Sarah

Once again, you eyes read over Sarah's name between your and Miranda's bodies. Glancing upward, you shared a look of confusion with your crush. The two of you had collaborated on a dare for her so recently that nothing immediately jumped to mind to dare her to do. At the moment she was still sitting on Matt, and you wouldn't want to disrupt his happiness anymore than you would want someone splitting up yourself and Miranda.

Above you, Miranda rested a hand on her chin in thought, her index finger drumming gently against the corner of her mouth as her eyes wandered absentmindedly. Finally, her eyes lit up with a spark of inspiration. "Ooh, here's a fun one," she whispered quite loudly, apparently the two of you working together on dares was now an open secret. "Like the reverse of her dare for Nicole," she continued, "make her kiss someone she has kissed before."

That sounded good to you and, with no ideas of your own coming to mind, you nodded your head in agreement until a thought suddenly struck you. "Would that include you?" You asked, raising an eyebrow at her. Miranda's sudden smirk and the blushing of her cheeks were all the answer you needed. "Wouldn't you like to know," she teased, making your dick throb in your pants and brush against her once more.

With the possibility of getting to see your crush make out with the second hottest girl on campus (in your opinion) at the forefront of your mind, you opened your mouth to give your dare. "Sarah, I dare you to make out with someone who you've kissed before," you announced. Sarah had been either kissing or whispering quietly to Matt, but when you announced her name she looked up with sparkling eyes that seemed to twinkle mischievously when she heard her dare.

"Isn't that just Nicole's dare again? I thought we couldn't repeat?" Tom said, his face looking as confused as he sounded. "Kinda, but more like the opposite," you shrugged. That was enough to quell any further argument, the dare was technically different enough that everyone else accepted it. "So if I kiss someone I haven't kissed before then do I get spanked too?" Sarah asked, already sounding like she might have been hoping for that. "Yes, if you can find someone that you've never kissed before," Miranda shot back, making her friend laugh.

"Maybe Sarah's punishment should be that she can't get spanked again tonight," you mused, making her pout. "Oh come on, let's not spoil the fun for everyone," she whined playfully, shaking her fat ass to emphasis just how fun it was. While most of the group were distracted by her ass, Sarah smiled to herself She was glad that, for now at least, your goals and hers seemed to align. You both wanted to keep Matt happy by keeping him near her. While Sarah's motive to have him on her side was different to your loyalty to your friend, the end result was still the same.

As for the dare itself, it was something she could achieve simply enough. Thinking about it, there were probably only two people in the room she hadn't kissed. John and Nicole, but even then that might have been a case of her memory failing her. She knew she'd kissed Matt because it was what she'd been doing right before the dare was announced, and she knew she'd kissed Tom because they had done everything else. As for Miranda, the two of them had certainly fooled around a bit after a few drinks.

Like a kid in a candy store, Sarah felt spoilt for choice. Matt would be the simplest option, she wouldn't even have to move. Kissing Miranda might serve to excite her, which could make Sarah's grander scheme easier in the long run, in addition to being a lot of fun showing off to the boys. The worst option was undoubtedly Tom. He was hot, and a good kisser, but it would only antagonize Matt after she'd worked so hard to get his support. Although, it could make Miranda or Nicole jealous.

She could even take a wild card and kiss John or Nicole, there was every chance she'd planted her lips on them at some point when she was drunk and forgotten about it. In the off chance she was wrong the worst that could happen would be getting spanked, although losing a dare would sting and slow down her plan a little.

Whomever she was going to choose, she would have to do it soon. Matt was looking up at her with puppy dog eyes again, in addition to everyone else's waiting stares.

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

This weeks CHYOA chapter is only fairly short, but there's a much longer one already available on my Patreon for my Patrons. I'm not saying size is everything, but there are definitely some characters in this story who would argue that bigger is better. If you agree with them, or are just curious to see what I've written a week early, or if you just want to support my biweekly writings, then please consider becoming a Patron.

https://www.patreon.com/Cheesers123