Playing Roles and Staying True

“Knock, knock.” Mercy knocks on the door from inside the room to restart the play they unintentionally interrupted earlier.

As the six of you have now agreed to continue on, Erica and Paige got introduced to each other. After introductions, you all discussed and agreed on the pretense that Paige is going to be a new student and needs to be shown how the school conducts ‘exams’, and that that’s the reason why Mercy and Paige are now going to observe your ‘make-up exam’ for Riley and Erica.

“Headmistress Mercy.” You address her nonchalantly, as Riley has returned to sucking on your cock.

“We’re glad you could join us.” Viv greets them in-character, before going back to licking Erica’s cunt from underneath her.

“I hope we are not interrupting your exams, Mr. Craig.” Mercy addresses you.

“Not at all. Who might this be?” You ask Mercy, referring to Paige, while Riley intentionally shows off to Paige by taking you deeper into her throat than she did before Paige arrived.

“This is a new student, Paige Halliwell.” Mercy answers, introducing Paige to the play.

“Hi. I’m a new student here at… uh… the Red Rum(?)” Paige introduces herself, improving the name of the supposed school you’re all in.

“I’m touring Ms. Halliwell of our facilities when I found that you were conducting a make-up exam after hours. Would you mind if Ms. Halliwell and I observe your examination methods?” Mercy elaborates.

“Of course, Headmistress Richards. You and Paige may take one of the free seats.” You answer, finishing the whole charade to create a pretext within the play for Mercy and Paige to join, and finally being able to get back to focusing on Erica and Riley once Mercy and Paige take their seats.

Speaking of focusing, you remind yourself why you’re doing this whole thing in the first place, and figure out a way to incorporate allowing you to check your phone without raising suspicion.

“As we have the headmistress and a new student here with us, let’s not waste their time and take turns with these exams.” You announce. “Ms. Bailey, please join Ms. Vanderhoff for a joint oral exam.” You direct Erica. Viv stops eating her out, and allows Erica to get down from the desk to join Riley. Erica kneels beside Riley when you get another idea to make the most of Erica’s enjoyment of posing for an audience.

“No, Ms. Bailey. I don’t want you to kneel. I want you to take your exam while standing in front of Ms. Halliwell’s desk, if you please.” You direct Erica, who understands what you’re going for and positions herself right in front of Paige’s desk.

“Wait.” Mercy interjects, before Erica bends forward to get her head to your waist level. As Ms. Halliwell’s a new student, I’d like to confirm with her if her personal space isn’t being violated.” Mercy says, making Erica pause from going towards Paige’s desk.

“What?” Paige asks, not exactly understanding what Mercy means.

“She’s asking if you’re comfortable if my asshole stares at you while Riley and I take our ‘oral exam’.” Erica decodes for Paige.

“Oh! I mean, yeah. Okay. Of course. I’m just a fly on the wall, remember?” Paige answers with an awkward chuckle, getting a chuckle out of Erica as well.

“Understood, Ms. Halliwell. If you ever feel any discomfort, you can say ‘Alice Cooper’ and I’ll relieve you from this situation immediately.” Mercy assures her, doing so in character, but also still sounding genuinely concerned for Paige’s comfort with the situation she now finds herself in; which is, honestly, more thought about Paige’s well-being than what you’ve shown.

‘Shit. Are you turning into an asshole?’ You ask yourself, just as Riley lowers her hardworking mouth to sucking on your balls.

Not the time, doofus.

Erica takes Paige’s answer as enough consent though, and rests her ass cheeks on the desk first, before bending forward to get her head at your waist level, while keeping her legs straight. You can see the curvature of her ass that leads to her smooth back from this angle, and you can only imagine what Paige is seeing from her end.

Erica takes a hold of your cock with her hand, as Riley continues to massage your balls with her tongue. Erica licks the underside of your dick from shaft to tip, flicking the tip of her tongue teasingly on the tip of your dick. Meanwhile, you instruct Viv to get your phone from the table so you can check the progress of their scores.

“As the two of you are now taking the oral exam as a pair, I’m giving both of you ten minutes to finish. Failure results in severe consequences.” You warn Erica and Riley, giving them the pretext that you’re using your phone as a timer, while checking out their scores. You actually do open up a timer, and get Viv to check if she still sees the timer when you switch to the app, which she confirms is the case.

- Vandherhoff, Riley - Affection Score: 15 (+1)

Lust Score: 48 (+26)

- Bailey, Erica - Affection Score: 5 (+2)

Lust Score: 27 (+23)

- Halliwell, Paige - Affection Score: 43 (+8)

Lust Score: 20 (+5)

- Richards, Mercy - Affection Score: 1 (+1)

Lust Score: 6 (+6)

“Are these two slutty truants doing well on their oral exam, Mr. Craig? What scores would you give them?” Viv asks next to you, cleverly coding her words. You give her an impressed smile, and a kiss to say you enjoy the wit she displayed there.

“Right now, both of them are barely even close to half of the scores they need.” You answer Viv; which, funnily enough, gets Erica and Riley to take a step-up in their head game.

The two girls now start to share the head of your cock, embracing it from all sides with their lips, while their tongues flick underneath your shaft. Both of them have their nails tease the skin of your balls as well, before Riley spits on your shaft, which Erica then laps up right after.

As the two girls start giving it their all, you can’t help but look at your audience. Mercy is expressionless, but seems to be sticking to her word that she’s going to evaluate your performance as a dom, as her eyes aren’t really focused on anyone else but you. Paige, on the other hand, is trying (but ultimately failing) to look anywhere else that doesn’t involve seeing someone naked or doing a sexual act. Her eyes keep going back to the ass in front of her desk though, and can’t seem to take her eye away from it once she notices something.

“Is it extra credit if Erica undergoes a rectal exam?” Paige asks jokingly, trying to sound more confident than what her embarrassed demeanor belies.

“I’m not puckering it for no reason.” Erica jokes back, momentarily taking your cock out of her mouth, only to get back to it once again.

“I think that answer is a good reminder to refrain from making joking statements you might regret, Ms. Halliwell.” Mercy reminds Paige with a playful smirk. “I’m sure Ms. Bailey would have still said yes even if she thought you were being serious.” Mercy explains, getting Paige to blush and look away.

“Ms. Bailey definitely thought you were serious.” Viv adds on teasingly. Erica does a moaning ‘mm-hmm’ to confirm Viv and Mercy’s assumptions, your cock inside her mouth, while wiggling her ass on the desk to tease Paige.

Paige bulges her eyes in awe, blushing as she does, as she can’t help but stare into Erica’s nether region while it stares right back at her. You actually have to stifle a chuckle as Paige’s look of embarrassment is actually pretty comedic.

“Enjoying the view, Paige?” You teasingly ask her, unable to not comment after your chuckle grabs Paige’s attention away from Erica’s crotch.

“Uh~…” Paige mutters in confusion.

“Aw~... what happened to my confident noodle, huh?” Viv asks her, seemingly breaking character to tease Paige.

“What?” Paige asks in confusion.

Viv rests her elbow on Paige’s desk, taking the remaining width of the table that isn’t occupied by Erica’s ass, and rests her chin on her hand. Viv is basically mirroring Erica’s pose, but with her butt facing your direction. You can’t see Viv’s pussy or asshole like Paige probably can with Erica’s, but you do see that Viv’s ass cheek is still pretty red from the spanking earlier; and like a bull seeing red, you give her a spank just because.

*SPANK*

“Ooh~, Daddy.” Viv moans. “Harder.” She seductively adds.

*SPANK!*

“What happened to staying in character, Ms. Nguyen?” You teasingly ask your girlfriend.

“I’m sorry, Mr. Craig. I just wanted to show the new student that this… is… all… just…” Viv seductively answers you, inching her face closer and closer to Paige as if they’re playing gay chicken like back in Viv’s restaurant the first time the of you got reacquainted. “Play.” Viv finally adds, and from your angle, their foreheads are definitely touching.

“Are the waters hot enough for my little noodle?” Viv teasingly asks, waiting a moment for Paige to answer, before breaking away from Paige with a confident smirk across her lips.

*SPANK!*

“That’s not how you should be speaking to our students, Ms. Nguyen.” You remind her, before wrapping your arm around her waist and have her forcefully cling to your body. She’s so light that you’ve picked her off her feet. Viv can’t hide her smile, as she seems to enjoy you suddenly manhandling her like this.

“But Daddy~” Viv teasingly groaned like a child. Although, she stares you eye-to-eye with a look of admiration, her smile undeniably one of happiness as well. “I can’t hide our love any longer.” Viv then jokes, her happy smile cracking into stifled laughter.

“Aww~, you guys are cute.” Erica comments, while she jerks you off with her hand.

“You only have a few minutes left on your exam, ladies. I suggest you truly give it your all if you want me to finish.” You remind them.

“He means ‘if you want to finish your exams on time’.” Viv corrects your slip up.

Riley takes that as a cue to grab Erica’s hair close to the scalp, before pushing Erica’s head further down your cock, she holds it there for a while, before finally gagging and being pulled back by Riley. Once Erica catches her breath, and spits out the extra saliva that’s collected inside her mouth due to gagging back to your cock, Riley repeats the process and pushes Erica’s head back to deepthroat you once more.

“Office entanglements are against school policy, you two.” Mercy suddenly chimes in. “We’ll have to have a closed door meeting to discuss your punishments.” Mercy adds.

“Just tell us when, Headmistress.” Viv replies to Mercy with a wink, before going back to looking at your eyes.

You notice how much attention she’s giving your eyes, and even though she has a happy smile on her face, you realize that she may hoping for something sexual to do. It then dawns on you that Viv has hang ups with her previous relationship with Celeste and her boyfriend because she felt underappreciated somewhat. More than that, you told her right before entering this club, that if she ever feels anxious about underperforming, she should look you in the eyes. Were Viv’s interactions with Paige just to grab your attention… or maybe, to remind you that she’s still part of this roleplay?

The suddenness of the realization apparently makes you subconsciously do a look that says just that, and it gets Viv’s attention.

“What?” She asks you.

“I got you, V.” You tell her sweetly, and her eyes light up, after hearing you say those words. “I got you.” You repeat, just to assure her that she didn’t mishear what you said. She palms your cheek softly, before giving you a passionate and loving kiss on the lips.

*Bi-bi-beep! Bi-bi-beep!*

Your phone alarm rings off, snapping you and Viv out of your own little world from the kiss, as it signals that the girls’ oral exam time is over; and that you and Viv have a duty as ‘educators’ to discipline them.

Viv gives you a loving look as your lips part, before giving you a nod that you understand as one of assurance that she’s not feeling insecure anymore. You give her the same nod, before kissing her on the forehead, taking a deep breath as you do to get your mind back to focusing on getting Erica and Riley’s scores up.

“Time’s up ladies.” You tell them, as you turn off the alarm, while also checking their scores one more time.

- Vandherhoff, Riley - Affection Score: 17 (+2)

Lust Score: 63 (+15)

+50 Lust Points. Total: 250 (For reaching the 50+ Lust Score goal with a person)

- Bailey, Erica - Affection Score: 10 (+5)

Lust Score: 51 (+24)

+50 Lust Points. Total: 300 (For reaching the 50+ Lust Score goal with a person)

- Halliwell, Paige - Affection Score: 43 (+8)

Lust Score: 32 (+12)

- Richards, Mercy - Affection Score: 7 (+6)

Lust Score: 11 (+5)

Riley doesn’t seem to care, and instead forcefully bobs Erica on your cock out of desperation. The open defiance to the time limit you set, gets Viv to show initiative and grab Riley by the hair as well, before pulling her by the scalp to make the younger girl look at her from below.

“Pencil’s down, Whorelei.” Viv tells her commandingly, and you can’t help but smirk at Viv’s show of authority. Riley lets go of Erica’s head after that, and Erica lets out long gasps for air after the **** on her throat that Riley **** on her.

“Thank you, Ms. Nguyen.” You tell her with a playful wink.

“Now…” You say menacingly to Riley, before pulling on the tail of her tie to undo it. You hand the tie to Viv, your smile towards Riley a diabolical one, as you can picture exactly what you want to do to her as punishment.

“Please tie Ms. Vanderhoff’s undisciplined hands behind her back, Ms. Nguyen.” You tell Viv, before tugging on Erica’s tie as well.

“Stand up, Ms. Vanderhoff.” You command her, and Viv helps her up once she finishes tying Riley’s wrists behind her back. You take Erica’s tie and place it on her neck as if you’re going to tie it; but you pull on it instead, with both ends in your hand as you walk back towards the teacher’s desk, forcing her to follow you.

You then pull on the tail of the tie to remove it from her neck once you’ve reached the teacher’s desk, and walk back to Viv to hand her Erica’s tie; instructing her to tie Erica’s wrists as well.

You then make your way back to Riley, and whisper to her ear, “Bend over the table, Riley.” You refer to her by her first name just so she knows you’re talking to her, and not just her schoolgirl character.

Riley places her waist to the edge of the desk, before bending forward to rest her head and upper body on the desk, while her ass sticks out on the edge. You bend forward as well, and place your lips close to her ears.

“I’m going to make that fantasy you told me about a reality.”

*SPANK!!*