She does it her way

Looking at Tom's near perfect cock Nicole knew she couldn't deny herself it, but looking at his smug, self-satisfied face she also knew she couldn't give him the satisfaction of getting to use her body like another one of his personal sex toys. This dare was about her and her pleasure after all, if anyone was going to be used in this situation it was Tom. Setting her face and her will in stone she pushes herself quickly to her feet, meeting Tom's arrogant smile with a fiery glare. As she closes the distance between herself and Tom, under the encouraging and apprehensive eyes of Sarah and Miranda, she feels her irritation at him growing with every step. When she's right in front of him she hops bodily on to his lap, her knees straddling his hips and his cock bumping against her flat stomach. He opens his mouth undoubtedly to say something else taunting or cocky but Nicole doesn't let him get a single word out.

Resting her hands on his sculpted chest she lifts her hips, lines herself up and in one rough thrust spears herself on his cock as deep as she can take it. The sudden fullness and the feeling of her virginity being completely destroyed briefly stuns Nicole, taking her breath away. Blinking back brief tears Nicole sees that the unexpected move has had a similar effect on Tom. His eyes have gone wide and his lip trembles as he mumbles "F-fuck." Nicole's wet pussy wrapped tightly like an anaconda around his cock, smothering that typical arrogance right out of him. "Are you alright Nicole?" Miranda's voice came from behind her, full of even more worry than before. Nicole's only response is lifting herself up on Toms lap, almost so the tip of his cock slips from the grip of her pussy, before dropping herself again.

This time Tom's cock seems to sink even deeper into her and the pain is much less noticeable, her body already starting to adjust to being stretched by such a large tool. While lifting herself up to ready another slam on Tom's lap Nicole's hands eagerly caress his well sculpted muscular chest, deciding to take this dare as an opportunity to experience everything his hot body has to offer. "Why does someone so gross have to be so sexy?" She muses, splaying her fingers on his solid abs. Briefly she even considers taking off the gag to kiss him, but she rationalizes that she'll need it to contain her moans that she is certain will be coming sooner rather than later. If you could hear the sounds she was going to make then you'd probably realize she was riding more than just a dildo.

Dropping herself against Tom's pelvis for the third time she notices two things; firstly, that almost all the pain has receded so now Tom's cock only feels good filling her deepest depths and secondly that her hips are now pressed against his, every inch of his huge cock is now inside her. Almost smugly she grinds her hips against him, rubbing it in that she's already taken it all and pleasuring herself in the process. When she goes to lift herself again Tom's hands paw weakly at her waist. "Slow down Nicole." He murmurs, loud enough for everyone else to hear. Lightning fast she grabs his hands with her own and forces them down on the arms of the couch, pinning them with her body weight.

Still holding his arms as leverage she begins to move faster, partly so Tom can't stop her and partly because it feels too good not to. Every time she took Tom's cock all the way inside her it's bulbous tip kissed her womb, sending pink shudders of pleasure through her body. And when she gyrated her hips with the whole length buried inside her she felt his cock along every inch of her channel. She could tell Tom liked it too, although she didn't really care. The way his breathing deepened and his cock throbbed inside her was further proof that she was making him lose control. She was winning. And that thought got her almost as hot as Tom's cock did.

Bouncing rapidly on Tom's dick she could feel an orgasm building inside her, much deeper and larger than the normal ones she felt when she played with herself. Tom's cock pulsing inside her and the almost frightened look in her eyes told her that he was getting close too. Digging her fingernails into his arms she bites down on the gag and resolves to not cum first. Tom was her dildo tonight, but she wanted to prove that she was better than him at the one thing he was good for. It couldn't have been much more than a minute since Nicole had taken Tom inside her when she felt an almighty throb from his cock, followed by thick, hot splashes deep inside her pussy. Savoring the moment she lets go of her control and finally climaxes herself, her body shaking on top of him and her pussy squeezing down on his cock and milking out yet more cum. Powerless from her exertion she falls forward, resting her blonde head on his broad shoulders as one thought crosses her mind.

I won.

After their mutual orgasm there's a lengthy moment of shocked silence. "Well, I guess you've done your dare already Nicole." Sarah says, partly for your benefit as, aside from the sounds of Nicole's breathing and some wet noises you were clueless as to what had happened. "That finished a lot quicker than I expected." Miranda says with a giggle, her double entendre flying effortlessly over your blindfolded head. "Come on guys don't be mean to Nicole, it's her f-, I mean, she's not very experienced." You defend her, catching yourself before needlessly exposing her status as a virgin, although you don't realize you're not quite right anymore. "Yeah it's Nicole's first time." Sarah repeats for emphasis, stifling another laugh as she looks at a shamed Tom. "Quick or not your dare is done Nicole, your turn to draw now." Sarah tells her, sounding slightly bemused as she slides the hat over the table to where Nicole is still on Tom's lap, his limp cock now slipped out of her and her pussy drooling a mix of his and her cum on to his groin. Without standing up she leans back and takes the hat, smirking at Tom again as she looses her gag to speak.