Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 16 by Cheesers123 Cheesers123

What does Sarah draw?

You

From just a glance of her bedroom eyes you can guess what she's drawn, and from the way those hungry eyes hone in on your cock it seems that the only tension Sarah intends to relieve is your own."John. This dare should be pretty easy for you. You've already gone all night without cumming once, you've just got to last another measly two minutes." You can tell by the way Sarah's eye narrow and the corners of her mouth upturn that she's obviously not quite done. "While I do everything I can to make you finish." Her mischievous smirk broadens into a fully fanged grin, as she practically licks her lips looking at you.

"That seems kind of impossible for me to do." You argue weakly, gesturing to your already throbbing cock currently being almost torn in half between two soft female hands as Nicole and Miranda both vie for control of your joystick. "What's in it for me if I win?" You ask, deciding that you might play along if the reward is good enough. "Besides the best thing your cock has ever felt?" Sarah sounds almost offended that the offer of her worshipping your cock for two minutes wasn't enough to make you jump at the chance. "How about your next dare is a double dare. You get to draw two pieces of paper and make both of them do something for you." That certainly sounds like an interesting deal, immediately thoughts of how to make Miranda and Nicole "settle their differences" start to fill your mind. Although the dare itself and the upsides of succeeding are naturally appealing, you still need to know what you stand to lose if (when?) you fail.

"No one's failed a dare yet. What happens if I do? Is there a forfeit or something?" You ask, pessimistically or realistically accepting the possibility of defeat. "Since you think your dare is sooo hard how about a tiny penalty." She holds her thumb and forefinger close together for emphasis. "If you lose you'll skip giving a dare this turn and I'll draw two names instead. "You could take issue with that last detail, it seems that Sarah is setting herself up for an easy double dare, but you decide that the quibbling about the rules has already gone on long enough. This is meant to be a party game after all, not a contract negotiation.

It sounds like a deal with the devil to you, your cock has been teased all night and with Sarah's reputation for her cock draining skills resisting her for two minutes sounds impossible. But this is all just a game, you don't want to spoil the fun by saying no. Besides, part of you really wants to see what Sarah has planned for you, even if it makes you bust in two seconds. "Alright." You agree without sparing a thought for anyone else. It's only after you've already consented that you consider the other people in the room and you instinctively hunch down a little in anticipation of a smack from Nicole or Miranda who are both still all over you, but no strike is forthcoming. Still, you don't look at them for fear of their icy stares and you avoid looking over at Matt for the same reason.

As Sarah advances towards you you suddenly find yourself wishing you’d spent more time discussing exact terms. There was a lot you could get away with in the name of the game, but if Sarah jumped up and speared her sopping pussy onto your cock that would cause irreconcilable differences between you and your friends. Fortunately for you Sarah doesn’t climb up but instead kneels down, crawling between your legs and placing her hands on your thighs, like a loyal dog eagerly greeting her master. While one hand idly walks up and down your thigh the other drops to her jeans and fishes out her phone. A few taps later and the two minute timer is ready and Sarah's phone is entrusted to Nicole, there being no open space within reach on the couch due to Miranda and Nicole's legs pressed or entwined with yours.

As Sarah makes her final preparations, throwing her long red hair back over her shoulders and chasing a few stray strands off her face, you're struck again by how sexy she is. Miranda was classically beautiful like an artists muse and Nicole was cute as a doll but Sarah looked like she was built for sex. From her expansive porcelain bust, to her pouty crimson lips, even to her always playful eyes, she exuded sexuality. All of this was only made worse when she smiled earnestly up at you, turning on her charm as she flashed you her pearly whites. "Ready?" She asks, sounding genuinely excited to play with your dick. Now this succubus was about to spend two minutes doing everything in her power to service you. "My dick doesn't stand a chance," is your last thought before wordlessly nodding your head.

Nicole starts the timer as Sarah opens her grinning mouth even wider, leaning forward to wetly kiss your cock. A blowjob, you should have guessed. Sarah licks her way down your cock, drooling liberally over it like she was starving and it was the thick hot sausage she'd been dreaming of all day. You knew from her reputation that Sarah could give some sloppy head, but this seems excessive. Her spit runs down every inch of your erection, flowing down it like a waterfall and spilling over your balls. She brings her hands up and wraps them round your shaft but she just focuses on using them to smear and spread her saliva over every square inch of your cock. When your dick is completely shiny with it's liquid coating Sarah surprisingly pulls away, and begins her real plan. She sits up and rests her big tits on your crotch with a gentle thud, enveloping your shaft instantly in an unimaginable softness. She smiles at the clear surprise on your face and begins to rock up and down, the hot embrace of her tits already driving a grunt of pleasure from your lips.

Tittyfucking. Of course that's Sarah's go-to technique. How could any guy resist a pair of immaculately soft tits like hers. Feeling those pillows moving up and down around your dick you have to suppress your urge to move your hips and fuck them back. Your thoroughly lubed cock glides easily through her cleavage, even when she pushes her tits together tightly. She smiles pleasantly up at you again, like she was having a stimulating conversation with you rather than sandwiching your hard cock between her fat tits. "You're gonna cum for me John." She states, as matter-of-factly as if she was predicting rain. "Do you know why?" You don't answer, but you don't need to. "Because nothing you could ever come up with could feel better than my tits." You wordlessly close your eyes and lean back, knowing that looking at her do her sexy work will only make your dare more difficult. Sarah isn't offended by your seeming lack of acknowledgement. On the contrary, she giggles at you averting your gaze and begins to pump her tits up and down even faster.

Sarah isn't the only one to see your struggle however, and soon you find weakness sensing vultures on both your flanks. "What's wrong John?" Struggling already?" Miranda teases, thoughtlessly tracing circles on your chest with her nails. "Boys are so easy. You give them a nice pair of boobs and they turn into a horny animal so fast." She titters while pushing her own ample chest onto yours a little more heavily. "Come on John, you're not gonna lose so easily right? I know you can do it!" Nicole cheerleads in your other ear, apparently not realizing her lips so close to you are sending goosebumps down your arms and making your task even more difficult.

Your eyes flit open and you whip your head downward again as you feel a hot wetness on the underside of your tip. Sarah has lolled her long tongue out like a landing pad for the head of your cock as it crests through the white waves of her tits. When you catch her eyes she grins like she knew that would get your attention, rolling her tongue twice around the sensitive helmet of your cock before leaning forward and taking it into her mouth again. A tittyfuck and a blowjob, any other time you'd be completely in heaven but right now you feel doomed. Sarah bobs her head on the head of your dick, her tongue wrapping and twisting around it like a snake, all while her velvety boobs stroke your shaft.

You screw your eyes tightly shut this time, practically throwing your head back as you try to think unsexy thoughts. An effort that is made much more difficult by the intercession of the two devils on your shoulders. Miranda brings her face so close to your ear that her lips almost graze your ear lobe. “Oh, what’s the matter John? You look like you’re about to pass out?” She murmurs sweetly, the teasing glee evident in her voice even with your eyes closed. “It’s okay John, you can cum if you want. I won’t be jealous.” Nicole joins in from your other shoulder, her lips going so far as to actually brush your ear. “You know, now I really wish I had boobs like that so I could make you feel this good. Do you want me to do that for you? Next time we hang out I could just cut to the chase, kneel down, and kiss your big fat cock. Is that what you want? Do you want me to be a slut for you?” Nicole murmurs, dirty words you never thought you’d hear from her tripping from her innocent lips into your ear.

At the same time as she murmurs that scandalous filth Miranda is still whispering in your other ear, dirty talk in stereo. “A big dick and lots of stamina, wow.” She says. “Y’know, if you’re man enough to resist Sarah's tits for so long, maybe we should have our own private afterparty sometime to see what else you can endure. Would you like that?” She asks, her question coming at the same time of Nicole’s so perfectly it was like they rehearsed it. You can’t tell if one, both, or neither of them is joking or serious and without thinking Sarah's big tits slamming up and down your shaft make you groan. "Fuck, yes." The words slip through your lips without a thought. Both Miranda and Nicole gasp quietly in delight at your answer before leaning up to kiss you on the cheek from both sides. "Thank you John." They whisper into your ears in sexy unison, making the hairs on your arms stand up. It seems you'll have something else to worry about once this ordeal is over.

Throughout their words Sarah keeps moving on your cock, although even without looking you've noticed a change to her movements. The downside of having such a big cock is that Sarah has found it so easy to fuck the shaft with her incredible tits whilst lavishing your tip with kisses and licks from her practiced mouth. The upside is that your fat cock has made Sarah horny too. Instead of the well practiced licks that would bring you quickly to your knees she simply slobbers on it with her head tilted to one side and her hot bimbo lips pampering your tip. It's almost like she's forgotten the dare entirely and now she's just worshipping your huge fuckstick for real, the sight, taste, and feel of it overriding her better judgement and reducing her to a natural slut. She looks blankly up at you with something like love in her eyes, although this could all be a trick to make you cum. Her tits still pump around your cock and you have no idea how long it's been, even if Sarah has fallen in love with your dick you still might cum and lose.

Sarah's not the only one getting horny, Nicole and Miranda are both practically panting as they lean against you, the surround sound experience of horny girls moaning in your ears makes you dare even more difficult. ASMR was never really your thing but when combined with a perfect tittyfuck from an ideal girl it really starts to wear you down. You try to remove your hands from the girls breasts to instead grip the back of the couch, hoping that sinking your nails into that will help keep your climax at bay, but Miranda stops you. She brings your hand back to her chest and makes you grope her again, adding another pair of soft boobs for you to endure.

As Sarah sucks hard on your tip, a low moan of need reverberating through her body and along your throbbing cock, you wonder how much more you can endure.

Do you do it?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)