Sarah (Sarah's sadistic scheme)

Her cheeks still stinging crimson, Nicole dug hurriedly in the hat, eager for anything to take the focus off her. When she grabbed a firm hold of a name, she didn't bother with any dramatics or tension building teasing, instead she drew it straight out.

"Sarah," she said quickly, even pointing at the red haired succubus with the hand that held the slip, in an effort to move everyone's attention on to her. The buxom slut simply smiled at what she could have construed as a rude gesture, since she already had an inkling of what Nicole would have her do, and that was something she wanted to do anyway.

"I dare you to go sit with Matt again, and you have to stay in some contact with him for the rest of the game, unless expressly stated otherwise by another dare, or on the condition that you are given permission for a temporary reprieve from myself or the majority of the game's participants!" Nicole rattled off her entire dare in one breath, evidently having spent a lot of time thinking about the specifics of what she wanted Sarah to do.

The petite girl's dare may have been more verbose and technically than Sarah had imagined, but it was still very much in line with what she had expected. Nicole was still sticking to whatever plan the nerds had hatched before tonight, even if John had gone off script.

He did seem to be back on the same page as the others now, however, as he practically rushed Sarah away from himself. Two pudgy hands on her back and hips guided her quickly to her feet as she stood up, with John trying to get her away like she was evidence. Since he now once again thought he had a real chance with Miranda, he didn't want living proof that his feelings for her had ever wavered sitting topless in his lap.

That fickle nature just made Sarah smile more, as her resolve to punish him hardened. Without a backwards look at John, she swayed her hips straight back across the room, to Matt. The pathetic dork's eyes lit up as he saw her return, and his weak hands trembled as they clutched at the edge of the blanket.

"It's good to be back, baby," she muttered, faking a smile as she put a manicured hand on his bare shoulder. Before he could stutter out a reply, she turned her back on him and sat down on his knee, much like she had done with John before. Matt's bony knee was much less comfortable, without the thick padding of John's, but she was just glad to be back on track.

John's soft hearted detour had nearly derailed her plan, and the only reason it hadn't fallen apart was because of Nicole's input. She'd have to pay that sweet, innocent, girl back for that. Maybe she would let her ride Tom's massive cock twice, before she kicked her out.

"Is this a good enough "form of contact" Nicole?" Sarah asked, grinding her soft ass against Matt's leg to accentuate her point.

"Haha, yes, I guess that will do," Nicole laughed in response, the pink blush that had filled her cheeks slowly fading now that more eyes were on Sarah.

"In that case, could you pass me the hat? I don't want to break the rules."

Nicole obeyed the request without hesitation, jump to her feet and delivering the hat right into Sarah's outstretched palm. The sudden hop as she stood up nearly raised her skirt enough to flash her panties again, but she managed to give the hat to Sarah and sit back down without further exposing herself.

"Thank you sweetie," Sarah replied, flashing the shorter girl a dazzling smile and then a nearly imperceptible wink. The nerd had just gotten her first taste of pussy, and she had seemed quite good at it. Sarah saw advantages to staying on this novice pussy-eater's good side as well as keeping her off kilter. The wink seemed to do just that, with Nicole's blush returning with a vengeance.

Turning her attention away from Nicole, Sarah sat back on Matt's leg, his breath hitching behind her as she settled in his lap like a cat. "I-I-It's n-nice to have you back," he muttered, trembling hands going very weakly to her waist.

"Aww, sweet," she replied, running her fingers down his own with one hand while the other laid the hat on her knee.

"Enjoy it while it lasts," she thought, "Soon, I'm gonna make you hate me."

XXXXXXXXXXXXX
Thanks for reading, I hope you've been enjoying this thread. All your support, both here and on Patreon, means a lot to me, and I mean it when I say it is part of the reason I keep writing. Today on my Patreon, I've posted an alternate version of events for Nicole having to eat out Miranda. Let's just say, she gets a lot more into it/ If that interests you, or if you want to support me even more, then become a Patreon member for early access and poll participation.

https://www.patreon.com/Cheesers123