Interrogate her

"Blackdekker close the door!" one guy screamed.

"What does one do with a witch?" a guy asked.

"I'm not a witch!" Natalie screamed.

"Explain to us. What were you doing!? What have you done in the past?"

"Google says you either burn them or drown them."

"We're not burning anyone. I wanna know what you did to us. You had me **** you in the toilet?"

"No that was just..." Natalie stuttered.

"What the fuck did you make Ms Pecker do to you? In Biology?"

"Holy shit I was supposed to go next in biology. Why doesn't Pecker remember?" said the guy that apparently was the one that was so intrusive during her examination.

"You do weird shit and then make people forget about it right?"

"Y--- yes." Natalie agreed.

"Why? You think it's hot?"

"Yes..."

"Then why are you covering?"

"Well it's just... It's not hot if I don't cover..." Natalie said.

"She's fucked up lads."

"Why were we seeing you as Pete a minute ago? Were you peeking at us?"

"M- Maybe. I also just wanted to be here... You know..." She said.

"She was pretending to be me? How did you fall for that?" Pete asked.

"Well she didn't pretend she was already acting weird. We just looked at her and saw you."

"That's fucked man."

"She's fucked."

"I think she has been fucked by all of us right?"

Most guys nodded. Actually one of them she hadn't. He had a bad breath. Poor dude probably felt too embarrassed to say anything.

"So what do we do?" One of them asked.