie had a killer body, as she slipped out of her pants so she was clad in baby-blue bra and panties, this girl with long dark hair pulled back into a ponytail was really impressive.

You didn't make any moves, but you didn't exactly resist, as Josie stepped forward again, grabbing your hands and placing them right on her breasts, encouraging you to squeeze. "You can have my body for whatever you want," Josie whispered, "I'll be your toy in every conceivable way. You just have to say you want me, and only me. And then your deepest fantasies are yours for the taking..." Her fingers ran along your crotch again, fondling your dick through the pants, and you couldn't help but shiver.

You had quite the decision to make, kind of. Well, the decision was more complicated than even Josie knew, but all your bad decisions today have turned out just fine, so what's one more? This felt like a betrayal to Archer though--but like, the real Archer, not the one Josie thought she knew. It would be really convenient if something happened to stop things from going too far...