Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)
Chapter 25
by
Cheesers123
What does Tom pull out?
His ridiculously big hog
It was hard for Sarah to keep the grin from her face as Tom hooked his thumbs into the elastic waistband of his underwear. She knew what was coming next, and she loved to see it every time. The pace of her pumping fist in Matt's lap increased as she bit her lip and stared across the room, eyes unblinking so that she wouldn't miss a moment of the show.
At an agonizing pace, born of easy confidence, Tom began to push down his boxers. Sarah knew he could have just used the button fly of his boxers but, like her, Tom was a show off. As his pubes came into view Sarah noticed that they were mostly short and neat, something she had never appreciated until she had put her hand down Matt's pants, his wiry mess of pubic hair still grating against her wrist as she watched.
Tom only had to pull his underwear down for a second for him to inadvertently put Matt completely to shame. Just the base conveyed how pleasantly girthy his cock was, being too much for Sarah to grip with just one hand instead of neatly filling her palm like Matt's did. Already, she could see him quail out of the corner of her eye, as if Matt was suddenly realizing that he would have to compare his little dicklet to a real man's cock.
But Tom was only just getting started.
Inch after inch of his meaty phallus slowly came into view as he continued to draw down his boxers, with the room growing ever quieter as his huge cock just kept going. The show had only just begun and Sarah could already see Miranda's and Nicole's eyes widen, while a peachy flush of excitement filled their cheeks. As his waistband descended, so too did their jaws, their shocked amazement growing as a cock bigger than any they had ever dreamed of was revealed between an arrogant jock's legs.
The look on their faces was an expression that Sarah recognized all too well, having worn it herself more than a few times. She still fondly remembered the first time he'd flashed his humongous piece of fuckmeat to her. At one of her first campus parties, he'd pulled her into the bathroom and arrogantly flashed it to her.
The fact that Tom's cock was this good made Matt's attempts to woo her even sadder, or funnier depending on your point of view.
From Sarah's point of view in the moment, however, Tom's cock was finally fully released from his underwear, and she had to bite down on her thumb to keep from whistling in appreciation. Only semi-hard, it still hung halfway to his knees, 12 inches of languid sexuality that never failed to make her drool. At the end of it was it's fat head, a swelling almost the size of her fist, with just enough softness to allow it to pummel her cervix without a flash of pain.
Tom was the complete center of attention, and he knew it. With his hands on his hips, he turned to face Miranda and then Nicole, swinging his mighty cock around like the weapon it was. Beneath his shaft, his swollen balls were impressive too. They were perfectly proportional to his cock, like two wrecking balls to accompany his swinging crane. The sight of his full package was obviously (and understandably) affecting Miranda and Nicole.
Miranda was openly giggling in disbelief, her eyes only briefly leaving his cock to glance quickly aorund the room as if she was expecting the whole thing to be a prank. Nicole, meanwhile, furrowed her brow in confusion as her hands irritably scrunched the bottom hem of her tiny skirt. Balled in her lap like that, it almost looked like her hands were about to start playing with herself.
It was like Tom's genitals were designed to drive horny coeds like them and Sarah wild, before fucking dangerously sticky creampies deep into them.
Looking at their faces, Sarah had to suppress a giggle. When she had told them that the guy she was talking about had a "monster cock", she should have explained that she really meant it had the same dimensions as a can of Monster energy drink.
Beside Sarah, Matt had gone stiff as a board, and she swore she felt his little dick shrivel up a little more in fear. Twiddling his cock around in his lap like a gearshift, she leant over to put her lips to his ear. "Ohh, size doesn't matter, babe," she cooed into his ear, slathering her words with so much honey that it actually looked like he believed her. For a smart nerd, he had to be pretty stupid to actually think his little cock could compete with one literally 10x it's size.
When the room was still silent after a few more seconds of swaggering, Tom spoke up again. "What's the matter ladies?" He asked, "cock got your tongue?" That lame joke drew a nervous laugh from Miranda, who thoughtlessly covered her mouth with the same hand she had been using to conceal her bare breasts. Tom's cock had only been out for 30 seconds, and a girl was already flashing him right back. That had to have been a new record.
"I see Miranda likes it," he commented, his eyes going to her temporarily uncovered tits. Blushing Miranda put her forearm back across her hard nipples, but not before Tom got enough of an eyeful of her 36C breasts to make his long cock twitch.
"What about you, Nicole?" He continued, turning to face her and whipping his dick around yet again. "You like?" As he asked the question he took his dick by the middle and held it up for her to appraise, earning a frown and a blush from her.
"It's completely ridiculous," Nicole huffed, "just a statistical anomaly, a quirk of biology, you just happen to fall outside of the mean in this one area. In every respect, you're still a boorish oaf. Besides, the average vaginal canal only has a depth of 3-5 inches anyway, so all those inches that you're gloating about are irrelevant."
She was panting by the time she finished, her stormy eyes glaring at his smug face, before flitting hurriedly down to his cock and back.
"Yeah, she likes it," Tom laughed off her rant, making her turn to red that her ears went pink. Before she could retort, he turned his back on her and reached for the hat. "Satisfied, Sarah?" He asked as he picked up the names from the table.
"Mmhmm," she nodded, "that seems like a fair trade for two pairs of boobs." Another smug grin was his answer to that, as he grabbed the brim of the hat before straightening up. In the brief second she had before he drew a name, Sarah looked around at the other gentlemen in the room.
Matt's mind was clearly still scrambled by her soft hand encompassing his cock, but a bead of nervous sweat had still formed on his temple just above his glasses. Multiple beads of sweat decorated John's brow, although given his size they might have been there the whole time. He wouldn't meet Sarah's eye, but she could still gauge how he was feeling without even needing to make eye contact with him.
The whole time since Tom had started his dare, John had been staring at Miranda. His heavy brow had become more and more furrowed as she had looked increasingly pleased by Tom's emerging cock. When she dropped her guard to titter at Tom's lame joke, John's fingers had sank deeply into the arms of his chair, a position they had remained in ever since.
"If you'd just leave now, you could spare yourself even more heartache," Sarah thought, "and for a guy as big as you, too much heartache might be fatal."
Sarah's cruelly mocking thoughts were interrupted as Tom retook his seat, throwing himself down besides Miranda and making her giggle in shock again. With his bare cock so close to her, her eyes struggled to choose where to stay. Like flitting birds, they flew from his cock, to the hat, to his face, and back, unsure where exactly was safest to land. Eventually, they settled on the hat, although that might have been because it was on his thigh right beside his thick member.
After a final stretch to get comfortable, that "inadvertently" involved him pushing his hips far forward, Tom reached into the hat to draw a name of his own.
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
Thank you for reading, I hope you enjoyed this chapter. Sorry about the late upload for those of you who were keeping track, I've been unwell lately and wasn't even sure if I'd be able to upload today at all. Fortunately, I managed.
If you enjoyed this chapter and want to see the next two, then please consider joining my Patreon. Your support is always welcome.
What does Tom draw?
The Afterparty
Six friends continue the party with a naughty game.
A group of friends gets closer than ever.
Updated on Jan 16, 2026
by Cheesers123
Created on Aug 28, 2014
by Cloontang1
You can customize this story. Simply enter the following details about the main characters.
- 51,519 Likes
- 19,201,145 Views
- 4,161 Favorites
- 9,744 Bookmarks
- 3,243 Chapters
- 106 Chapters Deep
- All Comments
- Chapter Comments
