Post-Show Talkback

“Thank you.” Maddy whispers quietly in between sobs.

“It’s not-uh~” You reply to her in a whisper as well, before catching yourself. You were about to say it wasn’t a big deal; but you yourself admit that, as good as your intentions may have been, you still meddled in her family’s affairs unnecessarily.

It’s a big deal to you. What more for the girl in your arms? If she finds your intrusion a good thing, you realize that’s something you should wholly accept instead of downplaying.

“You’re welcome, Maddy.” You whisper to her, rubbing her back to comfort her.

You let Maddy let out whatever emotions she’s feeling on your shoulder, just continuing to rub her back silently as the other girls in the room watch the two of you silently. They give reassuring smiles, and allow Maddy to have this moment with you. You notice Becca leaning towards Viv on the couch. Becca apparently asks Viv regarding Maddy’s family situation. At least, you assume based on the answer Viv gives which was at a more audible volume. The conversation between Becca and Viv probably snaps Maddy out of her emotional state, removing her head from your shoulder, taking a big sniff of snot; before standing up once more.

“I’m sorry for interrupting the discussion. I just…” Maddy started saying, wiping the tears from her eyes. Tanya stands up and gives Maddy a hug from the side. Tanya’s action gets all the other girls, except Becca, to stand up and join them in a group hug to comfort Maddy. You stand up as well and join in.

“Stop being a robot! Get over here!” Viv shouts out to her, getting Becca to immediately stand up and awkwardly join the group hug from the outside. Basically just putting her hands on Viv and Brooke’s lower backs. Viv wraps her arm around Becca to get her into the group hug.

“We understand, Maddy. No need to apologize to us.” Brooke then assures Maddy, once Becca has joined in.

“I’m sorry you had to buy a trait for my messed up family, Mist—” Maddy starts saying before you interrupt her.

“Don’t say sorry for that, Maddy. It was my choice. A choice that I maybe should have involved you in, since it affected you and your family. I actually think I should be the one apologizing for imposing my wishes magically on your family.” You tell her.

“How about neither of us apologize for not doing anything wrong then?” Maddy asks you with a huge smile, her eyes still teary from having cried just a moment ago.

“Deal.” You tell her, returning her smile with one of your own.

“Thanks everyone for this. I just let my emotions get the best of me again.” Maddy says with a chuckle. “I’m good now though. Plus, it’s getting kind of hot in the middle of all of you and I just had a shower.” She adds playfully, and everyone breaks away from the group hug while laughing.

“By the way, that was all of it; right, Dad? Is there anything else we need to tell them about the app?” Stella asks you.

“I don’t think so. I feel like I’ve pretty much covered everything.” You answer her.

“I guess we can call this meeting of ‘people who want to bang Dad’ adjourned!” Stella shouts out.

“Can we please get a better name?” Cassie asks playfully, but with a hint of annoyance.

“I vote for DILF Hunters.” Viv jokingly suggests, resulting in a defeated sigh from Cassie.

“Bit of a downgrade from being called girlfriends, V.” Tanya points out.

“Well, we’re not all that yet!” Viv says defensively.

“Oh! Speaking of, I guess we hold off discussing relationship rules until you guys are all official?” Cassie asks. Maddy smiles at Cassie’s assuredness of that scenario happening in the future.

“There are rules?” Brooke asks.

“Just a few. Main one being ‘don’t do anything to hurt anyone in the relationship’.” Cassie tells them.

“Sounds doable.” Brooke says with a chuckle.

“Oh, what about our scores, Mr. Craig? How are you going to tell us privately?” Maddy asks you.

“I can message your scores individually.” You answer Maddy.

“No, it’s okay. Tell us some other time. I’m not in a particular hurry to find out what your app thinks about my feelings for you.” Maddy replies, and the rest of the girls seem to agree that finding out their scores can wait.

The conversation takes a pause, as all of you aren’t sure how to move forward after the discussion you just had. Since all of you are already standing, it seems like there’s an unspoken consensus to end the discussion here for now.

“If that’s all, I think it’s time I get home. I’m curious what happened with Courtney and Chad tonight. Actually, I need to find out what’s been happening with them, period. She didn’t even tell me she was dating Chad.” Brooke shares with all of you.

“Wait, how did you know that Chad was dating Brooke’s roommate then?” You ask Viv.

“Oh, Brooke introduced me to Courtney when I dropped her off at her place last week.” Viv answers you, explaining how she was able to tell you and the girls that Chad’s date was actually Brooke’s roommate.

“I’m actually past my curfew too. I know magic’s on my side, but best not to **** it. I’m not sure there’s enough magic to counteract Grammy being Grammy.” Maddy jokes; and with that, Brooke and Maddy say their goodbyes to all of you. Noticeably, Becca didn’t say her goodbyes yet.

“I’ll tell Frank to drive you to your place.” Becca tells Brooke.

“Oh! Thanks, Becca, but there’s no need. I can walk it.” Brooke answers her.

“It would really help with my peace of mind if you ride with Becca, Brooke. We’re in a good neighborhood, but the city at this hour…” You encourage her.

“I agree with Jay. Although, you won’t be riding with me. I’m not leaving yet.” Becca informs all of you.

“Do we still need to talk?” Viv asks Becca.

“Yes. I want to speak with both you and Jay privately once more.” Becca answers her. Meanwhile, the rest of the girls encourage Brooke to take Becca’s offer to be chauffeured to her place; which Brooke ultimately accepts. Becca then calls Frank to come up and pick up Brooke. Once Frank arrives, Brooke and Maddy say their goodbyes once more, before finally leaving.

“You want to sleep with us at Jay’s place after your talk, V?” Tanya asks Viv, the three of them preparing to go back to your apartment as well.

“Uh~, depends on how long this talk is going to be, T.” Viv answers Tanya.

“Yeah, how long is this ‘talk’, Becca?” Stella asks Becca while doing air quotes on ‘talk’.

“I would suggest not waiting up.” Becca answers Stella.

“Ugh. Two nights in a row!” Stella says in playful frustration.

“Don’t mind her. She didn’t get to sleep with Jay yesterday. She’s a little antsy.” Cassie tells Becca and Viv.

“Hey! I don’t like the insinuation. I just literally want to sleep next to Dad. Like, Tanya said — best sleep of your life.” Stella says defensively.

“HA! Yeah, right.” Cassie reacts.

“I’ll make sure to cuddle you once I get back, baby. Don’t worry.” You assure your daughter.

“Promise?” Stella asks you, like she’s back to being five years old. You just give her a reassuring nod and it’s enough for her to get a huge excited smile on her face. “Good…” Stella says. “... and you’re putting a baby inside me first thing in the morning — OW!” Stella jokingly adds before Cassie slaps her arm.

“What did I say about the ****?” Stella asks Cassie in annoyance.

“Leave them to it, horndog. Your two day dry spell isn’t as big of a deal as you’re making it seem to be. If you want, just masturbate while Tanya and I do it.” Cassie tells her, to the surprised looks of everyone. Cassie doesn’t budge and instead says good night to Becca and Viv before walking towards the door. “Are you two coming or not?” Cassie asks Tanya and Stella.

“She’s joking.” Tanya says with a chuckle, before giving you a kiss on the cheek and hugging Becca and Viv to say good night; and Stella does the same. “At least I hope she’s joking.” Tanya then adds, before walking with Stella towards the door to leave.

“I don’t know. I might just take what I can get at this point.” You hear Stella say as they open Viv’s door to leave.

“Stella!” Tanya reacts in shock, before closing the door behind them.

“I apologize that I’m taking you away from an eventful evening.” Becca apologizes.

“I’m pretty sure Cassie was just joking.” You assure Becca.

“If she wasn’t, would you feel any jealousy that they’re doing things without you?” Becca asks you. You’re taken aback by the question, as it’s something you haven’t thought of before. Well, you’ve fantasized about it at least. You were usually in the room in your fantasies though.

“I-uh… I haven’t really considered it. Although, I’d be a hypocrite if I said they can’t do stuff with each other even when I’m not there.” You answer Becca.

“I see. So your relationship is polyfidelitous, but you’re allowed to be polyamorous. Quite an interesting configuration. You’re basically allowed a harem.” Becca observes, an amused smile creeping on her lips.

“I know that smile, Becca.” Viv reacts. “Don’t go buying them outfits and collars just yet.” Viv reminds her.

“Wait, what? What does that smile mean?” You ask in disbelief at what you just heard.

“She’s already imagining domming your other girlfriends without you.” Viv says with a chuckle.

“Only if they’re willing, of course.” Becca tells you. For the first time since you’ve seen her, there’s almost excitement breaking her serious demeanor.

“Oh~, uh~... I don’t know the proper etiquette here since we do plan to start dating anyway, but can you not fantasize about fucking my girlfriends in front of me?” You request from Becca. “At least take me out to dinner first.” You add on jokingly.

“About that.” Becca replies, her more serious demeanor back online. You’re about to tell her you were only joking, but she already asks her next question before you could. “There is a charity gala event the company organized this Friday. I invited Vivian, but then we had our fight so I decided to go alone; but with tonight’s developments, I’m hoping that….” Becca starts saying, before pausing, hesitant to complete her invitation. As self-assured as Becca is, it’s quite refreshing to see her nervous like this.

“Oh! Uh~...” You start saying, so that Becca doesn’t have to **** herself with doubt. “If I say yes, you’re not going to start fantasizing about my girlfriends again, are you?” You ask her jokingly, trying to lighten the mood. Before she could reply to your joke and derail you from seriously answering, you continue speaking.

“I’m kidding, Becca. I’m available on Friday. I’d be happy to go with you.” You answer her. Viv seems to be more enthusiastic about it than Becca, letting out giddy noises after hearing your answer.

“Wonderful.” Becca reacts with a shy smile. “By the way, are you able to purchase that polyamory trait by then?” She then adds, taking you by surprise as well.

“I can convert points for it if necessary. Why?” You ask her.

“My father’s going to be there.” Becca answers.

“I just thought it might increase your chances of survival.”