Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 41 by reaper13 reaper13

Does Penny accept her cousin’s offer?

She does

The very next day Jenny and Penny are already heading over to Greg’s place. Both are excited but each for a different reason.
When they arrive at Greg’s front door both blondes are giddy with excitement. Jenny rings the doorbell and Penny giggles. A few seconds later Greg opens the door … and Penny’s smile disappears so fast Greg probably never noticed she had it to begin with.
“Jenny, welcome.” Greg says, and leans forward to give her a kiss.
Jenny kisses him back and says, “Hey, Greg. This is my cousin, Penny.”
“Hello.” Penny replies politely.
“Good afternoon, Penny.” Greg greets her and holds out his hand.
Penny shyly puts her hand in his and shakes it.
Greg then asks the girls to step inside. Jenny gently pushes her cousin inside. Step one of Jenny’s plan is complete.

Greg soon asks the girls if they want anything to drink.
“I’d like a soda, please.” Jenny says.
“No thanks, I’m not thirsty.” Penny replies.
When Greg disappears into the kitchen, Penny grabs her cousin by the arm and whispers, “You never said he was black.”
Jenny had expected Penny to say something like that. After all, their dads are brothers and both conservatives.
“Should that matter? I mean, you’re not racist are you?” Jenny asks her cousin with a hushed voice, knowing it could put her on the defense.
“No, of course not.” Penny hisses. “But … you know what they say about black guys.”
“Like …?” Jenny asks softly, pretending not to know.
“Well, that the only reason they are interested in white girls like us is to just to make us pregnant with their black babies.” Penny whispers.
Jenny has heard that accusation herself more than enough. She’s heard it from her dad, her uncle, from the news media her parents watch. Frankly, the more she heard how wrong it was to let a black guy put his baby inside her, the more it excited her to do it. She even hoped those two times of Greg planting his seed in her at the convention had taken root. Now she wants to see her cousin get black bred just like she has been. Luckily she’s prepared a response to that.
“Oh, come on, Penny. That is super racist to say.” Jenny whispers pretending to be outraged. “In fact, the people who say stuff like that are usually white guys who are unable to find a girlfriend on their own and try to blame others for their failings. I thought you were smarter than that.”
Before Penny can respond, Greg comes back from the kitchen, bringing the whispered conversation to a halt and letting Jenny’s last sentence stew in Penny’s mind.

Greg holds out a plate in front of the girls with on it a closed can of cola, a glass of water a jar of salted peanuts.
“Oh, wow. You added a snack for us?” Jenny asks.
“I felt it would be cheap to offer just something to drink.” Greg replies.
“Oh, Greg. You didn’t have to.” Jenny says while she takes a few peanuts and puts them in her mouth. “Not for, well, what we came here to do.”
Jenny makes a glance at her cousin and smiles at her. Penny glances back at her cousin, then at Greg.
After Jenny grabs the can and opens it, Greg places the plate on a small table and sits on his sofa. Penny takes a seat on the other side and Jenny sits in between them.
“You know, I must admit, I’m a bit nervous.” Greg says while he takes the glass of water.
“Nervous how?” Jenny asks.
Greg finishes a sip from his glass and says, “Well, I’ve never been with two girls at the same time. Let alone a girl I’ve never seen before. I usually wait until second or third date.”
“Yeah, I know. I’ve never been in a threesome either.” Jenny replies and takes a sip from the can.
Penny just sits there following the conversation until she hears Greg say he thinks she is intimidating.
“Intimidating?” Penny asks. “Me?”
“Well yeah.” Greg explains. “Jenny just told me this would be your first time. When I had my first I was totally insecure. Like, constantly worried someone might interrupt us or something. But you are jumping straight into a threesome. That just has to require a lot of confidence.”
Jenny grabs a handful of peanuts and tells Penny, “Careful girl. You’ll make him too afraid to perform.” Then she eats the nuts.
“Don’t worry, I’m not that confident at all. I’m quite nervous, really.” Penny replies.
“I see.” Greg says. “Maybe it’s best to let you know beforehand, should you change your mind about going through with this, I’ll understand. So please don’t **** yourself into anything you’re not sure of.”
Penny smiles and says, “Thanks you, Greg. That makes me feel a lot better.”
“Soooo …” Jenny suddenly interrupts. “… how shall we get this started?”
Greg shifts closer to his girlfriend and puts his hand on hers.
“I propose we two start making out and when Penny feels it is appropriate, she can join us.” The black guy says.
His white girl smiles back at him and says, “Mmmh, I like the sound of that.”

How long does it take for Penny to join them?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)