Breaking Character

“Oh-ho~.” Riley lets out in reaction to your declaration that you can continue.

You separate from Riley and turn your body towards Erica, so she can see that your cock is still very much erect.

“Now I can see why he comes highly recommended.” Erica says excitedly.

“Ms. Nguyen, kindly help Ms. Bailey to stand up.” You instruct Viv, who stands up from her kneeling position in front of Mercy’s desk to help Erica. Meanwhile, you turn back to Riley and actually hit her on the cheek with your erect cock.

“This night is just full of surprises.” Riley says with a chuckle.

“Do you need help standing up?” You ask her, entirely out of character, but just in genuine concern she might find it difficult to stand up. Unsurprisingly, based on her sit-up from earlier, Riley stands up effortlessly.

“Okay, um… great job, Ms. Vanderhoff. You may take your seat.” You tell her, going back into character.

“You did great too…” Riley whispers near your ear, before giving you a surprise peck on the cheek. “Jay.” She then adds, before walking away from you. At the same time, Viv approaches you just as Riley gets back to her seat.

“Be completely honest,” Viv whispers to you as well. “Did that ‘lap dance’ looking thing she did feel as good as it looked, or were you just timing your nut?” Viv asks you, definitely out of character as well.

“Oh, former. Definitely.” You answer honestly, and maybe a little too quick in your admission.

“I knew it.” Viv says, and you can definitely hear the competitiveness in her tone.

“Hey~, you’ve got nothing to be insecure about.” You assure her, before wrapping your arm around her lower back to make her cling closer to you. “Say the word and I’ll stop this right now and focus on you until you beg me to stop.” You add, sounding like you were exaggerating, but meaning every word.

“What? No~. It’s not that. I’m good! I promise.” Viv assures you, surprised at your concern at first, but unable to hide how pleased she is with it by giving you a kiss on the cheek to assure you. “I just wanted to make sure if that move was all form and no function, ~cuz I am definitely asking her to teach me that shit.” Viv replies, chuckling at her admission.

“Let me guess, you’ll try and make the others jealous with it once you’ve mastered it.” You jokingly ask, and Viv lets out a giddy laugh at your question.

“How do you know me so well already?” Viv asks you with a giddy smile.

“You say that, but I know the real reason you want to learn it is so you can please Daddy.” You jokingly reply, and it gets her to laugh. You make her laugh even harder when you pretend to be disgusted with yourself by calling yourself Daddy.

“I fucking hate how much I can’t stay in character with you.” Viv says, her smile and her eyes just lighting up the room.

“Yeah, you should really practice what you — ow!” You tease her, before she pinches your nipple, making both of you laugh.

“Still, I hope I’m not being a bad sub.” Viv tells you, a hint of guilt in her tone.

“I wouldn’t actually know if you are…” You tell Viv, and her look turns to one of concern as she looks away from you. “And I wouldn’t care if I did.” You then add, before you make her look towards you with your free hand. “All I care about is you being a great girlfriend, and me being the same for you.” You add sweetly.

“You are.” Viv says sweetly. “You’re a great fucking girlfriend.” Viv adds, unable to be sincere for too long.

“You did say you’re a lesbian.” You reply.

“You are so fucking cheesy.” Viv teases you, even rolling her eyes in exaggeration, but the hug she gives you afterwards definitely expresses what she truly feels.

…

“Oh shit! Sorry. I’m really breaking immersion here.” Viv says, breaking away from your hug forcefully, after making her realization.

“Hey don’t mind us, we can get off to rom-coms too.” Erica comments with a teasing look. You see Riley looking spent behind Erica, leaning back on her chair that she’s placed next to Paige’s; who seems to have a more awkward look on her face with her former high school classmate nonchalantly sitting naked next to her.

“I feel like another reminder that school policy does not look favorably on staff intermingling is in order.” Mercy jokingly adds in character.

“Duly noted, Headmistress.” Viv replies, before turning her look towards Erica. “As for you, Ms. Bailey, you’ll pay for that remark.” Viv addresses her in character.

“That’s my line, Ms. Nguyen.” You say, before spanking her ass from behind, making her jolt forward in surprise.

“Apologies, Mr. Craig. I didn’t mean to undermine your authority.” Viv says in character. “Can I make it up to you by making a suggestion on how you should conduct Ms. Bailey’s exam?” Viv then asks.

“You may, Ms. Nguyen.” You reply.

Viv approaches Erica, pausing in front of her for a moment, before walking past her to stand in front of Paige’s desk.

“Ms. Halliwell.” Viv grabs Paige’s attention, even though she already had it based on Paige’s curious stare. “Do you remember the safeword, Headmistress Mercy gave you?” Viv asks her.

“Uh, yeah?” Paige answers.

“If you feel any discomfort with Ms. Bailey’s exam, please be reminded that there will be no issue with you saying it, and we will immediately respect your wishes.” Viv reminds her, getting Paige to nod that she understands. “Good.” Viv says in reaction.

“Over here, Ms. Bailey.” Viv instructs her, and Erica turns around to come up to Viv’s side. “Lean forward and place your hands on Ms. Halliwell’s desk.” Viv instructs her, and Erica does as she’s told without hesitation. “When Mr. Craig starts your exam, Ms. Bailey; you are not to break eye contact with Ms. Halliwell. Is that clear?” Viv instructs her.

“Yes, Ms. Nguyen.” Erica replies.

“Okay. Good.” Viv says, clapping her hands as she does; before grabbing the seat in front of Paige’s desk to place it next to Riley.

“Now, Ms. Vanderhoff.” Viv addresses Riley after sitting next to her, who looks surprised that Viv grabbed her attention.

“Yes, Ms. Nguyen?” Riley asks, sitting up straight while addressing Viv in character.

“You may have gotten the right answer to exam questions, but can you show me your solutions?” Viv asks her, to Riley’s confusion.

“What?” Riley asks.

“Okay, fuck this metaphor.” Viv says in exasperation. “Can you tell me the secret to that body wave thing you did to my boyfriend?” Viv asks her outright.

“Oh! Yeah. Of course.” Riley replies.

“Oh, nice! I thought I’d have to proposition you for it.” Viv jokes, making her and Riley laugh, before Riley starts explaining her move to Viv like they’re having a nice afternoon chat… naked… with the other girl’s face still sort of covered in cum.

You take your phone from the desk and check scores one more time.

- Vandherhoff, Riley - Affection Score: 19 (+2)

Lust Score: 74 (-26)

- Halliwell, Paige - Affection Score: 46 (+3)

Lust Score: 48 (+16)

She’s really close in both! Well, you only really need the Lust Score right now, so you can buy Supportive Parents for Cassie; but if you can get the Friendship Points, then that’s even better, since that means you don’t have to convert points.

- Richards, Mercy - Affection Score: 11 (+4)

Lust Score: 32 (+21)

For how much she’s commented on her interest in a separate session with you and Viv, I guess that’s about right. Enough to verbalize her interest, but not enough to grow impatient and want it now.

Finally, you check Erica’s scores last, as you intend to keep your phone on the desk so you can check her progress as you try to increase her score.

- Bailey, Erica - Affection Score: 11 (+1)

Lust Score: 80 (+29)

Wow. She really does like being treated like an erotic statue.

…

“Oh, sorry. You guys can proceed with that now.” Viv tells you, having thrown out the roleplay entirely with her tone. She may have said it as you were looking at your phone for too long. You look back at the rest of the still engaged audience, and the ass that’s pointing towards you, waiting for its turn.

“Ms. Nguyen, you are still on the clock.” You say commandingly, and it gets Viv to immediately stand up from the chair she was leisurely sitting in while having her conversation with Riley.

“Kindly help clean Ms. Vanderhoff. We can’t let her return home in that state.” You instruct Viv, who smirks at your instruction, as you gesture to her that you’re referring to Riley’s cum-covered face. Viv doesn’t hesitate to sit back down, wrap her arm around Riley’s shoulders, pull her in close, and just lick the cum right off her cheeks, before the two girls exchange a cum-filled kiss, putting on a show for everyone in the room, and finishing it off by showing their cum-coated tongues, then swallowing it all.

“Excellent work, Ms. Nguyen. You may take your break.” You tell her in character. The two girls both give you a wink before returning back to their conversation as if nothing happened.

“As for you Ms. Bailey, your exam is about to begin.” You inform her, placing your hand on her ass that still remains immaculate after all the spanking you’ve been doing today. “You have been informed by Ms. Nguyen of your additional task, and I would advise you to start doing so now.” You tell Erica. By Paige’s sudden change in her demeanor, you can only assume that Erica’s staring right at her.

“Good.” You say, trying to sound threatening. “Blemishing this visage for everyone’s viewing pleasure would be such a shame.” You add to be even more threatening, while doing a light tap on her ass cheek that gets her to actually flinch.

“Paige.” You say in a much softer tone, but Paige still seems to gasp that you’re addressing her. “I know you’ve already sat through a lot, but Viv wasn’t kidding when she said you can call it quits when you feel uncomfortable.” You assure Paige, while you continue massaging Erica’s ass cheek teasingly.

“I know, Mr. Craig.” Paige assures you. “I know I’ve been jumpy, it’s just…” Paige surprisingly starts to admit.

“What is it, Paige?” You ask her, more concerned than curious.

“Would it be weird if I touch myself?” Paige shockingly asks you.

…

“BAHAHAHAHAHAHA!”