Combine your problems

You found yourself already standing in front of Lucy’s room with your mind still in disarray, but you did have the start of a plan as you knocked on the door and waited for her to answer.

“Come to my room with me” you said when you saw her peer through the crack in the door when she opened it.

You didn’t wait for her to answer and were already halfway down the hallway when you heard her door shut behind her. The sound of Lucy’s steps made it clear she was following you and once you got to your bedroom, you waited at the door for her to enter before closing and locking the door behind you.

Lucy stayed silent at the fact that you locked it but she was clearly looking at you for an explanation. You ignored her for a moment and moved to your desk chair to get yourself seated, turning to face her before getting ready to speak.

“Look, neither of us thought that we were gonna be in this position a few hours ago and although I barged in on you earlier I didn’t mean any harm in it. So, here's what I suggest. For a punishment, you have to strip naked” you explained, letting your words hang in the air.

“...That’s it?” Lucy asked expecting more from you.

“Yes and no. I’m not gonna make you do anything else but I want you to sit down with me and help go through some of my problems. The first one was the issue with Grace’s pillow, which I still need to confirm with you but the rest are more ordinary to be honest. Just that you won't be allowed to wear clothes and my bedroom door will be unlocked and open a crack so anyone can come in if they wanted. It's a small punishment but I think it slightly fits the crime. You called Rebecca a slut so you have to dress like one. Or not dressed at all in this case” you explained with a smirk.

Lucy seemed less enthusiastic when you mentioned the chance of people walking in, making her glance at the door a few times but she didn’t seem to have any issues helping you with your problems. Granted, she didn’t know what those were yet but her main concern seemed to be the nudity.

“Well it’s not like I have a choice right?” Lucy replied, starting to strip off.

She definitely had a choice in your eyes and there was nothing stopping her from just ignoring your command entirely but apparently that thought hadn’t crossed her mind. Maybe she was using it to justify her actions but that didn’t matter to you once her t-shirt came off and her bra came into view.

She saw you watching but she didn’t do anything special to spice things up, seemingly treating this like an actual punishment. Her jeans were next as she lowered them from her waist and won her legs. Her ass was hidden from view again as she faced you but this time you were going to make sure you got a good look one way or another.

Lucy gently folded and placed her clothes on the edge of your bed before reaching around to her back to unhook her bra.

“Can’t you turn around or something?” she asked, acting embarrassed, her bra now undone but she kept her hands on her chest to prevent the bra falling to the floor.

“It wouldn’t be much of a punishment if I did. And besides, I’ve seen it all before so why change that now?” you replied, hearing Lucy click her tongue in response.

She still didn’t move with the intent to tease you and she let her bra fall into her hands before placing it with the rest of her clothes, quickly pulling down her panties and lifting her leg to pick them up. Her panties joined the pile and Lucy kept her arms crossed over her chest in a defiant pose, hiding her tits from your view but with you still sat down in your chair, you got the perfect view of her pussy as you stared at her for a few moments.

“So can I sit down now?” she asked, sounding annoyed at being ogled.

“Sure, there's a stool over there” you replied, watching as she turned to get the stool and getting a view of her ass like you knew you would.

You planned to definitely make her next punishment a spanking if you could help it, just to have a more valid excuse to feel her up without her immediately getting angry. You had got a brief feel earlier when you were going down on her but you knew you were getting greedy when you wanted to grope and feel every inch of her and every other one of your subjects.

You let Lucy sit down at your desk before getting up yourself, going back to the door to unlock it and open it slightly. You got to look at your sister’s ass and bare back again as you returned to your chair but you now saw that she had moved her arms into her lap as she got more comfortable, the change letting you stare at her tits once again before you focused back onto the first of the topics you wanted to run by her.

“So first off, Grace didn’t ask me any questions or mention anything when she saw me this morning. I assume she didn’t see the cum on her pillow but I wanted to still ask you about that now. Were you able to tell that there was something when you were trying to sleep last night? Any smell or difference that you noticed?” you questioned, knowing the topic was going to get her more on edge.

“Well, I knew it was already there so I think that skews my answer…” Lucy responded, avoiding answering the question.

“Oh, I can sneak in your room when you're not there and do a test that way? You won’t know if I’ve done anything to your room that way as I could just do nothing.” you said, seeing Lucy pause before she said anything else.

“No I think this was enough. Even though I knew it was there I didn’t really sense it without my face being right next to it. You told me it was under Grace’s pillow so I highly doubt she would know what was there” Lucy explained, a hint of a blush rising on her cheeks as she admitted what she thought.

“Hmmm” you replied, pretending to consider her words for longer than you needed to.

You were already pretty sure Grace hadn’t noticed from her earlier reaction but Lucy’s opinion did give you some extra confidence. You let Lucy sit as you pretended to ponder, dragging it out a little bit longer than you should.

“Fair enough, we can move on then. These topics are a bit more mundane but I still think they’re important. The analogy I have in my head is that Emma is the devil on my shoulder tempting me with her desire to see other women, and I want you to be the angel. The voice of reason.” you explained, your early thoughts being put into words.

“You mentioned me helping you before but I still don’t get what's in it for me?” she asked back.

“Well, you get a bit more control over what goes on around here for starters. I’m not saying I’m gonna accept all of your suggestions but it gives you a chance to speak your mind. Sarah seems to be relying on me a bit more and Mom quickly handed over the punishment role. They trust me for some reason and I’m giving you the chance to be seen in a better light. Plus we can hang out and do something together without me messing it up and doing something perverted for a change” you explained, slipping in a joke to hopefully lighten the mood.

That seemed to do the trick as you saw the beginnings of a smile appear on her face but you had still made her strip naked which was hard for her to ignore.

“So, you still want to help?” you asked again, waiting for her to answer.