Nicole

Sarah had to fight to keep a grin off her face. She had drawn the perfect person, at the perfect time, after a slew of perfect dares. It was like everything had been leading up to this, events falling into place in just the right way to aid her greater plan. Sarah couldn't help but steal a glance at her target before making her announcement. Across the room Nicole pouted and rubbed her sore behind through her skinny jeans, obviously with no idea what Sarah had just drawn or what she had in mind for her.

"Nicole honey, I drew you," Sarah announced loudly, replacing the cute pout on Nicole's face with a look of surprise as her hand hurriedly retreated from her ass. "Since everyone seems to be so giving right now, I want you to give too," she continued, replacing Nicole's name in the hat and returning it to the table. Nicole already looked a little perturbed by Sarah's words, but she had no reason to be worried, yet. "I want you to give Tom a blowjob."

The moment those words were spoken, outrage broke out across the room.

"Sarah," Nicole and Matt sighed her name with varying degrees of anger and disappointment.

"Oh, now that is definitely favoritism," John argued, leaping predictably to Nicole's defense like a white knight.

Unfortunately for all of them, Sarah had expected her dare to cause an uproar, and she had come prepared with the perfect counter.

"What's the big deal? You got something from your crush, I got something from mine, why shouldn't Tom get something from his?"

The three bombs she had just dropped in a single sentence completely derailed the argument, shocking everyone in the room into silence. Her knowing about your infatuation with Miranda was somehow both the most personal and also least surprising thing she had just said. Her crush? Matt? And Tom's crush? Nicole?! The whole thing was so unexpected that it left your head reeling.

You weren't the only one. Matt had been shocked into wordless silence as well, looking up at Sarah from his position below her with open-mouthed awe again. Hearing her so candidly admit to having a crush on him had pushed rational thought out of his mind, now all he could do was stare at her admiringly like she was the rising sun. Nicole, meanwhile, was blushing through an entire spectrum of reds as her face twitched slightly, the thought of Tom having a crush on her evidently causing some sort of system error. Even Tom looked at Sarah with a face that could be taken as either utter confusion or irritation at his secret being outed.

This was the intended effect of Sarah's words, and she used it to push through her dare. "So Nicole, are you gonna suck Tom's dick for us, or are we all going to sit here getting blue balls?" She asked crudely, the utter bafflement of her detractors making her more confident. "Hey, I still think that dare's messed up," you continued to argue more weakly than before, "has Nicole ever even given a blowjob before?" Sarah knew the answer to that was "yes, and she loved it," but she wasn't about to expose that little tidbit unless she absolutely had to. "Wouldn't it be kinda messed up to **** her to do it the very first time like this?" You continued to defend her on an untrue point, if only you knew how she really felt about sucking cocks.

"Well, I'd never eaten pussy before and Miranda still made me do that," Matt interjected, before Sarah could be tempted to spill the beans on Nicole's oral fixation. It seemed that since Sarah had professed her "crush" on him that he was now on her side. "Wow really? You're a natural babe," Sarah rewarded him for siding with her by cupping his chin and kissing him, cementing him as an ally for at least the rest of this argument. You rolled your eyes at his change of heart, but accepted that, for as long as his crush was physically all over him, he was going to side with Sarah.

"*Mwah*, see John," Sarah broke the kiss, "doing new things is just part of the game. If Nicole doesn't want to do it that's fine, but she'll have to quit the game. It's up to her."

All eyes turned to Nicole now, to see what she would do. So many pairs of eyes zeroing in on her all at once made her freeze like a deer in the headlights, especially as her own thoughts had distracted her completely from the conversation. Since the dare had been announced, her thoughts had been bouncing wildly around her head from one thing to the next. Her first thought, to her shame, had been instant arousal. The game had been making her so horny, giving her so much to see but so little to touch, that the thought of wrapping her lips around a throbbing dick had unleashed butterflies in her stomach.

The next thought, was disgust, as she remembered that the dick would be attached to that asshole, Tom. The third thing to come to her mind had been a memory, of Tom stroking his dick into her face maybe an hour earlier. It had looked so big, thick, and meaty then, as he'd ran one strong hand up and down his girthy shaft, that Nicole found her wandering thoughts wrapping back around to arousal again. His dick would easily be the biggest she had ever sucked, maybe too big, but there was always pleasure to be had in a challenge, especially when that challenge involved slobbering all over such a magnificently masculine cock.

She'd been so busy daydreaming about wrapping her pretty little lips around Tom's monstrously big dong, that she didn't really pay attention to the argument over her dare until an abrupt silence recaptured her attention. Scrubbing through what she'd just heard, she really thought about Sarah's last sentence instead of just allowing it to go in one ear and out the other. "Tom gets something from his crush? ME? Tom has a crush on me?!"

That sudden revelation had sent her reeling just like that sentence had done to everyone else. It just didn't make any sense. Nicole didn't even know Tom was capable of feeling anything for a woman besides a desire to fuck her, now she was supposed to believe he had some genuine desire for her? That was ridiculous, it's not like Tom had been looking at her, touching her, teasing her, and flirting with her all night. . .

"Oh my god, does Tom actually have a crush on me?" That thought had sent her psyche down a twisting waterslide for a few moments, during which she couldn't find purchase on any solid thought to escape the spiral. It was only the sudden shift of focus on to her that stopped her, yanking her out and bringing her brain to a lurching halt. Again, she reexamined what she had only half heard to find the reason for the surprising pause, realizing with shock that it was now up to her to decide.

As she looked into Sarah's expectant eyes, Nicole found herself wondering something that she probably should have thought about sooner: Why is she doing this? Sarah helping Tom to hook up with his crush wouldn't make an awful lot of sense even if Nicole did really believe he had a crush on her. Did that red haired girl have another motive, was she still trying to punish Nicole just for kissing the wrong person? Or was it something even worse, did she think Nicole wanted this? Sarah had heard her talk about what she enjoyed in the shower, was this her trying to be nice to Nicole?

Whatever it was, the time for thinking was over. Everyone was waiting for her answer, to do the dare and keep playing or back down and lose.

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

Thanks for reading and I hope you enjoyed this chapter. I'm sure you can guess what Nicole chose to do, but if you just can't wait a week to find out then become a Patron and read it today. Nicole's whole slutty escapade is over 4k words that almost sees her giving in completely, so if you want to see that or you want to support me then check out my Patreon.

https://www.patreon.com/Cheesers123