A Series of Discussions

Stella and Cassie decided that it would be best to talk about the possibility of seeing each other in a more romantic light when they can do it seriously and privately between the two of them, and decided to table that discussion while you drive Viv and Tanya to work.

Afterwards, you and the girls discussed a few more things. The first one was updating them on all the traits you bought yesterday. They thought it made sense you bought the ‘Life of the Party’ trait, since you’ll be attending a party later tonight.

Stella and Cassie were definitely excited at the idea of getting Seldom Sleepy for themselves, but like you told Brooke earlier, you’re not going to magically help them get a pass and not learn to manage their time properly because they only need four hours of sleep. Promises were made that they’ll use their time responsibly, and they both agreed that if they can get their GPA to a 3.5 and maintain it for the next semester, then you’ll buy it for them once you have the points. Although, if they don’t maintain it once they have it, you’re not above wasting points and taking it away from them.

Healthy Body was something Stella and Cassie were also interested in getting, but you were a bit more adamant in denying that request. Since they were both athletes competing in a sport, you reasoned that it would basically give them an unfair magical advantage which defeats the spirit of competition; and the two girls, thankfully, agreed that there’s a moral issue there that they don’t want to cross. Especially after you told them that “Cheating is still cheating even if you don’t get caught.”, and Stella pretty much stopped arguing for it after that.

You also mentioned to them that you bought the ‘Always Clean’ trait for safety reasons, now that everyone agrees that you’ll be utilizing your hall pass to farm Lust Points soon. Tanya immediately said she’d want that for herself; and explained, after everyone gave her curious looks for her interest in that particular trait, that it’ll save you and her time if you ever want to try with her ‘taking the dirt road’, as she put it. The other girls got a kick out of that answer and had a good laugh at the excited look you had when you realized what it would mean.

As you moved on to the final two traits you had on your wishlist, the four of them pretty much had an idea that you already bought Steadfast Lover after last night; but were a bit surprised that you already bought Normalized Polyamory, since they don’t feel any different. It was the conversation about the benefits of having Normalized Polyamory that led to another topic — sleeping arrangements. Now that there’s no jealousy involved, you thought it would be an easier discussion if your suggestion is a rotation system.

Viv, on the other hand, was ready to just tear down the wall that separates your room and hers, but you remind her that would have to go through a fuck ton of discussions with the Board of the apartment building before being allowed. The others agreed to your suggestion of a rotational system, but Viv countered by suggesting to just add her mattress next to yours and just rearrange your bedroom, which became the consensus solution for now. Although, doing so had to wait as you had to drive Tanya and Viv to work.

Before the three of you left though, you asked them one more thing — how to make your first night with Brooke ‘special’. Stella and Cassie said their suggestion for Tanya’s date could work, but Tanya and Viv suggested not to overthink it. After much discussion, Viv’s suggestion was the surprising unanimous winner from the girls: “Book a hotel room, order a light snack from room service, give her a massage, fuck her brains out, sleep, wake up, fuck her brains out some more.”

“So Cassie likes to cuck Stella!?” Viv asks as soon as everyone closes their doors to your car.

“Is that such a shock after last night?” Tanya asks Viv.

“I mean… yeah, now that you mention it. It makes more sense. I just didn’t expect it from Cassie.” Viv explains her surprise.

“Nobody would expect a kink like that for Chad either. We can’t judge a book by its cover.” You point out to Viv, who just agrees.

“So I have my submissiveness, Cassie has her cucking, Tanya has… a kink to bother her neighbors by being as loud as possible.” Viv jokes, getting a loud “Hey!” from Tanya who’s sitting beside you.

“I’ll get you back for that, V!” Tanya says in fake annoyance.

“I think she’d actually like that.” You joke, pointing out that Viv likes acting bratty to be ‘disciplined’.

“Mierda. Tienes razón.” Tanya reacts, getting Viv to laugh at Tanya’s predicament.

“Please punish me, mommy.” Viv teases Tanya some more.

“Now there’s a kink.” Tanya jokes back.

“Wait, do you actually like being called ‘mommy’, T?” Viv asks back.

“If you are the one calling me ‘mommy’, hell no.” Tanya jokingly answers. “I’m your older sister at best. Cassie and Stella though, I wouldn’t mind.” Tanya more seriously answers.

“What about me, T? How about I start calling you ‘mommy’?” You jokingly ask.

“I already call you papi. It’s only fitting.” Tanya answers back while giving you a wink, and you can’t help but chuckle.

“Why were you listing kinks, Viv?” You ask her.

“Oh, I was just wondering if you have a Bingo card of kinks you were filling out.” Viv jokes, making all three of you laugh.

“It is pretty weird all four of you have unique kinks.” You admit.

“I don’t have one.” Tanya replies.

“I thought being called ‘mommy’ was yours?” You ask Tanya, and she gives a shrug and a “Meh.” in response.

“It’s not really a kink, I can take it or leave it. Liking anal is probably the closest thing to a kink I have, which isn’t saying much.” Tanya answers.

“It’s a kink depending on who you talk to.” Viv chimes in. “If it’s not a common thing to the person you’re talking to, it’s a kink. If it is a common thing for them, they might just consider it a sexual preference.” Viv explains.

“So what you’re saying is, if I’m talking to you, everything’s not a kink and just a preference.” Tanya jokes, making you genuinely laugh; but getting a sarcastic laugh from Viv.

“All kinks are just sexual preferences until you can’t get aroused without them.” Viv explains.

“Can you imagine? Only getting aroused by anal. Your poor douche.” Tanya jokes.

“Well, Copperfield over here eliminates that problem.” Viv jokes, getting you and Tanya to chuckle.

“I guess it becomes one of those ‘philias’ if you can’t get aroused without it, right?” You then ask Viv.

“A fetish, would be more accurate.” Viv replies.

“I thought fetishes are just like kinks?” You ask back.

“Nah. Common misconception. Fetishes aren’t just preference. For it to be considered a fetish, it’s necessary for someone’s sexual arousal.” Viv explains.

“How’d you learn that?” Tanya asks.

“A club member who’s day job was a psychiatrist told me about it when she found out I haven’t had any vanilla sex for years. She asked me if I could only get aroused by being dommed, and I said I wasn’t sure since I haven’t done vanilla for so long. That’s when she explained the difference to me.” Viv shares.

“That actually sounds like what Chad told me about being cucked. He said he was the most aroused when he watches someone he likes being fucked by someone else. Plus, with how **** he is to have that kind of relationship with someone and have it work, it seems like he doesn’t want any other kind of sexual relationship too.” You observe. “That’s borderline a fetish, right?” You ask Viv, who shrugs and just answers, “Probably.”

“Oof… and I thought having an anal fetish sounded bad.” Tanya jokes in reaction.

“Although Stella probably won’t admit it, she’s kinda similar to Chad in the way that she might actually like watching Cassie and I go at it as one of her kinks.” You inform Viv.

“Are you serious!? That’s Stella’s kink?” Viv asks, in amused surprise.

“I thought hers was getting pregnant?” Tanya asks.

“That too.” You reply, getting Viv to laugh boisterously.

“That’s fucking hilarious!” Viv says in reaction. “Stella probably wants to breed you an army of **** babies that you can start dating too when they grow older.” Viv says jokingly, and Tanya laughs at the joke; but you can’t help but get your skin to crawl.

Is that your future?

You mentally slap yourself to focus on the road, and stress over that problem when the time comes. For now, you clarify to Viv what it is exactly that Stella’s kink might be.

“From what Stella told me, she’s not really into the idea of actually getting pregnant, just the risk of it. She doesn’t want to use birth control, or condoms, or have me pull out; just to increase the risk. She assured me that she wants to finish college with Cassie before starting a family; so, for now at least, she’s only really interested in the risk.” You explain.

“Aaah. Then, yeah. That sounds more like a ‘preg risk’ kink than a ‘breeding’ kink.” Viv replies.

“Ay, Dios mio. You sound like the wikipedia for kinks.” Tanya teases Viv.

“A kinkipedia if you will.” Viv rides the joke.

“Wait, before I forget to ask about it, you said Stella could be into being cucked by Cassie?” Tanya asks you.

“I mean, she hasn’t complained or said anything to the contrary. She seems to enjoy it from the few times she’s watched us… so I guess?” You answer Tanya.

“Let me guess, you think that little tidbit is going to help Stella in being open to dating Cassie?” Viv asks Tanya.

“I mean, yeah. I hope it does.” Tanya answers.

“What about you, Jay? What do you think?” Viv asks you.

“I’ve already told them that I wouldn’t mind them dating. Whatever they decide, I’ll support them.” You answer.

“But what are you hoping for?” Viv asks again.

[Minisode] #3: Cassie and Stella define the relationship

“I honestly don’t know what I was hoping for when I said it out loud, Stella.” Cassie answers Stella, after being asked why she suddenly decided to tell Stella about her recurring romantic thoughts about her.

“I keep hearing you in my head to either go all in or keep it in my pants, and after hearing Jay say that he doesn’t mind us doing stuff without him… I just…” Cassie begins to explain, before having trouble finding the words to continue.

“Thought of putting me on the spot to answer it for you?” Stella jokes, making herself and Cassie chuckle. Stella then puts a hand on Cassie’s shoulder and looks her in the eyes.

“Hey.” Stella says sultrily, making both of them stifle laughs. Stella, after having made the atmosphere a little less tense with her Spider-Man reference, takes another deep breath before saying what she wants to say.

“I love you, Cass.” Stella tells her sincerely, and Cassie knows it’s sincere; but Cassie also knows that it’s not the kind of love she sometimes feels for her. “I really and truly mean that.” Stella adds to further emphasize her sincerity.

“But…” Cassie preemptively continues for Stella.

“But I can’t say it the way you want me to say it.” Stella tells her honestly.

“I under—” Cassie immediately replies, before pausing after hearing Stella continue her thought.

“At least not yet.” Stella continues.

“You’re my best friend, my roommate, my teammate, my co-girlfriend… my sister. How much more different would our relationship really be if you and I start dating separate from dating Dad together?” Stella asks Cassie, making both of them smile.

“I honestly don’t know the answer to that question.” Cassie answers.

“But…” Stella playfully continues for Cassie.

“But I’d like to find out.” Cassie finally admits.

“I’d be the biggest hypocrite if I denied us the opportunity to find out.” Stella answers Cassie.

“Why would you be a hypocrite by not wanting to find out? Stella, if that’s what you want to do—” Cassie asks, before getting cut off by Stella.

“That’s not what I mean, Cass! Relax. I just meant…” Stella interjects to get Cassie to stop panicking from misinterpreting what she means. “Remember our talk at the park a couple of weeks ago? When all we were worrying about was how you and Dad could finally be together?” Stella asks Cassie, who nods in response. “Remember what I told you then?” Stella continues.

“Of course I remember. I’ve been repeating it in my head, remember? ‘Go all in or keep it in my pants, there’s no in-between.’” Cassie answers her.

“I’m not talking about that part. I also said that if I’m going to be the only reason preventing you from finding happiness, I’m not being a good friend.” Stella reminds her. “I want you to be happy, Cass. I want us to be happy. Even though I haven’t ever thought of our relationship ever going there… if there’s a chance for us becoming happier from this… then yes.” Stella tells Cassie.

“I want to find out too.”